Last week’s agreement by Nokia to adopt Microsoft’s Playready DRM (digital rights management) platform can be seen as one more instance of DRM fragmentation, as the various approaches proliferate. But perhaps the deal should actually be seen exactly the reverse light, as a proactive intervention by Nokia to break the deadlock between the different DRM technologies, and in so doing, pursue its number one goal, of becoming a dominant mobile internet influencer.
The deal itself is straightforward. Microsoft has issued a DRM porting kit for PlayReady, and Nokia has said it will put the technology on its S60 and S40 devices by early 2008. Ostensibly this is Nokia bowing to the inevitable that some operators will want to offer services where music and video can be held on both a PC and a handset without any new PC software being involved, complete with the ability to move it freely between the two. There are really only three ways of doing that 1) port the Open Mobile Alliance’s DRM 2.0 to a PC, so that the two may swap content; 2) port Playready to Symbian and Linux handsets (it’s already on Windows Mobile); 3) invent something new.
Until the Nokia announcement our money was on the third option, with Adobe in the pivotal role. Adobe has licensed the dominant Intertrust DRM patents so that it can write its own DRM system, which will be part of its media player, due out on PCs this fall, and handsets sometime after. Most online video is Flash Video-based these days, and with a DRM this system could be adapted for premium content and bridge the PC-handset divide. In this scenario, further payments to Intertrust come from the tools which create DRM content, not from each device ,and the famous and successful Adobe Acrobat business model is shifted across to DRM. Perfect.
Adobe would have no control over the underlying platform, has a history of being agnostic about overall architecture and is happy to play as a component within other systems. Therefore it would have some advantages over DRM from Microsoft, which has a habit of building enforced monopolies that the cellular industry, especially Nokia ‘ which seeks a similar level of influence in mobile software – has aggressively spurned over the past 10 years.
Another variation on ‘something new’ is to build an interoperability bridge between the two environments, and we have examples in the Intertrust Nemo interoperability architecture endorsed by the Coral Consortium, and also in Core Media’s Windows Media DRM-to-OMA bridge, built under license from Microsoft.
As for option one, putting OMA on the PC, this is a relatively trivial matter, and something that is actually happening, but it is not an approach that has been adopted widely by the cellular community, partly because of licensing costs. There is a license for the essential patents to offer OMA DRM from the MPEG LA, but this is regarded as too expensive with Intertrust and its parents, Sony and Philips, plus ContentGuard and Matsushita, all holding key patents. Intertrust has offered its own licenses directly and recently Telefonica and LG Electronics have taken Intertrust licenses, to go with the one Vodafone signed up for in 2005 and since these charges are very low, it has been assumed that Microsoft ‘ through its joint control, with Time Warner and Thomson, of ContentGuard ‘ that was keeping the MPEG LA license charges high, mainly to give its own DRMs, including Playready, a chance to breathe. If that was so, then the tactic has proved successful.
However, with Telefonica currently the only major operator to have gone public with a trial of Playready, it seems odd that option two – endorsing the Microsoft system for both mobile and PCs – has now become a preferred option for Microsoft enemy Nokia. We put this to Sebastian Nystrom, director of technology strategy in the Nokia Corporate Strategy unit, and the main DRM strategist for the handset maker. ‘We have merely added another DRM, we have not put it ahead in preference to any other DRMs that we support,’ Nystrom claimed. ‘The reasons for endorsing the Microsoft product is that it can operate in user domains and brings an ease of use to DRM that isn’t in other DRM products.’
The Microsoft software comes with two distinct improvements over the software giant’s other offerings, Windows Media DRM and the Zune DRM ‘ first, rental, purchase, subscription and pay per view models can all be supported on Playready; and second, it supports what are known in the DRM world as domains. A DRM domain is a cluster of devices which are shown to belong to a single family or person, so that once registered, they may share content without decrypting it, through a series of encryption key-issuing techniques. A PC, for instance might manually authorize a number of handsets, and then lose the ability to authorize more past the set limit of five or so. There is a crude version of this in the Apple iPod and iTunes, and naturally this is now extending into Nokia territory through the iPhone, which may have been one motive for Nokia’ lastest move, allowing to endorse a piece of software that overnight gives it iPhone-like DRM capabilities or better.
