The intensified US focus on emergency response following hurricanes and terror attacks has restored the tarnished reputation of satellite-based communications, as operators look to space for networks that can work in extreme conditions. Vendors and carriers of satellite and stratellite systems see disaster management as a way to put their technologies back on the map, while some wireless companies are looking to put their platforms in space to achieve satellite-style ubiquitous coverage.
In many ways, the satellite and terrestrial wireless industries are converging, with the former looking to broadband wireless to provide a return path for interactive services, and also being used to backhaul Wi-Fi and WiMAX in remote areas or mobile environments like trains. However, the two worlds are also coming into conflict as they battle for precious spectrum, a battle that is partly being fought on the basis of their capablilities in emergency situations.
Companies like MSV (Mobile Satellite Ventures), an operator since 1996, have been demonstrating hybrid satellite/CDMA handsets, a solution that claims to be cheaper and more usable than the original and unpopular satellite phones launched by ventures like Iridium, plus able to roam on to the standard CDMA network. MSV is developing a next generation hybrid wireless network that will use new satellites working in unison with MSV’s patented ancillary terrestrial component (ATC) technology, which will employ thousands of land-based towers in order to deliver seamless service to standard wireless devices. These hybrid systems are seen as the way to bring down satellite phone service costs, increase usability and extend the coverage that broadband wireless can offer into remote areas and emergency situations.
With this new potential to combine the ubiquity of satellite with the cost structures and familiar devices of CDMA or broadband wireless, there is new interest in the satellite spectrum around 2GHz, which is the center of a major political battle. Cellular carriers such as Sprint are seeking the right to bid for shares of the 24MHz chunk of 2GHz S-band spectrum available, alongside the satellite specialists. Since it is so close to the 1.9GHz cellular bands in the US, 2GHz could be a valuable expansion band. The spectrum was originally assigned to satellite companies, but many of those licensees went out of business and when only two remained, and failed to meet their deadlines, the licenses were returned to the FCC. They remain earmarked to be reallocated, under new conditions but possibly for no extra charge, to the remaining mobile satellite players, TMI/Terrestar and ICO, but the cellcos are arguing that it should be auctioned, with wireless providers also able to bid. Intel has estimated that such an auction would raise about $9bn.
The key argument now being employed by the Satellite Industry Association (SIA) to counter this proposal is that, when a disaster affects local wireline or wireless terrestrial systems, MSS networks can provide critical communications capabilities, as they did after the Gulf Coast hurricanes.
The main providers engaged in the dispute fall into three camps ‘ European satellite giant Inmarsat; the two remaining MSS licensees, TMI/TerreStar and Craig McCaw-backed ICO, a reincarnation of a former ICO company that failed; and the cellcos Cingular, Sprint Nextel and T-Mobile USA. TerreStar and ICO, of course, argue that two providers are enough, pointing to other satellite duopolies such as XM and Sirius in radio, EchoStar and DirecTV in television, and Iridium and Globalstar. Therefore they argue that Inmarsat and the cellcos should be excluded from bidding, in the interest of getting spectrum to TerreStar and ICO quickly to speed their deployment of real world services.
Inmarsat is also using disaster management as a key argument, pointing to its extensive experience, during its 26 years in business, in emergency relief efforts, most recently in the Pakistan earthquakes. It is looking to source cellular/satellite hybrid phones and possibly to partner with a broadband wireless operator to add a terrestrial element to its platform. Several senators have called for additional spectrum to be freed up for such hybrid services, claiming they are the most effective for a solution that spans emergency situations and mass commercial applications too.
These dual-mode phones are vital to give satellite a chance of penetrating the consumer market. TerreStar plans services based on dual-mode handsets from 2007, with its implementation of ATC going live in mid-2008. ICO also plans to go live in 2007 providing it has sufficient spectrum. Like other dual-mode handsets, these new generation satellite phones use modified 3G handsets that run on the terrestrial cellular (or, in future, WiMAX) network when they are in urban areas or indoors, but communicate directly with a satellite wherever the terrestrial network does not reach.
