Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 May 2008

Nortel’s first quarter looks good in the shadow cast by AlcaLu’s

Low expectations abound in the wireless infrastructure market in the face of carrier consolidation, RAN sharing or delayed upgrades; and threatened global recession. So Ericsson was buoyant last month on quarterly results that would have been lacklustre in another year, and Nortel saw its stock rise by 8% on better than expected revenues, even though the improvement seemed to be almost entirely down to one deal from its LG-Nortel joint venture, and its net loss widened. However, almost anything would have looked good compared to the bad quarter reported by Alcatel-Lucent, giving rise to renewed rumors that the French powerhouse is hunting for a new CEO.

Nortel announced first quarter revenues of $2.76bn, 11% up on the same period in 2007, and far higher than Wall Street forecasts of around $2.5bn. The Canadian firm’s stock leapt by 8% to $9.40 on the news, even though analysts later pointed out that a single LG-Nortel deal, which was brought forward, had largely accounted for the $260m sum by which Nortel outperformed expectations. The company stated that its ‘deferred revenue balances decreased by $266m during the first quarter of 2008’. Welcome, but not necessarily the sign of a deep trend. However, there were other positives ‘ gross margin and operating margin improved over last year, at 41.6% and 4.7% respectively, and Nortel said it expected full year revenues to grow ‘in the low single digits’ compared to last year’s total of $10.95bn. However, net loss for Q1 increased from $103m last year to $138m this time, largely because of $88m in restructuring costs (without those, the net loss would have been a more encouraging $35m).

The LG-Nortel windfall boosted the Carrier Networks division, which enjoyed a 21% revenue jump year-on-year to $1.2bn, and an operating profit of $259m, about half of this coming from the LG venture. This was the most impressive revenue increase among Nortel’s four units. Global Services rose 15% to $516m and Enterprise Solutions was up 7% to $641m, but Metro Ethernet Networks fell 12% to $327m.

Like Alcatel-Lucent, Nortel suffered from the contraction of the CDMA business, and saw revenues from this falling from $568m last year to $555m. Another problem area was circuit and packet voice solutions, which fell to $127m from $170m on the falling demand for TDM voice switches.

Over at Alcatel-Lucent, it was far harder to find light in the first quarter figures, despite improvements in revenue and profit for GSM and W-CDMA ranges. Across the whole group, the quarterly loss was a massive €181m ($278m), up from €8m in Q1 last year. Analysts were shocked, the most gloomy of the pundits having forecast €150m loss, and the company’s stock fell by 7.4% to €4.16 (its value has dropped by 56% since the companies’ merger in 2006). Worryingly for Alcatel-Lucent, other infrastructure vendors did not follow its share price drop, and Ericsson stock actually rose by 2.5% on its rival’s news, indicating that the markets believe the poor results were down to specific problems at the French giant, not just general industry conditions.

This was the company’s fifth consecutive quarterly loss since Alcatel bought Lucent in 2006, despite the reduction of about 6,700 jobs so far, with 2,300 still planned to go, and the rationalization of R&D and other facilities and programs. CDMA was the major culprit, with wireless revenues falling 6.5% year-on-year to just over €1bn ($1.7bn). Although AlcaLu does not break down revenues among different product lines, and it pointed out that the first quarter last year had been exceptionally strong in CDMA, it did admit the CDMA business had fallen ‘materially’, while GSM grew on the back of
network expansions in China, India, the Middle East and Africa; and W-CDMA revenues more than doubled, admittedly from a low base. The company also talked up five WiMAX deals during the quarter.

‘In GSM, we have good, profitable growth due to a refreshed product portfolio,’ said CEO Pat Russo on her earnings call with analysts. ‘GSM and W-CDMA were offset by the expected decline in CDMA’It’s unlikely we’ll see CDMA in the aggregate grow in 2008. It’s a declining market and we’re 50% of it.’ The vendor introduced a new GSM platform last year based on its Twin TRX radio transceiver, which claims to double base station capacity, and on its ATCA-based base station controller, which reduces costs and footprint by using a standard chassis. In W-CDMA, AlcaLu is merging its own system with that of Nortel, and will reveal a new combined product later this year.

Some investors and analysts are renewing calls for Russo to quit, pointing to results that were poor even allowing for the strong euro/weak dollar (AlcaLu does over half of its sales in dollars) and the threat of recession, factors that also affect Ericsson and Nokia Siemens, which did better than forecasts in their first quarters. There are also serious doubts that Russo will achieve the annual cost savings of €1.4bn by next year that she has promised, and she has now downgraded her forecast for full year sales from ‘flat’ to ‘a low to mid-single digit decline’. Speculation about who might be approached by AlcaLu’s board and its chairman, former Alcatel CEO Serge Tchuruk, is mounting already, with recently departed and well respected British Telecom CEO Ben Verwaayen hotly tipped, according to Light Reading analysts,along with former France Telecom CEO Thierry Breton.