Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 August 2007

Vodafone officially goes technology neutral and joins WiMAX Forum

The WiMAX Forum has secured what may be its most coveted new member, the once hostile Vodafone. Although the giant operator has clearly been backing away from a UMTS-only strategy over the past year or so, as its business priorities diversify, the official acknowledgement that WiMAX could be an important part of its strategy is a huge psychological boost for the 802.16 community, under pressure from the intensifying hype around LTE developments.

“We are technology neutral,” said a Vodafone spokesperson. “We’re interested in both WiMAX and LTE.’ He added that the operator hopes “to play a role in shaping end-to-end specifications’, a key objective for Vodafone, which is determined that next generation wireless platforms should be driven by carriers’ business requirements rather than vendor interests ‘ and that it should claim the most influential role in defining those requirements. The main vehicle for the large cellcos’ bid to control 4G has been the NGMN (Next Generation Mobile Network) group, founded by Vodafone, NTT DoCoMo and others, and there is already increasing communication between this body and the WiMAX Forum ‘ something that should be stimulated by large 3G operators like Vodafone joining the Forum.

Vodafone has taken an interest in WiMAX for years, and has carried out trials of various OFDM technologies through subsidiaries, including a major 802.l6e project by MTC Vodafone in the Middle East and a commercial deployment in Malta. It is also monitoring trials by partners and joint ventures such as SFR in France. However, these remained very much under the hood until this year, when senior executives started to go public on the openness to adopt a multi-technology strategy. At February’s 3GSM show, CEO Arun Sarin famously called on LTE vendors to speed up their efforts or risk losing the market to WiMAX, and since then the carrier has pulled back on some UMTS efforts, admitting disappointment at the technology’s ability to support its business model in some markets. “The GSMA needs to influence the ecosystem. LTE is still at the standards stage, while WiMAX is a commercial reality,” Sarin said in that landmark speech for WiMAX’ credibility in the mobile world.

In need of an OFDM/MIMO/IP platform ‘ to deliver 4G-style services, to support Vodafone’s badly needed convergence offering in some territories, and to enable it to bid for the widest possible number of new spectrum allocations ‘ Vodafone clearly feels it will not be able to wait for LTE, or rely on souped-up HSPA, in all its markets. There are several relatively recent business departures that are now seen as essential to balancing out the commercial failure of European 3G, and the saturation of core markets, and allaying the fears of Vodafone’s shareholders that its heyday is over.

One of these is that Vodafone needs to acquire fixed broadband capabilities and move towards convergence and quad play, and in some markets this will be more easily and cheaply achieved using broadband wireless rather than buying or partnering with DSL providers. A second is a shift away from the attempt to be a global brand, and instead focusing on emerging markets such as India and the Middle East ‘ areas where WiMAX spectrum may become available before 3G licenses, or where WiMAX will prove more cost effective to build out new markets. Thirdly, while LTE will offer better backwards compatibility with current UMTS/HSPA networks, Vodafone also wants to emulate Sprint Nextel and others by moving sideways into adjacent markets, where new technologies, devices and services will be needed and where it may be worthwhile to gain time to market and choose a network optimized for a new style of communications and media.

Some observers even saw a link between Vodafone’s announcement last week that it had definitely decided to hold on to its 45% stake in Verizon Wireless, despite some shareholders’ calls to cash this in, and the joining of the Forum. This might be true if Verizon Wireless plans to base its own next generation roll-out around WiMAX rather than CDMA’s pre-4G successor, UMB ‘ although the operators’ sale of its 2.3GHz spectrum and vocal commitment to CDMA does not suggest this will be a factor any time soon. Rather, the decision is a sign that Vodafone has been forced to turn its back on many sacred cows amid the intense commercial pressure of the past two years, and that it now has two overriding motives in selecting technology. One is, now it is dropping its once homogeneous business model, to gain competitive edge in a wide range of services and models, depending on the market, a strategy that will require a mixture of networks. The other is to ensure it gains major influence in shaping any standards that it chooses to include in its strategy, and those now include WiMAX.