Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 June 2007

Qualcomm could waste its huge 3G chances with lawsuit intransigence

Qualcomm suffered another setback in the courtroom last week, as Broadcom was awarded $19.64m in damages over the CDMA giant incorporating Broadcom technology in its baseband chips and software. Meanwhile, Nokia launched its first patents countersuit in its year-long and multi-fronted legal battle with Qualcomm, and warned that the dispute is threatening to slow down the whole W-CDMA market – one in which it is increasingly clear that Qualcomm stands to be one of the major beneficiaries.

The Broadcom award came from a jury trial in the US District Court in Santa Ana, California, which also found that three Broadcom patents are valid and that Qualcomm’s infringement was wilful, allowing the court to increase the damages up to three times the amount awarded by the jury. Broadcom will now ask the court for an injunction barring Qualcomm from further infringement of the three patents.

The first of the three patents relates to a single chip being able to talk to two separate wireless networks, and the jury found that Qualcomm used the multimode invention in its EV-DO baseband chips. The second relates to a particular chip architecture for video processing, which the jury found Qualcomm used on its enhanced multimedia chip platforms. The final patent describes how the same chip can work on both fixed and variable bandwidth networks, as embedded in Qualcomm’s Qchat push to talk software, according to the findings. Qualcomm’s stock fell 2%, on fears that its negotiating position with Broadcom is now fatally wounded, and that there is no clear workaround for the three patents at issue – unlike in an earlier ITC case related to power saving (see below), in which Qualcomm says it is already close to a reworking of its products to avoid the debated IPR.

Despite settling some claims out of court last fall, Qualcomm has suffered a string of defeats in its ongoing battle with Broadcom. In December the US International Trade Commission (ITC) found that Qualcomm’s 3G cellular baseband chips infringe a Broadcom patent related to power saving technology. A decision on the remedy for that infringement is due on June 7, though it is expected that the court will delay ruling on an injunction for one to two months, which would give Qualcomm time to complete its workaround. Speaking at a recent investor conference Qualcomm COO Sanjay Jha said that he did not believe it would make sense for customers to adjust inventory in anticipation of the decision, and said the company still views CDMA inventory levels “at the higher end of 15 to 20 weeks”.

Then, in January, a court threw out a complaint by Qualcomm which claimed that Broadcom was improperly using patents which are embedded in the H.264 codec standard. That court found Qualcomm had waived its right to enforce the patents by the simple act of never mentioning the patents to the relevant standards body, and that decision could also backfire on Qualcomm further when that court considers remedies for that omission in June. H.264 technology is at the heart of devices like iPods, DVRs, set tops, DVD players and video-enabled cellular handsets and Qualcomm was the only IPR holder not to sign up to the patent pool.

Broadcom has also accused Qualcomm of concealing 35,000 documents that Broadcom says would have proven the CDMA giant was lying during the January H.264 trial. The latest shot came just after Broadcom’s victory last Tuesday. Qualcomm denied it had concealed documents and said the failure to find them was “inadvertent and not done in bad faith”.

Broadcom has been more successful in one-off court actions than in some broader complaints it has brought alleging antitrust and business malpractise by its rival. One of these failed in the US, though it is being appealed, and another is still under review in Korea, while Broadcom has also supported a complaint brought to the European Union by Ericsson, Nokia and others – the action that it seems Qualcomm takes the most seriously, and which has provoked its CEO Paul Jacobs to say he would spin off the IPR business if that became necessary to placate the EU. This would enable the company to retain its interest in intellectual property, without it touching its own stock market valuation.

On Broadcom’s part, the smaller chipmaker is determined to repeat its success in WLan and other markets in the W-CDMA arena, particularly leveraging its strengths in multimode handset platforms, an area in which Qualcomm also excels. Broadcom is concerned that its antagonist will assert a similar IPR stranglehold in W-CDMA as it has in CDMA2000 and so limit the opportunities for competition from newer entrants.

