As the year nears its end, one topic sure to feature highly on the traditional ‘techologies of the year’ lists will be NFC. But in reality, the contactless standard for exchanging small amounts of data has been a damp squib so far, at least in terms of its most-hyped application, smartphone payments. It turns up in transport passes and some payment cards, and in phones for useful purposes like exchanging contact details or even logging onto Wi-Fi with one action. However, bringing together the payments/transport functions and the handset has progressed slowly, as operators and vendors vye to control the experience and they all mull over the business case. Outside Japan and Korea, where NFC mobile payments are widespread, most handset-based money services are not using this technology ‘ indeed, the most successful rely on good old SMS. And even in the US, users are still waiting for big name ventures like Isis to go live, Apple remains aloof, and Google Wallet is still available on only a few devices and networks.
This is not to say that NFC will never be important ‘ the weight of carriers’ interest in it, especially when they can control it via the SIM card, will drive it forward, and the big credit card platforms like Visa are stepping up their activities. But it will need a more convincing business case to attract really big investment; it will need greater commitment from payments giants like PayPal; and will also need more wholehearted support from the largest handset makers. Samsung and Nokia have so far focused mainly on non-payments functions and Apple is not yet supporting NFC at all.
Meanwhile, the really disruptive forces in non-traditional payments have been PayPal and, more recently, Square, neither of which are NFC-reliant ‘ but which may be expected to take a major role in mobile payments. This is because they offer extremely simple user experiences, and they rethought the commercial process from scratch for the new behaviors driven by the web ‘ in a way that Apple with Passbook, and Google with Wallet, have not.
NFC itself has been held back by the fragmentation created by many companies trying to put their stamp on the experience. Rival operators are often working together ‘ as in Isis and a series of European collaborations like the UK’s Project Oscar ‘ but they need to look far wider and create working alliances with the whole value chain. The new head of NFC at the GSM Association – which is a big supporter of the technology to enhance the role of the handset and the operator’s SIM card ‘ commented in a recent interview with Mobile World: ‘If we try and do it alone it’s not going to work.’ Pierre Combelles, a former Orange executive, says the NFC industry is finally at a ‘tipping point’, but tipping it in the right direction is not assured. He added: ‘Of course, there’s still a lot to do because let’s not forget we’re really moving the tectonics of very, very big actors; banks, retailers, operators and so on and, of course, the habits of people as well. This is not going to change overnight but I think momentum is gaining.’
However, he stays loyal to the cellco perspective on payments by giving the SIM card a central role, particularly in the always sensitive areas of security and privacy. He said: ‘We don’t know any other ecosystem in which the responsibilities between the different actors, and what the customer can expect in terms of service and guarantee, is as clearly specified as SIM-based NFC.’
That ignores the push by some players to remove reliance on the SIM, or to wrest control of that SIM from the carrier, as Apple has played with from time to time. And while carriers dream of an m-payments world underpinned entirely by NFC and their own SIMs, in reality they are adopting other technologies if they want short term impact. A typical process is that seen at the recently formed m-payments joint venture between Denmark’s four cellcos, which will not support NFC transactions until ‘stage four’ of its roadmap, and at an unspecified time. Stage one uses SMS and an app, allowing users to purchase items such as tickets and add the sum to their phone bill. So far so conventional, though such services are very attractive to subscribers. In the second stage, users can buy products online by entering their mobile number and then confirming the purchase with a PIN, with the funds taken from their bank accounts. In stage three, they will offer a digital wallet to which users can add cards such as gym membership, charge cards and coupons ‘ however, at this point, there is still no mention of NFC or payments, and this shows how many carriers are emulating Apple’s Passbook rather than plunging into full wallets before they understand the business case or how the necessary partnerships will work. They said NFC payments would be part of their wallet ‘eventually’.
This caution is hardly surprising when even operators in countries where NFC has been heavily deployed are not reporting compelling results. In Japan, handsets featuring the NFC-based Felica contactless technology account for more than 60% of the total installed base, but even so, only about 15% of those Felica phone owners actually use the service, and then mainly for public transport. That is despite the fact that lead operator NTT Docomo invested large sums in helping retailers pay to instal point-of-sale terminals ‘ perhaps the biggest single obstacle to NFC payments adoption in most markets. The situation is getting worse in Japan now as consumers are migrating from operator handsets to new models like iPhones, which often do not have NFC included.
