It is clear that much of the growth in the mobile equipment and device industries will come from the huge emerging economies ‘ China, India, Indonesia and Brazil ‘ in the coming years. However, the patterns of procurement and pricing are very different in these markets, compared to the norms of the west, and that is placing the traditional vendors on the horns of a dilemma ‘ will they choose to adapt their products and pricing strategies to compete according to the new rules being set by the Asian powerhouses; or will they cede the hardware battle to suppliers which have built their business models from scratch around these new rules?
There are increasing signs that established players such as Ericsson and Nokia Siemens, on the equipment side, and Motorola Mobility on the device front, are pulling back from hardware sales in some countries, especially India, and will rely on other activities such as managed services to retain a presence (and higher profits). And while the western vendors have done surprisingly well in gaining elements of the big Chinese 3G and TD-LTE roll-outs, alongside powerful local competitors like Huawei and ZTE, now that the operators’ investment is shifting to devices, it looks increasingly tough for the US and European brands to retain the position to which they are accustomed in their older territories.
Two companies highlighted these trends in the past week ‘ Nokia Siemens downplayed India as a potential revenue engine, while Google’s Motorola unit looks set to exit the market almost entirely on the handset side.
Carriers report that the big European suppliers ‘ Ericsson, Nokia Siemens and Alcatel-Lucent ‘ are less aggressive in targeting deals in Africa and parts of Asia than Chinese rivals, which are better adjusted to low infrastructure costs, and in some cases rarely turn up to bid for the projects.
Nokia Siemens has been the most vocal of the majors about the difficulties of making a profit in wireless networks in price competitive markets such as India, and has stood back from bidding in deals which would prove to be loss leaders. CEO Rajeev Suri confirmed the focus on value rather than volume, in an interview last week with Bloomberg, saying his company would forgo some deals in emerging markets and focus its efforts on US growth.
Although NSN missed out on most of the first major US contracts for LTE RAN gear ‘ dominated by Ericsson and Alcatel-Lucent ‘ it says there will still be plenty of demand as the operators look to increase 3G and 4G capacity. It has already won a share of T-Mobile USA’s LTE build-out, along with Ericsson, and is heavily promoting its flexible RAN architecture, FlexiZone small cell and Wi-Fi platform, and its broader Liquid Net framework for agile, responsive networks.
Suri said: ‘Our strategy was to go for Korea, Japan and the US because that is where operators are monetizing data. It was about withdrawing from some markets in the Middle East and Africa where it’s hard to make money and the rest of the world we would defend and not grow. What we saw in the third quarter was that the strategy is working.’
Suri, now in his fourth year as CEO, recently delivered NSN’s first quarterly sales increase and profit since last year but admits ‘the industry is a tough place’. He aims to grab the opportunity offered by US authorities’ hostility to Chinese vendors ‘ security agencies recently warned operators against buying from Huawei and ZTE, supposedly on security grounds. This leaves a rapidly expanding mobile broadband market open for the European suppliers, as well as Samsung, which has won deals at Sprint and MetroPCS.
However, NSN still has a struggle in North America, where its sales fell by 6% in the third quarter, in contrast with a 29% rise in Asia-Pacific. The venture now promises to increase marketing spend and other activities to boost US business and try to stay in contention with Huawei for the second spot in the wireless equipment market, after Ericsson.
‘The competitive environment within the mobile equipment industry has changed in favor of NSN,’ Sami Sarkamies, a Nordea Bank analyst in Helsinki, told Bloomberg. ‘It looks like the Chinese vendors will be kept out of the US., while NSN’s improving profitability makes it a more compelling partner than Alcatel- Lucent, which is struggling.’
Meanwhile, Motorola once wrestled with Nokia for the number one spot in the Indian handset market, but now it could pull out altogether as new parent Google starts to act on radical restructuring plans. The search giant, which acquired Motorola Mobility earlier this year, wants to restore the unit to profitability by focusing its activities on fewer device models and territories ‘ and many observers believe that will be a prelude to selling on the hardware business, which creates conflicts of interest with Google’s Android partners and its co-branded Nexus business.
The latest sign that Google may exit India, where huge unit growth potential is offset by intense competition and price pressures, came this week when the firm shut down Motorola Mobility’s India website. That followed an announcement in August that it planned to downsize its operations in the country and lay off 4,000 employees in Asia to cut costs.
‘We are streamlining our business and support systems, and unfortunately, we’ll no longer have a dedicated website for India,’ said a holding page which replaced the former site. However, it promised to continue to offer local support sites for existing products.
The August restructuring plan included the closure of one-third of Motorola Mobility’s offices worldwide and a 20% slashing of the workforce, with the focus on Asia. At the time of the announcement, William Moss, director of communications for Motorola Asia-Pacific, said: ‘India is affected by this global restructuring, but we do continue to have substantial operations there.’
He echoed the corporate line set by new general manager Dennis Woodside, telling The Times of India: ‘We will simplify our mobile product portfolio, shifting the emphasis from featurephones to more innovative and profitable devices. We expect this strategy to create new opportunities and help return our mobile devices unit to profitability.’
The aim of Google’s plan is to exit unprofitable markets, accelerate the shutdown of the featurephone business, and create just a few high impact devices each year instead of dozens, according to Woodside. Google’s previous claims that it would largely leave Motorola alone were already thrown into doubt when Woodside, a Google veteran, was named to succeed former CEO Sanjay Jha and he lost no time in assembling his own management team, losing 40% of the handset maker’s vice presidents.