In essence the tide is turning against Qualcomm’s IPR practises and its peculiar approach of licensing all or none of its technologies together in a single agreement, often at rates five or six times those of other patents that are considered essential in the same process.

However, while all of these court cases give rise to a lot of negative pressure on Qualcomm’s share price, the company continues to perform admirably in its financial results, despite putting aside $200m to fight court cases. This is mostly due to its ability to infiltrate new markets, such as HSPA, at an early stage, by getting chip architectures working more rapidly than its rivals and focusing on high levels of integration. But of course, its ability to compete effectively as a chipmaker even without its IPR bargaining chips will start to put new pressure on Qualcomm to separate its semiconductor and patent activities more clearly. The chip revenues are considerably larger, though less profitable, than the IPR revenues, and Qualcomm has valuable headstarts in W-CDMA and HSPA technologies that it cannot afford to relinquish by slowing down the market through the negative impact of the lawsuits.

In this respect, the fights with Nokia are far more significant than those with Broadcom, since they cast doubt over the whole issue of future handset pricing, and whether there will be any interruptions in supply of products from the largest phonemaker. They also stand to set important precedents for Qualcomm’s patent negotiations with other manufacturers as current agreements come up for renewal. And Nokia is playing hard on the argument that, by refusing to compromise on W-CDMA royalties, Qualcomm is holding back the market and therefore shooting its own chip business in the foot.

Last week, the Finnish giant’s chief technology officer Tero Ojanpera warned that the dispute was leaving a door open for rival technologies such as WiMAX. “This whole discussion might have an impact on 3G technology,” he said, adding that other technologies such as mobile 802.16e were gaining momentum “due to uncertainties surrounding the licenses”.

Nokia, which is estimated to pay Qualcomm about $500m a year in royalties, even though it has exited the CDMA market, has made an interim payment of $20m that it says reflect a fairer monthly price to renew its agreement, which expired in April. Qualcomm is disputing Nokia’s estimates and argues that its licensing practises have contributed to the rapid fall in handset prices over the past few years, and allowed manufacturers to innovate because they do not pay extra to use additional patents.

The Finnish company is clearly getting tired of the delays and is going on the aggressive in the hope of pushing its rival into a compromise. Last week it filed a counterclaim against an April suit by Qualcomm in the Western District of Wisconsin, asserting that Qualcomm has been using Nokia IPR in its chipsets and making those chipsets available to other handset customers. Specifically, Nokia says that Qualcomm is infringing on six implementation patents that are being used in Qualcomm GSM/W-CDMA and CDMA2000 chipsets. The phonemaker is seeking damages and an injunction.

The implementation patents g relate primarily to multiband/multimode technologies, and direct conversion technologies that reduce handset and chipset size, cost and power consumption. They seem to fall into very similar technical areas to the Broadcom suits, and the actions may have been coordinated to cause maximum damage to Qualcomm if successful. Nokia pointed out that these patents were not essential in order to produce a standard product, as many of the Qualcomm patents are thought to be, but they provide substantial benefits when used – in other words, Qualcomm could get around these patents easily enough, but would have to redesign its chips to do so.

Qualcomm had sued over patents Nokia continues to use despite the expiration of their licensing agreement. Over the past two years, Qualcomm has filed 11 patent suits against Nokia seeking damages and injunctions. “Over the past 19 months Qualcomm has filed 11 patent litigation cases against Nokia seeking damages and injunctions,” said Rick Simonson, chief financial officer of Nokia. “Nokia has now filed its first counter action to address Qualcomm’s unauthorized use of Nokia technology. We will continue to defend ourselves and exercise all rights according to our extensive IPR portfolio.” Lawsuits between Nokia and Qualcomm will proceed in the UK in June, in Germany in August and another complaint before the ITC is anticipated to be decided by September.

