The disintegration of the Wintel alliance that has been the backbone of the PC industry has been on the cards in the very different mobile world, and the biggest potential split between Microsoft and Intel is now heralded by a new project focusing on 3G-enabled laptops. The GSM Association has recruited Microsoft to work on a global research program to determine consumer user trends and the mass market potential of notebook PCs with embedded cellular broadband. This will be a direct blow to the Intel-inspired camp that believes Wi-Fi and WiMAX, with their open IP heritage, are more suited to the mobile data world, and particularly to the notebook platform, than 3G.
Microsoft has been a major supporter of Wi-Fi but has been surprisingly reticent about WiMAX, considering its usual enthusiasm for any technology that will increase usage of Windows-based devices. Widely available wireless internet access is clearly a key driver for that usage, but Microsoft has found it hard to break into the cellphone base in any force, and now faces the danger of the successor to the notebook – the Ultra-Mobile PC or other similar formats – adopting Linux more commonly than Windows. The GSMA work looks like a bid to increase its influence on an increasingly hostile mobile world, regardless of the impact on Intel’s plans for notebook WiMAX.
Through the GSMA, 13 mobile operators will participate in the research, including main survey sponsor Telef’nica, AT&T Mobility, China Mobile, DTAC, Maxis, MTN, Orange, SingTel, Smart Communications, TeliaSonera, Turkcell, Vodafone and Wind. This could be the first major offensive from cellular against both established Wi-Fi and emerging WiMAX, and if Microsoft feels it can sway the market by bundling drivers and support software into laptops, it would be in a strong position to ask these cellular operators for a tiny slice of their extra ARPU cake from broadband wireless.
Microsoft has always felt it has the right to be a technology powerbroker on the PC, and in cellular broadband it may well step in, putting it at the throat of its old partner Intel. Not that the results of the survey are likely to be a surprise – the cost structures of UMTS and HSPA have been a deterrent to use of 3G in laptops, where Wi-Fi has offered a more appealing flat rate model. One tier one mobile operator confided in us at the WiMAX World Europe show in Vienna: ‘It just gives us an opportunity to pay $100 per laptop, with much of it going to pay for intellectual property at equipment suppliers such as Qualcomm. Users refuse to take that cost on, so operators have to subsidize these 3G cards. Why would we not offer a WiMAX network instead and eliminate $60 of upfront IPR cost?’
The cellcos will find from their research that they will need fixed rate, all you can eat, low priced services, which also don’t cost the PC card marker an arm and a leg in intellectual property costs. At this stage, their networks will be able to compete with Wi-Fi and WiMAX on the basis of greater availability, though lower average speeds.
If Microsoft steps into this argument, on the back of a positive survey, it would do so without Intel backing it, but it may still put a powerful argument to Dell, HP and other PC makers for PC-style techniques such as ‘bundled’ cards and a free trial period, which might help sway the market. Some companies, including Dell, already offer bundled 3G card/carrier contract options with some notebooks, alongside Wi-Fi. For now, Microsoft is just feeling its way, with a global study and field trials, but going forwards it threatens to intervene in what is becoming one of the great broadband debates, that of the right technology for personal broadband – and its weight could help stall the market between the two major approaches.
‘Microsoft’s customers are increasingly looking for the mobility and ubiquitous connectivity that mobile broadband HSPA networks can provide worldwide today,’ said Will Poole, corporate vice president of the Market Expansion Group at Microsoft. ‘We are excited to be working with the GSMA’s mobile operator community to find ways to enable every Windows Vista customer to enjoy mobile broadband, whether they own the most economical entry level notebook or the highest end model.’ Wasn’t that the speech Microsoft was meant to make about WiMAX?
Intel and 3G laptops:
Despite its aim of controlling the mobile internet platform by making WiMAX the major connection for personal broadband, Intel knows that it will be impossible to keep 3G and HSPA out in many territories. It even formed a partnership with Nokia to develop HSDPA modules for laptops, but dissolve this in February (see Wireless Watch February 12 2007) in a move that highlighted the conflicts of interest it faces in the area of the 3G PC.
Nokia said there was an “inadequate business case” for the joint development, but the conflicts were clear. Nokia is taking on Intel’s Ultra-Mobile PC architecture directly with its Wi-Fi/Linux Internet Tablet. While there are many reasons why the two should ignore hardware competition and collaborate rather than compete (see Wireless Watch April 23 2007), in the meantime, both will need new partners. Nokia will want to play in any wireless notebook segment, regardless of radio, while Intel cannot ignore 3G and may be looking among the specialist chipmakers, such as Icera, or card manufacturers like Sierra Wireless and Novatel, both of which will be very relieved by the disappearance of the Intel-Nokia threat.