Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 July 2007

M-payments could be backbone of banking in emerging economies

Mobile payments and banking have so far made limited progress in most countries, with Japan the most prominent exception. Many factors are responsible for this – security fears, user resistance or apathy, poor interfaces, a failure by operators and banks to coordinate their efforts. But as in the mobile content world, there is a rising perception that, while the expectations of uptake in the developed nations may have been overblown, there could be a huge opportunity waiting in emerging economies, where traditional banking and payment infrastructure is often inadequate. But also as in content, this will require the rapid development of new devices and user interfaces to make the services cheap and simple to use, and will entail a closer cooperation between operators and financial service providers – a cooperation that could also transform another aspect of the mobile value chain.

In the content and media sectors, the relationship between content owners and wireless providers has often been uneasy, with each wanting the upper hand in the chain, in terms of branding and profit share. The same debates will have to be conducted in the banking arena, though they may be offset by the clear benefit in partners pooling resources to launch mobile payments facilities – not just on the equipment side, but in the marketing that will be essential to convince many users to adopt the functionality.

‘Despite many initiatives and projects undertaken to develop mobile payment solutions, nothing compelling has emerged, until now,’ said Cees de Jong, senior vice president of global markets development at consultancy Atos Origin, which has a practise in mobile payments. ‘Thanks to technological advances and new regulations, the time is now right. Consumers are changing in their attitude to what a mobile phone can do, and mobile phones are changing to make those things easy to do.”

However, he points out that the opportunity is not for the cellcos alone, but will lead to a far more complex value chain than they are used to dealing with, including internet giants like Microsoft, banks and new entrants.

In the short term, remote payments are focusing mainly on online bill paying or funds transfer, purchase of specifically mobile services such as ringtones or prepaid credit top-ups, and there is a limited shift to mobile point of sale systems, using the cellphone or other device for contactless payment. As near field communication (NFC) technology converges with cellphones, the handset could become the default device for any payments that can be carried out using a swipe mechanism, such as purchasing transport tickets.

While the main initiative needs to come from the financial institutions and carriers – which can invest in the required systems and on marketing and customer awareness – there is also a need for policy makers to act to accelerate uptake, especially in emerging nations. This is certainly the view of some of the major players, and last week Vodafone, in association with Nokia and its half-brother Nokia Siemens Networks, published a report that puts pressure on governments and regulators to act.

The report, produced by Frontier Economics and Groupe d’Economie Mondiale as well as consultants to the World Bank, claims a lack of access to banking services is currently forcing people in many nations to rely on a cash-based economy with inadequate security, which leads to an informal labor market and lower tax revenue for governments. Where infrastructure for traditional banking services is limited, the mobile phone – the most commonly owned electronic device in all but the poorest areas – could provide the most commercial and practical route.

Alan Harper, director of group strategy for Vodafone Group, said in a statement: “The case for mobile transactions has been well proven by recent pilots. In a country such as Kenya there are 400 bank branches, 600 ATMs and 10m mobile phones. There is clearly the potential to bring access to finance for hundreds of thousands of individuals for the very first time. However, there is also an increasing need to ensure that current banking regulations do not undermine or limit this growing potential.”

Most importantly, the report authors believe that mobile transactions must not be shoehorned into existing retail banking regulatory structures as this will involve high fixed costs and “significant compliance problems”.

However, given the slow pace of most regulators, and the lack of coordination between these bodies across large regions of the world – most significantly Africa – there need to practical solutions with more immediate impact, and again, this will come back to the operators working closely with the banking community. Industry associations such as the Open Mobile Association’s Mobile Payments group – which seeks to standardize processes and therefore make them more available at low cost – and the GSM Assocation’s Mobile Money Transfer initiative, can also carry significant weight, especially by helping to coordinate operator efforts. A GSMA internal study of 20 countries showed that the main regulatory barriers for mobile operators targeting the ‘unbanked’ are focused on rules against money laundering, as well as the difficulty in identifying and understanding the potential customers.

Technological advances are also still needed. Though there has been a great deal of progress on mobile and contactless payments platforms in the past few years, several industry alliances have foundered and there has been a slow move to standardization in many areas. The greatest hopes in terms of the front end mechanism rest with combining NFC with mobile handsets, and achieving a single platform for this ultra-short range technology round the world. A step in this direction was seen at February’s 3GSM conference, when 14 mobile operators teamed up to create a standard payment system based on NFC, christened ‘Pay-Buy Mobile’. Among the backers are AT&T and China Mobile, and the aim is to support interoperability between suppliers’ equipment and financial companies.

This work complements that of the NFC Forum, which takes care of the radio communications standards to facilitate mobile payment, but not the logistical structure of managing financial transactions. The operators’ initiative will adopt the structure mapped out by the GSMA in 2006.

While the operators are keen to embrace mobile payments as a way to generate new services for their high speed networks, and attract and retain customers, there remains the problem familiar from mobile content – how to turn all this activity into a profitable revenue stream, particularly if m-payments will require updated (subsidized) handsets with NFC facilities. The role model is NTT DoCoMo in Japan, the country where the FeliCa proximity payment system is already widely used. This allows customers to install the EDY ‘mobile wallet’ system onto their phones and pay for small purchases, such as public transport tickets, by waving their handsets over a sensor. FeliCa handsets are now sold by all the Japanese networks, though NTT DoCoMo was the driving force behind it.

However, DoCoMo generates a strong revenue stream because its parent company is also active in mainstream banking, and so its mobile network can act as a new channel to market for existing services. Most cellcos will have to partner with a separate financial institution, making the commercial case less clear. For the handset makers, though, this may be another chance to implement a relatively low cost new technology in phones and so drive another upgrade cycle. Nokia has offered NFC handsets for some months now, and earlier this year, Motorola took the lead role in a new pan-European consortium formed to develop an open architecture for the development, deployment and use of NFC in handsets (the group’s project is called ‘Store Logistics and Payment with NFC’ or StoLPaN.

The major efforts in NFC to date have been spearheaded by Sony and Philips, whose de facto standard gained significant backing in 2004-5, notably from Nokia and Samsung, which conducted trials with Mastercard and Visa. While Samsung has focused on mobile content functions, most projects have been centered on mobile payments, with NTT DoCoMo the first to launch commercial services in this area based on NFC. The Sony-Philips platform emerged from a project called Mifare within the Dutch company, which was then combined with Sony technology.