But Intertrust remains an obstacle. It has filed a number of patents, some issued, others pending, relating to how a domain is built using DRM keys. Our understanding is that it filed these after it agree its landmark $440m court enforced licensing agreement with Microsoft. At the time Microsoft was licensed for 10 years to use the existing (not future) Intertrust patents, for free, on its own platforms, and for a further fee on non-Microsoft platforms. So it doesn’t look as though Nokia can avoid Intertrust even by adopting Playready. It will need a patent license for the existing Intertrust technologies already licensed to Microsoft, because it cannot offer them for free on a non-Microsoft platform, and it will further need access to patents filed after the Microsoft Intertrust settlement.
Nokia can, of course, hide behind the idea that operators that choose DRM, and Nokia just needs to be agnostic and support the operator choice, but this is not the Nokia way and it never has been. Look how aggressive Nokia has been about supporting the OMA’s BCAST versus DVB encryption for DVB-H systems.
Which we why we see the Playready move at least partially as iPhone avoidance ‘ not because it is worried about competition to its market share, but because it needs to meet or exceed current expectations, some of which are currently being set by the iPhone (if all iPhone handsets shipped for the next two years came out of Nokia’s market share, it would be barely a blip, and most are robbing other vendors rather than the market leader).
There are other reasons for Nokia and Microsoft to work together in this area. For instance, they are among the 18 voting members of the Digital Living Network Alliance (DNLA), one of the most powerful consortia built around the concept of the digital home. The DNLA has yet to embrace a single DRM, and told Microsoft three years ago that if its software only runs on Microsoft systems, then its technology would not be chosen. By launching Playready is was preparing to get around that obstacle and by gaining Nokia’s backing it goes one step further, so it is now a straight fight between Playready and the Intertrust inspired Coral Consortium for content interoperability. It is likely that both may get the nod and to the exclusion of all other digital home DRMs.
‘There’s only one internet,’ said Nystrom, pointing out that the mobile web and the web are one and the same, and hinting that Nokia just has to support a common toolset on both. ‘We are always in close discussions with operators and we have shared with them the information that we planned to support Playready and they have shared their thoughts with us, and they are in approval.’
As part of the new agreement, Nokia and Microsoft will also collaborate on expanding and simplifying consumer scenarios for accessing, experiencing and moving digital content using mobile devices, they said in a prepared statement.
‘Through our collaboration with Nokia, we aim to deliver a compelling platform that offers consumers seamless access to virtually any type of digital content they want,” said Amir Majidimehr, corporate vice president of the Consumer Media Technology Group at Microsoft. “Nokia’s breadth of offering in this space, coupled with core digital media technology from Microsoft in the form of PlayReady, will bring new mobile entertainment scenarios to life for millions of consumers around the world.”
Microsoft PlayReady is designed for digital entertainment services, devices and applications, with a specific focus on meeting the needs of mobile operators, service providers and device manufacturers. The technology supports a range of business models that can be applied to almost any type of digital content (music, video, games, ringtones and images) and a wide range of audio and video formats (including Windows Media Audio (WMA), Windows Media Video (WMV), AAC, AAC+, AMR and H.264).
The next question seems to arise is that if Nokia is pro-actively supporting Playready, does this mean that it will prefer it over the Adobe Media Player, which is about to come off beta? If so will it support the Microsoft Silverlight rival to Flash video? If it does, it risks opening the door perhaps a crack too wide for Microsoft. So we reckon that while Microsoft pushes Playready, and Intertrust and its partners push OMA-Intertrust interoperability, we feel that Nokia has just signed up to ensure its offerings are up to date during the coming iPhone panic and that after that, the consumer’s love of ease of use will continue to push most consumers towards Adobe Flash Player, on both the PC and the handset.
This analysis was first published in Fautline, the sister service to Wireless Watch, which provides weekly insights into the latest developments in broadband digital media and the quad play. Please email Linda Elisha on [email protected] for further details.