While NFC requires new terminals, other solutions like Square and PayPal Here do not, so can expect faster uptake by retailers. The latter has put mobile at the heart of its growth strategy, but not necessarily NFC ‘ and its efforts feed into the wider payments umbrella being created by its parent eBay, and spanning physical, online and mobile transactions. It launched PayPal Here, its response to the successful Square payments reader, earlier this year, and may be followed into the field by Amazon, expanding its Payments platform to bricks and mortar stores. These solutions offer a simple gadget which turns the handset into a terminal for merchants. Using the plug-in card reader – dongle-sized and fully encrypted ‘ and an app, retailers can accept payments by swiping cards in the mini-reader, by scanning them using the handset’s camera, or manually entering details. They can also send invoices and accept PayPal directly from their app or a mobile website.
All this is very simple compared to getting NFC into a host of stores, devices and user consciousness. During its Q2 results, eBay CEO John Donahoe said NFC would ‘never be ready’ and did not offer obvious consumer value. The PayPal subsidiary then ditched its NFC experiments and focused its efforts on Here. However, it is not writing off NFC completely. Earlier this month, head of communications Adrian Christie told CNet: “We just see NFC as a modality, a token, a way to connect to a terminal, but there are other ways to connect a terminal and NFC is not the only way. I know there is definitely some concern from consumers in terms of reliability of NFC and tapping, but we’re watching all those indicators, and in no way are we ruling it out.” But amid extensive PayPal research into consumer behavior, the company has not yet been convinced that a contactless handset is easier for the user than a plastic smartcard, or even using Bluetooth.
And the world’s most successful m-payments services are not in Japan and are not powered by NFC. Instead, they are usually based on SMS and target consumers who really need them, because they lack bank accounts and plastic cards. The foremost example of these emerging economy offerings is Vodafone’s M-Pesa in selected African markets. This shows how a new financial service should be done ‘ starting with simple but appealing functionality and then expanding into broader applications. Kenyan joint venture partners Vodafone and Safaricom have expanded their M-Pesa service to offer interest-bearing savings accounts and small loans to users, most of whom are ‘unbanked’.
The additions to M-Pesa ‘ which is the biggest revenue generator for Vodafone in Kenya ‘ are called M-Shwari, and are being launched in cooperation with the Commercial Bank of Africa (CBA). Safaricom customers can sign up to the M-Shwari interest bearing savings account, provided by CBA, directly through the M-Pesa menu on their handsets, without having to fill in forms or visit a bank branch. They can also apply to CBA for a mini-loan directly from their phone, using an interface designed by Vodafone. Approval is based on M-Pesa transactions and savings history, and when a customer gets the green light, the loan money is sent directly to the M-Pesa account, enabling it to be used for payments from the handset. There are no set-up fees or charges.
‘M-Shwari creates a safe environment for customers to borrow small amounts and links the amounts of credit available to the ability to save,’ said Michael Joseph, director for M-Pesa within Vodafone Group. “Saving is no longer the privilege of an elite.’
He added that, if the service is successful in Kenya, Vodafone will launch it in other markets, as it did the basic M-Pesa payments and savings offerings.
“M-Shwari is a groundbreaking financial service innovation that will foster a culture of saving and allow Kenyans with no collateral to access micro-saving and loan products through the convenience of their mobile phones at very competitive terms,” said Safaricom CEO Bob Collymore, in a statement.
According to the Central Bank of Kenya, about 12m citizens are unbanked in a population of almost 42m, and around US$3.5bn circulates outside the formal banking system.
Safaricom offers M-Pesa under licence from Vodafone (which owns a 40% stake in the operator too, and has management rights). The M-Pesa licence fee makes up the vast majority of the total fees Vodafone earns from its partner. In fiscal 2011, the Kenyan carrier earned $130m from the mobile money service and 80% of its subscriber base use the service. M-Pesa was launched by Vodafone’s Tanzanian subsidiary, Vodacom, in July 2011 and roll-outs have followed in India, South Africa and, through a local partner, Afghanistan. It is reportedly being considered for other territories such as Egypt too.
