Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 May 2008

Motorola streamlines handset cost base and takes risk on UIQ

Motorola’s handset operations continue to perform disastrously, but the company is at least trying to set out a development roadmap that points to a lower cost model ‘ long overdue, considering the company is competing with the arch-expert in supply chain efficiency, Nokia. Such moves are important to restore some level of confidence in the company, if it is to gain any shareholder value from the spin-off or sale of the devices unit. A credible new CEO for the division, a more efficient cost structure, and a sense that there is some idea at the top of how to improve Motorola’s fortunes in the future, are all essential, and the new handset roadmap goes at least a small way to promising the last two of these.

The first element is an acceleration of Motorola’s moves towards outsourcing, which it has taken rather half-heartedly for some years now, mainly in the areas of manufacturing and IT. Now it will aggressively pursue ODM agreement for lower end GSM handsets, with an external partner building the core device at low cost. This is an approach that has long been established among tier two device makers, but is now spreading throughout the handset sector, with Nokia, for instance, relying on Taiwanese and Indian ODMs for most of its CDMA models.

Motorola is also looking to reduce costs and complexity by simplifying its supply chain and its design activities in 3G handsets, in order to support fewer technologies. Most significantly ‘ and bucking the industry trend somewhat bravely for a company that badly needs to increase its volumes ‘ Motorola will defocus on Linux and make the Symbian-based UIQ sofware platform the standard for its 3G lines. This will enable the company to streamline its software and component platform strategies, CEO Greg Brown told investors, so that Motorola can focus more on form factor and industrial design as well as software, services and new interface technologies.

While most vendors and operators are looking to reduce the number of platforms they have to support, shifting from Linux ‘ where Motorola was the pioneer among the tier one phonemakers ‘ to Symbian/UIQ seems counter-intuitive. Even Nokia, which virtually controls Symbian and used to present it as the standard for smartphones, is increasingly looking to Linux and other open source systems, not just for low cost markets (Mobile Linux has been particularly strong in China) but enterprise and high end offerings like the internet tablets. It has also placed key elements of Series 60, its alternative Symbian-based software platform to UIQ, into open source and is widely expected to port it to Linux soon.

By contrast Motorola – which in 2003 seemed virtually to lose interest in Symbian, selling its stake in the OS company and focusing on Linux and Windows Mobile ‘ is moving in the opposite direction. This is no doubt partly driven by its need to get back into the flow of the smartphone market, where Symbian remains the most successful and advanced platform ‘ some of Motorola’s recent troubles are down to its over-enthusiastic race into the ultra-low cost handset market, which killed its margins. But redressing the balance cannot mean ignoring the emerging economies altogether, and in most Asian markets, at least, Linux is set to be the most important OS as more advanced handsets are adopted (the real ULCHs use embedded OSs). Brown said the company would continue to support and make devices on its Linux/Java platform for its primary customers in China, but the focus would be on UIQ (we assume Windows Mobile is also being put on the back burner, although it does power one of Motorola’s most high profile ranges, the Q smartphone, a BlackBerry challenger).

Of course, differentiation in high end phones will increasingly come from the user interface and applications platform, not the OS itself, so from that point of view the focus on UIQ does give Motorola some advantages ‘ it is an advanced system for complex smartphones, and is 50% owned by the company, with the other half held by Sony Ericsson. This gives Motorola a strong measure of control over the technology and the ability to differentiate from Nokia Series 60, even in the Symbian world, and it is not inconceivable that UIQ’s owners, despite the technology’s roots within the Symbian organization, could port it to Linux in future (Linux certainly remains immature and unproven in the smartphone market for the present).

UIQ was purchased from Symbian by Sony Ericsson in November 2006 and a year later Motorola, which had already licensed the technology, bought 50% ownership. Reviving its flagging interest in Symbian technologies will bring short term benefits to Motorola ‘ allowing it more easily to join the current trend for touchscreen phones; and strengthening its hand against Nokia S60 and the iPhone, even perhaps luring developers away from S60 by increasing support for UIQ. However, as with S60, broader ambitions will rest on opening up UIQ further, to open source communities and to other operating systems, rather than keeping it in a Symbian ghetto.

On the hardware side, Motorola will focus all its 3G silicon activities on its existing partnerships with Texas Instruments and Qualcomm, excluding its own former chip unit Freescale altogether from future high end ranges. The first TI and Qualcomm devices will appear from Motorola next year.

Brown told investors: ‘In 2009, as we transition more of our devices to our improved platforms, we will deliver a broader and more innovative and competitive customer driven product portfolio in which we will have lower cost devices and improved feature sets reflecting trends in music, touch, and messaging.’