Nokia’s aim, apart from straight cost reduction, is to make itself a net recipient in the exchange of IPR with Qualcomm, rather than paying more than it receives. It also hopes to set new precedents for IPR charging in handsets to reduce costs across the board and shift the industry goalposts. The key difference between the two adversaries is that when Nokia uses Qualcomm technology, it is the only beneficiary, but when Qualcomm uses Nokia IPR, all its licensees get the benefit. So potentially a win for Nokia, now that the Finnish company has extended its actions to patent infringement suits of its own, would be even more devastating for Qualcomm than simply being forced to cut royalty revenue from this huge customer.

Despite all this apparent gloom, the prospects for Qualcomm’s core semiconductor business remain brighter than ever. It is increasingly clear that the company will have to address the relationship between its two main activities, and the structure of its licensing, fairly drastically in order to avoid a serious drop in its to-date resilient share value, and to prevent the damage to its 3G chip revenues that further nervousness and delay could cause. But while such rethinking could be painful, it would certainly not be terminal. Even if Qualcomm were to adopt the same licensing rates and structure as peer group companies, it would still have one of the strongest IPR businesses in the industry, with its large arsenal of undisputed patents and its continuing commitment to high R&D spend. And its chips and patents are now targeting an increasingly broad market, beyond CDMA, so giving it huge expansion opportunities, primarily in W-CDMA, but also in multimode systems including Wi-Fi and the emerging OFDMA technologies.

The belated upsurge in 3G adoption round the world will boost Qualcomm’s earnings and value over the next few years despite the Nokia dispute. According to a new research note from American Technology Research, W-CDMA will replace GSM in two-thirds of wireless networks in 2007-2010, making W-CDMA the fastest growing segment in wireless, with 175m handsets expected to ship this year. This is particularly important for Qualcomm as it scarcely participated in the GSM market, and so its share of the W-CDMA sector represents all-new revenue streams. Positive factors include a likely increase in demand for W-CDMA from Motorola, which is reducing its reliance on its former chip unit Freescale and trying to step up its lagging presence in 3G handsets – leading to the signing of a chip partnership with Qualcomm last fall. Also, despite long term question marks over CDMA2000, that segment will see strong growth in the coming few years, and W-CDMA is likely to experience high demand in China, despite the government’s pushing of the homegrown TD-SCDMA standard, while Qualcomm is also leaping ahead in HSPA and mobile TV chips. The researchers estimate that, over the next three years, 730m handsets based on CDMA and W-CDMA will be sold, with Qualcomm securing 55% of the blended share. Their forecast includes the assumption that Nokia and Qualcomm will settle in 6-18 months from now, with Nokia reducing its average royalty rate to Qualcomm to about 2.5% (compared to the estimated Qualcomm average of 3.8%).

Of course, one factor that may make ATR’s forecast look over-optimistic is the current surge in Nokia’s fortunes. Qualcomm will succeed, in the short term, on the back of Nokia losing out to its rivals – not just because of the licensing disputes, but also because Nokia is not a chip customer. Handset makers that are increasing their semiconductor spend with Qualcomm include Motorola, LG and Samsung, but all these are currently under pressure from Nokia and another non-Qualcomm supporter, Sony Ericsson. Jha admitted to investors that for Qualcomm to increase its market share in W-CDMA chips – currently estimated at 30%, according to iSuppli – it would need Samsung and LG to boost their market share and for Qualcomm to increase its revenues from Motorola. Jha is hopeful that the current streamlining going on at Motorola will include a decision to rely more heavily on Qualcomm for 3G chips, as CEO Ed Zander looks to increase output of W-CDMA handsets while rationalizing the supply chain. “We’re hopeful the decision making process going on at Motorola will lead to us increasing our market share there,” Jha said.

Such an outcome would be a huge psychological, as well as monetary, boost to Qualcomm and its shareholders because it would indicate that tier one handset makers still want to increase their business with the CDMA giant, despite their doubts over its business model and fears of over-control. This is because the company actually has advanced 3G silicon, and with Nokia rampant once more, challengers like Motorola have to put technological functionality, cost and form factor ahead of political considerations as they strive to bite back.