Vodafone also recently expanded M-Pesa by attaching it to the HomeSend international remittance hub, operated by BICS, opening it up to a wider range of communities which lack conventional banking services. M-Pesa customers will be able to send and receive funds via their handsets, through 21 international money transfer businesses in 35 countries.
These kind of services, not NFC wallets for users with too many payments options already, are the heart of the mobile money explosion. According to the GSMA, 140 mobile money transfer systems now exist in 65 countries and a further 100 or more are in development, mainly in emerging economies. And these offerings actually affect consumers’ lives rather than complicating them. Michael Joseph, director of mobile money at Vodafone, said recently: ‘Mobile changes lives. It also transforms societies and economies – a 10% increase in mobile penetration in a country equates to a 1.2% increase in GDP growth. We are now at the next stage of that growth. By breaking down national barriers to make mobile money transfer truly global and ubiquitous across all competing networks, just like text messaging today, we can further connect the world’s huge unbanked population.’
Recent operator NFC moves:
Despite doubts, operators are getting far more active in NFC, with trials and even commercial roll-outs mounting.
China Unicom recently launched an NFC wallet with China Merchants Bank to provide mobile payment for its subscribers, with Shanghai the first city to adopt the service. Customers can link their bank account to their SIM card to turn their phones into a mobile wallet. In June, China Mobile announced a similar alliance with China UnionPay to collaborate on mobile payments services, including integrating banking details into SIM cards and NFC-based wallets.
The Danish cellcos, TDC, Telenor, Telia and Three, recently formed a new company to offer mobile payments in the country. Initially it will support transactions via SMS or an app-based service, then add the ability to make online purchases from a handset, and finally offer NFC-based payments. The partners have also appointed Peter Bredgaard as managing director. He is currently the chief sales officer of Unwire, a Danish vendor that offers value added services such as mobile wallets, payments and ticketing.
Vodafone recently signed a multiyear contract with NFC security specialist Gemalto to support the roll-out of mobile payment services across its global footprint. Gemalto will supply security via its Trusted Service Management (TSM) platform. This encrypts data as it moves between mobile networks and banks. Gemalto is also providing its UpTeq NFC SIM, which enables secure over-the-air (OTA) installation of third party applications while avoiding clashes with other services already present on the card. The deal should allow Vodafone subsidiaries around the world to connect more easily to local third parties including banks, retailers and transport operators. This could accelerate the creation of an NFC ecosystem with the cellco at the heart of the value chain.
In October Turkcell launched the Turkcell Wallet, a SIM-based mobile wallet that is compatible with both smartphones and featurephones, and enables users to carry out a raft of different transactions by entering their phone number. Smartphone owners can download a Wallet app, and even make contactless payments if their phone is NFC-enabled, while featurephone customers receive an over-the-air update that embeds the wallet into their handset’s SIM menu. The product can be used as a standalone prepaid cash card or be linked to a debit or credit card. ‘It’s the only solution where you use your own PIN number, that works with any phone, that works with multiple banks,” claimed an executive, who wants to license the wallet to other operators particularly in eastern Europe, central Asia and the Middle East.
Isis, the mobile payments joint venture led by three US cellcos, kicked off its first consumer trials at last this fall, in Austin, Texas and in Salt Lake City, Utah. The mobile wallet comes well behind Google Wallet, and so will hope not to suffer that product’s teething troubles, which included security fears and a shortage of supporting handsets. The partners delayed the trial from July, saying they wanted to ensure the user experience was as good as possible. Osis, which includes Verizon Wireless, AT&T and T-Mobile USA, offers an m-wallet which enables customers to pay for purchases, use store cards and redeem discounts and coupons, all from an NFC-enabled smartphone.
However, the need to be part of an alliance was highlighted when A1 Telekom Austria said it plans to terminate its NFC mobile payment service on December 31. It says customer feedback indicated they wanted a roaming service, which would only be possible with the cooperation of all network operators. A1 launched a pilot project with partners McDonald’s and Merkur in April to support payments using NFC-enabled handsets. The project is also understood to have suffered from technical problems, with customers complaining that payments took a long time and often did not work.