Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 May 2008

Texas Instruments puts UWB on the back burner for three years

Texas Instruments has dropped out of the WiMedia Alliance, claiming that UltraWideBand (UWB) technology will make no impact, especially not in the world of handsets, prior to 2011.

Previously the chipmaker ‘ a co-founder, with Intel of the Alliance, which supports an OFDM-based UWB standard for high speed personal area networks – had fingered mid-2008 as the date for delivery of a mass market UWB device with sufficiently low power to deliver data to a handset at 480Mbps or more, making it possible to copy entire films in well under a minute. The use case of copying last night’s missed one-hour TV episode to your phone while tying your shoe laces and feeding the cat, before heading out for work, will instead be taken up for the next three years by Wi-Fi, TI believes.

Yoram Solomon, senior director of technology strategy and industry relations at TI, confessed to the downgrading of the technology on the chip giant’s priority list last week, and laid out a grim outlook for the UWB industry for the next three years. ‘I’ve seen all the demonstrations and lab results that show that UWB can deliver upwards of 480Mbps, but that’s not in a commercial product, and it is especially not possible when it’s on the same 5x5mm piece of silicon as two other radios, and for a phone that’s where it’s got to work.’

He went on to make it clear that no technology is yet robust enough to work outside the lab. ‘We have PhDs who can tell you a lot more about this than I can, but all of our experts say that none of the UWB technologies has an advantage over the other. I know you think Pulse~Link may have an advantage operating under the radio noise floor, but let me tell you that where one technology has the edge on robustness, the other has it on performance or avoiding interference or multipath. Texas owns most of the intellectual property in the Multiband OFDM Alliance, that formed part of the WiMedia Alliance, so Texas will not drop out of this technology.’

Solomon made it clear that Texas had de-emphasized attempts to productize the technology for now, adding: ‘Some technologies appear to operate under the noise floor of other, existing radio, but on a 5x5mm chip suddenly the radio noise floor is a very different place. For now we think that 802.11n Wi-Fi gives us the right technology to use until UWB becomes mature enough to put in a handset, and we are working with the Bluetooth SIG to use Wi-Fi as a basis for the next Bluetooth. There is testing and protocol adaptation to go through, but we would expect this during early 2009.’

Solomon said that 50Mbps was a more likely rate for Wi-Fi when integrated on a handset and that it was a stopgap to load and sync devices like the N95 with 8Gb of memory on them, for the next three years. ‘There will still be a Bluetooth radio, an FM radio and a Wi-Fi radio, but by using the same PHY for more than one of the radios we might reuse some components and get some chip savings,’ he explained.

But on home networking standards, where Pulse~Link and many WiMedia members are focused with UWB, Solomon was fairly gruff. ‘In home networking we have to decide if we are using Wireless USB, 1394, or DLNA on IP over UWB, Wi-Fi or Bluetooth, before we can make any headway. We are also strong believers that we should not use all this bandwidth irresponsibly and there is no way that uncompressed video should be flying around the home on 60GHz carriers. If you have that bandwidth, use it compressed.’ Many TV vendors have talked about using powerful line of sight radio connectivity between a set-top and a wall-mounted TV to send uncompressed HD at 2.5Gbps across a room.

On the basis of TI’s views, expect low power handset Wi-Fi to transition to 802.11n shortly and for applications for fast sideloading to emerge in the 50Mbps range, which is likely to mean copying a one-hour piece of video to a phone, formatted in QVGA, in about 40-60 seconds, in the early part of 2009.

This analysis was originally published in Faultline, Wireless Watch’s sister title, which offers weekly insights into the digital media markets and the economics of the quad play. Please contact Peter White on [email protected] for more details.