Some of Woodside’s actions fit in with directions already taken by Jha, such as reducing the number of devices and streamlining processes. But Jha, after a period of retrenchment largely to the Americas and China, was starting to eye expansion in emerging markets and Europe again, chasing the high growth area of affordable smartphones. That policy now looks in doubt, and it remains to be seen whether the ‘few devices’ keep the Motorola brand for long.
China remains the exception for Motorola, which will still be an important vehicle to expand Android in the world’s largest smartphone market ‘ and is set to become the largest installed base for the Google OS, and for iOS, next year. China overtook the US as the world’s largest market for new smartphones this year, and has been the main source of new iOS and Android activations since early this year. That will add up to the biggest active base as early as the end of Q113, according to mobile analytics firm Flurry.
The US will remain number one in the two leading mobile platforms for another few months because of the impact of the current holiday buying season, but soon China’s own new year will reverse that trend, and there is also the possibility of an iPhone or iPad at the largest cellco, China Mobile, for 2013, sparking another wave of activations. The other two cellcos will start to sell the iPhone 5 before year end according to Apple. According to Flurry’s calculations, the US had 181m active Android and iOS devices as of October, making it the largest base, ahead of China on 167m. After that there is a huge drop to the third placed territory, the UK on 35m devices. Next come Japan and South Korea (28m and 27m respectively), then Germany, France, Canada, Brazil and Spain. China has seen iOS and device activations rise by 293% in the past year.
However, a different set of handset makers will take advantage of this wave. China plays by very different rules from the US. The three cellcos are even more powerful and the role of Apple is smaller, partly because it has not succeeded in making a deal with the largest operator, China Mobile. There is also a greater focus on local vendors, which are riding high on the growth of their home market, also disadvantaging Apple.
In fact, Android had a massive 90% share of smartphone sales in China in the third quarter, according to local research firm Analysys. Although the figures tend to exclude important factors such as grey imports (very relevant to iPhones), the company’s ratings are generally reliable and they indicate massive expansion for the Google OS, up from under 60% a year earlier.
That is partly because all the major Chinese vendors ‘ Lenovo, Huawei, ZTE, Alcatel/TCL and others ‘ all use Android as their premier OS, although Samsung is the market leader, while other non-Chinese Android vendors like HTC and Sony are launching many models optimized for the country. This is not always good news for Google, since many Chinese vendors support user experiences, like those of Baidu and AliBaba, which use the Android kernel but virtually exclude the search giant’s own brand and services.
And while Apple’s share has been squeezed in China over recent quarters, making it urgent for the firm to create a TD-SCDMA/TD-LTE iPhone for the largest operator, Samsung cannot rest on its laurels either. According to another research firm, Gartner, Lenovo will become China’s largest domestic smartphone provider next year and will be biting at its Korean rival’s heels.
Gartner says Lenovo has already achieved the number two spot on a quarterly basis, taking 14.8% share in the third quarter, up from just 1.7% a year earlier, and overtaking Apple (on 6.9%). Samsung had 16.7% of unit sales in the period. This is a significant achievement for Lenovo which, despite being the world’s top PC maker, has never made much mobile impact. In 2007 it sold its cellphone division to an affiliated private equity group for US$100m, but then bought it back in 2009 for $200m. It has huge brand recognition and distribution channels in China, where it positions its handsets at the midrange.
ALU in new financing talks with Goldman:
Alcatel-Lucent’s quest for sustained profitability remains a tough one, and the French firm is now reported to be in financing talks with Goldman Sachs Group to strengthen its balance sheet.
According to Bloomberg, the terms are still being worked out, but would see the US investment bank granting ALU financing of an undisclosed amount, with the Paris-based vendor providing some of its assets as collateral. ALU shares leapt by as much as 8.3% on the reports on Thursday, after a rise of 16% the day before, though they are still only €1. The stock has fallen by 34% this year and was trading near a 23-year low before the Goldman talk emerged.
CEO Ben Verwaayen is under pressure to explore many financing options as losses persist and the firm continues to burn cash, despite a reorganization process which has been going on for most of his five-year tenure. He is also said to be exploring better returns on its huge patent collection, and further asset sales, offloading non-core businesses which could include the enterprise and submarine fiber cable divisions.
But each of those assets could fetch only €1bn or less, say analysts, not enough to solve ALU’s problems, which have got worse again amid the eurozone crisis and a slowdown in telco spending, especially in Europe. ALU had achieved several profitable quarters and significant LTE deals in north America, but it continues to frustrate investors with its cash burn rate- about €700m a year since it was merged. More than €2bn of debt is due over the next three years, adding to the challenges.
Verwaayen has already made thousands of job cuts during his CEOship, and sold assets such as a stake in aerospace manufacturer Thales, and the Genesys call center software unit. He is also said to be exploring ways to generate cash from the patents portfolio, largely inherited from fabled US research arm Bell Labs, which was part of Lucent. In February, ALU announced a deal with licensing syndicate RPX covering 29,000 patents, which it said would deliver several hundred million euros ‘ but is has yet to disclose any revenue from that contract. Insiders say RPX no longer has the exclusive on that agreement.This month, ALU appointed former Nokia executive Craig Thompson to head a new dedicated business unit created to manage the IPR portfolio.