Tesla has a tough job on its hands to clean up its tarnished reputation given recent events, but the company has made a step in that direction this week with the roll out of a software update for its Autopilot system, the first since the unfortunate death of a Tesla driver in Florida back in May – but it’s going to take more than that to claw its way back into the industry’s good books.
However, all Tesla’s hard work to build a safer system and restore the industry’s faith in its technologies has been somewhat overshadowed in the wake of the discovery that there has in fact been more than one Tesla autopilot fatality. Back in January, a 23-year-old driver in China was killed after his vehicle failed to detect a road sweeping truck on a motorway – and somehow Tesla has managed to successfully prevent this information from coming to the fore.
An investigation by Central China Television (CCTV) claims that the driver had Autopilot engaged, but Tesla has responded by saying there was no way of detecting if Autopilot was engaged in this vehicle or not. This reeks of hypocrisy, as Tesla prides itself as an omniscient being that always knows if its vehicles have Autopilot activated – and it has used that fact in past claims against the safety of Autopilot, from people looking to sue.
We aren’t sure why Tesla doesn’t know if Autopilot was being used. It seems to have known whether it was active in every other crash that has been publicly discussed. The fact it didn’t disclose this incident to the world may well point to yet more flaws in its technologies – suggesting that Tesla is trying to run before it can walk. It speaks volumes that Tesla’s share price has slipped around 19% this year, as it tries to acquire SolarCity, a solar panel company in the US, in which CEO Musk is a significant shareholder.
We all want a future where self-driving cars create safer and more efficient societies, but Tesla’s insistence to push its autonomous technologies into vehicles and onto the roads without ensuring safety first is not just holding itself back, but the entire industry. The extent of Tesla’s doggedness has led to its former camera supplier Mobileye making the decision to cut off all business ties with the company – amid claims that Tesla was “pushing the envelope in terms of safety.”
Tesla clearly thought it could do a better job than Mobileye at developing vision chips for autopilot so it went and did just that, returning fire by doubting the innovation of Mobileye.
A Tesla spokesperson told Reuters that Mobileye “attempted to force Tesla to discontinue this development.” Musk’s desire to change the world is admirable, but the pace that Tesla is pushing forward is alarming many in the automotive industry, and may well incur the wrath of the regulators.
Autopilot’s name is an issue. The technology is still not finalized and comes with many repeated warnings that drivers should pay attention to the road at all times. In the two potential Autopilot deaths, it appears that these drivers were ignoring these warnings, but it still proves that the technology isn’t as effective as the branding would suggest. This is a problem in a world of gullible consumers.
Tesla’s fleet currently stands at 90,000 vehicles and growing fast, and 1,000 customers are in the process of testing new features in its “early access program.” With the upcoming launch of the more affordable Model 3, in which Autopilot is a prominent feature and key to Tesla’s plans for an autonomous fleet of Tesla taxis, that figure looks set to swell – as long as Tesla can nail the production process to bring them in on budget. There are many in the auto industry that are very skeptical of the company’s ability to do this.
“Tesla’s failure to report the death of another of its human guinea pigs in a timely manner is unconscionable,” said John Simpson, Consumer Watchdog’s Privacy Project director. “It also makes it clear that autonomous vehicle technologies must be subject to safety regulations that are enforceable by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.”
Autopilot 8.0 puts on-board radar technologies at the forefront of controlling the Autopilot function in its semi-autonomous vehicles, rather than relying primarily on cameras.
Tesla co-founder Elon Musk has made a bold claim that the update could have saved the life of the Tesla Model S driver whose vehicle collided with an 18-wheel tractor trailer, as the radar would apparently have been able to detect a large metal object lying across the road and the GPS could calculate from its location that this wasn’t an overhead sign or footbridge.
Tesla also says the software behind the automatic steering function has been tweaked to disengage if a driver fails to acknowledge the warning messages to keep hands firmly on the steering wheel at all times.