Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 July 2007

Operator RFPs for femtocells gather pace as attention shifts to gateways

Consumer Wi-Fi vendor Netgear’s announcement of a femtocell gateway earlier this month highlighted a new opportunity for the makers of these tiny indoor base stations, and with Nokia Siemens (NSN) talking up a similar device, the floodgates may be about to open, especially as major operators start to issue their RFPs with an eye to accelerating quad play services to the home.

Netgear is working with femtocell specialist Ubiquisys on a gateway that will incorporate a miniature 3G base station with a Wi-Fi/VoIP/DSL device (see Wireless Watch July 2 2007). NSN’s product is being created together with home gateway supplier Thomson, which will integrate the Finnish-German giant’s 3G Femto Home Access product in an existing residential gateway design. Such devices will support enhanced mobile access within the homezone, potentially with flat rate tariffs, reducing the need to use Wi-Fi for low cost voice and data. By combining with a gateway, the Wi-Fi can be used for in-home media networking, and the DSL for backhaul for both wireless systems (a future product incorporating WiMAX, as envisaged by Motorola and others, could do away with the need for this DSL function, supporting a wireless-only quad play operator).

Alcatel-Lucent insiders acknowledged that the company will also announce a similar product soon, no doubt with an eye on France Telecom’s impending femtocell and quad play roll-outs, and also its ongoing trial with Japan’s Softbank. The focus of that trial is Femto Base Station Router, based on the former Lucent BSR platform and designed to work with that collapsed base station architecture. Softbank is an enthusiastic adopter of emerging technologies in its bid to bridge the gap between its service, acquired from Vodafone, and leaders DoCoMo and KDDI. It has turned to Alcatel-Lucent for a 3G network upgrade that relies heavily on enhancing indoor coverage through femtocells.
A gateway product could well created in partnership with 2Wire, whose residential units AT&T uses for its satellite/DSL Homezone services, and in which Alcatel-Lucent has a stake; although French reporters have also pointed to a deal with another CPE partner, France’s Sagem.

Also involved in the SoftBank trials is UK-based ip.access with its Oyster3G product, and the femtocell was used in a recent proof of concept that showed mobile voice, video and data calls using the femtocell to provide a 3G signal directly within the home, together with plug-and-play installation and configuration.

Sprint Nextel’s and Vodafone’s RFPs for femtocells have attracted early attention, but are now being followed by a rush of requests from operators, many of which plan to start deployment in mid-2008. Some are more cautious – France Telecom is about to issue its own RFP, having taken an active interest in femtocells for well over a year, but says it sees the technology being “well off mass deployment”, by which sources said they meant no major roll-out until the end of next year. One obstacle for FT, which will not apply to all carriers, is restrictions on the 3G license terms, which may limit how far a cellco can retail femtocells or other carrier-controlled consumer equipment. In France, for instance, the regulator must be notified every time a Node B (including a femtocell) is added to the network. Apart from some niche applications among heavy data users such as enterprises, FT is primarily interested in femtocells as part of its IMS roll-out strategy, which will move to its mainstream in 2009. In the mean time, its convergence offerings, such as Orange Unik, will remain heavily oriented to UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access), running over Wi-Fi, while fellow French operator SFR (part-owned by Vodafone) is likely to be the first commercial deployer of femtocells in the country.

Vodafone is set to be far more aggressive in deployment, reflecting its always wary attitude to Wi-Fi as an operator network, and its need to move hurriedly to some form of quad play even where it does not have wireline networks. It will also be keen to take a driving seat in the emergence of femtocell platforms, helping to mould standards rather than being a market follower – a trait it will have in common with Sprint Nextel. Unwilling to lose the market advantage its early RFP could have brought it, Vodafone is now expected to accelerate its commercial trials and roll-out to stay ahead of the converged operators with which it needs to hold its ground – particularly FT and Deutsche Telekom.

Airvana’s IPO plan:

Coming into the femtocell space from the CDMA side is Airvana, which recently acquired the UK’s 3WayNetworks and now aims to raise up to $83m in an IPO on the Nasdaq exchange.

In documents filed with the SEC last week, the company said it will sell 8.3m shares of common stock priced between $8 and $10. The float is being underwritten by Deutsche Bank, Lehman Brothers, Morgan Stanley and UBS Investment Bank.

Airvana’s core business is in EV-DO equipment, OEMd by Nortel and Alcatel-Lucent, but it is moving sideways into fixed-mobile convergence and femtocells in order to reduce its dependence on CDMA and penetrate the UMTS sector. In the first quarter of fiscal 2007, the company reported an operating loss of $21.5m on revenue of $0.3m. Revenue for full year 2006 was $170.3m with operating income of $57.1m.

UMA growth:

Despite the rising interest in femtocells, the UMA technology remains in growth mode, primarily supporting Wi-Fi/cellular hand-off – though it can also be used as an interface for 3G femtocells too. UMA subscribers are due to reach 65m by 2012, according to a new report from ABI Research.

‘Until recently, proponents of competing fixed/mobile convergence solutions frequently cited the fact that UMA was only usable with 2G or enhanced 2G cellular services,’ said principal analyst Philip Solis. ‘But recently, the UMA client software has received an upgrade that will allow it to work with 3G handsets and services, offering another mobile broadband fixed/mobile convergence option that will be viable for some time to come.’