MSV is a pioneer in this field and, like others, is playing the public safety card to gain political support for its approach. “MSV’s vision is to launch the most advanced system ever that will serve all Americans, as well as provide critical services to emergency responders,” said CEO Alexander Good at a recent presentation of the technology on Capitol Hill. ‘In the short term, our integrated satellite-terrestrial system will be available to ensure that public safety has communications wherever needed and that all users are connected to the latest communications technologies.’MSV received the first ATC license granted by the FCC last year and holds significant patents in this area.
Before ATC, various attempts have been made over the years to come up with a technology that will offer satellite levels of coverage with lower infrastructure costs. Many of these have focused on ‘stratellites’ or large tethered airships or balloons. Last week, a European project was demonstrating data rates of 11Mbps (the speed of basic Wi-Fi) from a balloon at 10,000 meters altitude. The demo was run by UK-based Skylinc and European organization Capanina. Skylinc once promised to launch commercial services in January 2004, now it gives a vague timescale of 2008-2010, though it claims it will be able to get up to 120Mbps by then.
The highest profile example of stratellite development has been Sanswire, owned by Globetel, which is looking to combine its technology with WiMAX. In June it acquired HotZone Wireless, which develops extended range Wi-Fi and pre-WiMAX systems for the stratellites. The combination of stratellite and radio technologies could cover areas up to 120,000 square miles, claims HotZone. The HotZone product line includes wireless routers which cover metro areas with Wi-Fi, WiMAX or with VoIP services based on DECT and PHS cordless handsets, and claims to be the only outdoor system embracing all these protocols in one network. It also supports DVB-RCT technologies for wireless transmission of voice, data and real-time video.
The problem for such solutions is that they are unlikely ever to achieve the economies of scale to support low cost access, but public safety can provide a financial justification that commercial services cannot, and even more so once large players like Cisco start joining the party. Like GlobeTel/Hotzone, Cisco has been working on emergency response oriented solutions that combine support for many protocols in order to enable different safety agencies, with different systems in place, to communicate seamlessly. The company is also experimenting with communications from space, adapting its Mobile Access Router, which is typically used for IP access from ambulances, police cars, aeroplanes or public transport vehicles, to run on a low earth orbit satellite. The resulting Cisco Low Earth Orbit (Cleo) has now been circling the earth for two years and is designed to show the aerospace industry that commercial IP technology is space-worthy, according to Rick Sanford, director of Cisco’s Global Space Initiatives group.
Cisco believes that routers in space will enable future satellite-based broadband services that will be more robust and lower in cost than current satellite systems for commercial or emergency communications. It claims having a router on board reduces latency and increases resilience, since packets can be moved dynamically to different nodes, allowing satellites to route signals to each other in the air. The move to more affordable and flexible satellite and stratellite communications, more easily combined with terrestrial wireless devices, will also be helped by the current US Department of Defense project with the NASA space agency to define the next generation IP architecture for space, which will ensure interoperability between terrestrial and satellites, while using commercial off the shelf equipment.
While Cisco continues to develop Cleo with an eye on future applications towards the end of the decade, some specialists are looking for faster results, driven by public safety interest, based on putting terrestrial wireless technologies into the sky. There are already aeroplane-based services, notably Connexion by Boeing’s and Tenzing’s in-flight access (though these are backhauled by satellite), and the Verizon Airfone platform, which does use ground-to-air spectrum. More ambitious attempts to transmit broadband wireless signals between air and ground are emerging from a few specialists such as WiSky Networks, which has gained patents for terrestrial broadband wireless to aircraft in flight (or ships at sea). One application would be creating ad hoc networks in emergency situations, when a plane could be flown over the area to provide instant backhaul for access systems, at far lower cost than using satellite.
All these are various approaches to combining the advantages of satellite with those of terrestrial wireless, to increase ubiquity and flexible roll-out without piling up costs. The need for more effective emergency communications will certainly be a major accelerant in this process, as long as it does not get bogged down in spectrum wars, and as long as the focus on public safety does not sideline the valuable commercial and social aspects of these technologies in bringing low cost access to even the most hard to reach communities.