Most of the major mobile players have gained new CEOs over the past two years, reflecting the massive changes going on in their sector, and the need for new blood and thinking. Not that the new chiefs always bring that ‘ as the speculation over who will succeed Paul Otellini at the helm of Intel, there is a balance to strike between promoting internally, for stability and intimate knowledge of the firm; and the ability to look at the company with fresh eyes. The firms with the biggest challenges are, predictably, the ones most likely to bring in outsiders, as Nokia did with Stephen Elop, after generations of Finnish veterans. But Google and Apple both got old-timers to take the wheel ‘ reasonable, given that both companies are still very successful, but arguably short-sighted, risking that they will stay with the old norms even after those have been outdated (the lack of big innovations from Apple under Tim Cook’s leadership is starting to worry some investors). Motorola Mobility also got a new top gun after its acquisition by Google ‘ Dennis Woodside certainly brings a new outlook to the handset maker, but is very much a veteran of the search giant and its assumptions. And then there’s Microsoft, still run by its second ever CEO, Steve Ballmer, who probably has just one more chance to prove he can adapt to the mobile world.
But none of that matters too much if the CEO has a strong team of lieutenants with vision, market credibility, plus the ability to execute well and motivate internal teams. At the current time, we see the new chiefs starting to line up their management teams, and the people who will really drive mobile developments in the coming couple of years. Cook recently started to change his image as a CEO who is not given to dramatic actions, and followed up the fiasco of the iOS Maps launch not just with an apology, but by using the incident as a trigger to reorganize the management structure.
The most public element of that reshuffle was the departure of Scott Forstall, the software chief. The key Maps and Siri products, which were part of his remit, were moved to an enlarged online services group, headed by Eddy Cue. He now has the toughest job in Apple, striking the sensitive balance between leading the move to cloud services while protecting the traditional control and revenues that come from native apps. Cue has already started on his own personnel changes as he rises to his first big challenge, to get the Maps program back on track ‘ vital to deliver a fully fledged web experience to users, to wrongfoot Google and to stem the progress of Nokia with its Navteq monster. Already known as a ‘fixer’ within Apple, he has reportedly fired the person who directly oversaw the Maps project, Richard Williamson, who was senior director for iOS platform services.
According to Bloomberg, Cue is now talking to one of Apple’s location partners, TomTom ‘ itself striving to keep its platform alive as the mobile giants develop their own ‘ to improve the iOS product. This is likely to be just one example of a reworking of the Apple structures, better to meet the new pressures of the multiscreen, always-online market. That does not necessarily require a new CEO, argue insiders, as long as old assumptions are challenged among the critical product executives, new ideas are imported, and they are held fully accountable when old Apple tactics go wrong in the new world.
The Maps problem created just one of a series of question marks over how effectively Apple is working in the cloud. Siri, for all its high profile, has been heavily criticized by some users, and could be overshadowed by Google Now, which has far broader capabilities and, of course, leverages the company’s massive search resources (which Apple lacks). And although there is hefty uptake of iCloud, this has not expanded in terms of its functionality nearly as far as many have hoped, leaving it vulnerable to Amazon and others. Cook has been aware of the need to embrace the cloud more proactively and his recent reshuffle indicated he will do something about that in 2013. While Forstall’s direct replacement, Craig Federighi, will oversee the increasingly converging iOS and OS X platforms, the web products have received greater resource and focus by being moved into Cue’s enlarged group. Cook has created or redefined Apple’s product groups in a move whose importance has so far been under-reported, but which will have clear effects from next year. The groups now comprise Online Services, Human Interface, Technologies (hardware and chips, under Bob Mansfield) and Software (Federighi’s OS unit), mirroring the four key elements of the Apple platform.
Along with Cue, the influential Jony Ive – formerly head of industrial design and now chief of the new Human Interface division ‘ is the most critical executive in delivering a ‘new Apple’ from 2013. He takes the lead in ensuring that Apple continues to work its ‘magic’ in the actual look and feel of the device and UI. Perhaps the most dangerous of the criticisms of recent iPhone launches was that customers would become bored of the hardware/software design in the fickle consumer electronics world. Putting the whole interface ‘ UI and industrial design ‘ under a single executive is significant for a firm whose differentiation rests on an integrated hardware/software experience.
“Apple should double-down on Jony Ive,’ commented Gene Munster, senior research analyst at Piper Jaffray, in a presentation on the future of Apple at a recent Business Insider conference. “The concept of the Apple’s operating system has basically been copied by competitors… The real substance is the hardware side, where Jony Ive plays into it,” he said. “The difference is in the hardware, and isn’t fully appreciated.” This justifies the integration of hardware and UI design responsibilities under one well respected executive.
Other companies are looking to inject new energy into their sub-CEO executive levels. Microsoft recently ousted its high profile Windows chief, Steve Sinofsky, and replaced him with Julie Larson-Green. As with Forstall, a reputation for difficult relations with colleagues dogged Sinofsky and may have accelerated his departure, but the real reasons lie in the need to project to investors and partners that the company is ready to take on new directions. Not that Larson-Green is new blood, having worked at Microsoft for almost two decades, but as with Cue and Ive at Apple, she places new emphasis on user experience, the key to competing in the open web world. She led the team which drove the redesign of Windows, adopting a brand new user interface close to that pioneered on Windows Phone. Her strengths are seen as being in product design and user experience, which will be valuable in the fight against similarly skilled Apple executives.
Meanwhile, HTC certainly needs some new ideas about how to stem its falling market share ‘ high profile and well received devices launches this year having proved not to be enough. Now the Taiwanese firm has hired a new head of marketing, Benjamin Ho, former VP of business strategy and marketing at Taiwanese cellco FarEasTone and former CMO of Motorola. He will replace John Wang as HTC’s chief marketing officer.
Under Wang, HTC had briefly made a real marketing impact, creating new brand awareness, especially in previously undertapped Europe, with its slogan ‘Quietly Brilliant’ and a massive advertising campaign. But the gains from that 2010-11 activity fizzled out from later 2011, and this year has seen HTC’s once leadership position in Android eclipsed by the Samsung Galaxy juggernaut. Now HTC has launched a project, known internally as ‘Marketing 2.0’, to focus on ‘holistic marketing’ and mass market brand outreach.
The use of the tired ‘2.0’ slogan does not bode well for radical new thinking, but HTC’s changes reflect a general trend which will affect all the mobile players, and has also been seen in Elop’s successive reshuffles at Nokia and Dennis Woodside’s new pared-down structure at Motorola. The second tier executives who take the lead on product design and marketing are more important than they have been for years, as all the companies try to grab the shortlived opportunity to define the next generation mobile experience, which is centered on creating an appealing and unified interface for multiscreen and multiplatform cloud services.