Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 November 2005

XO sells wireline business in latest sign of LMDS revival

The Baby Bell operators are increasingly tying up control of telecom long lines, notably with Verizon’s acquisition of MCI and SBC’s of AT&T, and BellSouth’s alliance with Sprint. This is making the market unattractive for independent competitors, and some are turning to wireless as an option with lower costs and greater growth potential. The best example to date is XO Communications of the US, which is to sell its national telecoms business for $700m in order to fund the creation of a broadband wireless service geared to enterprises and other carriers. Such actions are creating something of a spectrum goldrush, not just in the WiMAX access bands around 2.5GHz and 3.5GHz, but higher up in the 28-31GHz or LMDS range. Is this a return of the disastrous LMDS bubble of the turn of the century or does XO represent a real and profitable shift to wireless backhaul?

It is hard not to believe that there will be an alliance between XO’s planned roll-out and Clearwire. XO sprang from the ashes of NextLink, a failed broadband wireless operator heavily backed in the late 1990s by Clearwire chief Craig McCaw, and he has retained links with the new entity, to the extent that it was widely rumored Clearwire would use XO to backhaul its pre-WiMAX services.

One asset XO inherited from NextLink was a near-national set of spectrum licenses, mainly in the 28-31GHz or LMDS range, and including over 70 metro areas. It is the largest owner of spectrum in this band in the US, with 101 LMDS licenses of about 1GHz of spectrum, covering 173m population. Although this spectrum proved uncompetitive for access services in the late 1990s – because of expensive proprietary equipment, limited propagation and non-line of sight capabilities, and immature demand ‘ there has been significant new interest in its potential for backhaul of access networks in lower reaches of the spectrum, such as WiMAX. More enterprises and 3G operators, as well as providers using WiMAX or Wi-Fi to deliver services, are looking to wireless backhaul instead of T1 leased lines. They are seeking to reduce costs as backhaul requirements mushroom with increased use of mobile data and the dense configurations required by 3G and Wi-Fi mesh networks. In many cases, wireless offers a lower cost and more flexible option.

This should create a readymade market for the new wireless entity, regardless of whether it ties up with Clearwire (which has been using wireless backhaul from Dragonwave in its early markets, in its own spectrum).

XO will sell its wireline business, along with the brand name, to a company called Elk Associates (although it said it is still open to higher bids, in which case it would pay Elk a 1% break-up fee). It is not moving too far from home ‘ Elk’s owner, investor Carl Icahn, is the controlling stockholder in XO too. The possible rival bidder could be Qwest, which ‘ having failed to take MCI ‘ badly needs to build up its own assets if it is to hope to expand and stay competitive in a market increasingly dominated by its three larger Bell cousins.

The wireless company will take a new name, still to be announced. The sale will repay outstanding long term debt, redeem outstanding preferred stock, and fund the growth and development of its wireless business, which will be debt free and have $300m in cash to fund operations. XO is already selling wireless to businesses and wireless service providers in select markets, and plans to expand coverage in the near future.

“The actions we take today will create a pure play fixed broadband wireless provider that combines significant resources with in-depth expertise to meet the growing demand for high bandwidth broadband wireless services,” said XO CEO Carl Grivner. “The market opportunity to provide these services has emerged, and our new focus on fixed wireless communications will enable us to offer robust fixed wireless solutions to business, mobile phone companies and wireline telecommunications companies.”

The XO deal is just one example of the new investor interest in LMDS spectrum, which is creating dangerously high valuations for some players in the space. For instance, First Avenue Networks, which ‘ as Advanced Radio Telecom ‘ was backed by Qwest and others during the last bubble, and bought the spectrum assets of another failed operator of that time, Teligent, is currently valued at $359m, on revenues expected to be about $1.3m this year. Teligent had a total of 350MHz of spectrum covering 75 markets. First Avenue’s main approach is to lease its spectrum to service providers for backhaul and other purposes. The company also has extensive holdings in 39GHz. Free of its wireline activities and debt, the wireless rump of XO may hope for a similar valuation multiple.

IDT, also looking to go public on the back of its extensive spectrum holdings, will have similar high hopes. IDT is the other main holder of LMDS spectrum, having bought the third of the best known US broadband wireless operators of the turn of the century, Winstar. IDT’s spectrum covers all 50 states and averages 615MHz capacity in the top 200 markets. The parent company is attaching new importance to the fixed wireless assets of its division and last year announced a reorganization that defocused on direct services to commercial customers and put the emphasis on exploiting LMDS, offering wireless backhaul to enterprises and operators, spectrum leasing to telcos, plus private line and wholesale offerings.

‘We recognize that the future of telecommunications is quickly moving away from traditional wired service towards new technologies,’ said IDT chairman Howard Jonas. ‘This reorganization directs Winstar/IDT Solutions’ assets to the sectors of the telecom marketplace with the greatest potential for growth. We are aggressively pursuing agreements with other carriers and cellular companies as well as integrating Winstar/IDT Solutions’ assets into IDT’s recently announced Wi-Fi phone service.’ IDT recently appointed former AT&T vice president John Petrillo as a new CEO.

Whether the intense interest in LMDS frequency owners is an irrational blip or a reflection of a genuine market trend depends on the answers to two questions ‘ is there real demand for these high frequency networks, and does the technology work this time around? In 1999, the answer to both was ‘no’, even though Microsoft, McCaw, several large telcos and countless venture capitalists thought otherwise and put billions of dollars behind their confidence.

In 2005, demand has certainly risen, although LMDS will be better positioned to backhaul access networks based on WiMAX, 3G or Wi-Fi than as a last mile technology in its own right, as it was in 1999 ‘ where it performed badly because of the short range of signals in high frequencies, the need for line of sight and the susceptibility to disruption in rain and fog.

The need for backhaul is mushrooming in the enterprise, 3G networks and Wi-Fi or WiMAX access systems, and there is a rising interest in shifting from wireline ‘ particularly leased T1 lines and their multiples ‘ to wireless. The main motivators are lower cost of ownership, a tendency to move costs from opex to capex budgets among cellcos, and the greater flexibility of wireless.

Now, new equipment is emerging for the higher bands, which while still expensive and proprietary, can be cost justified by the exploding demand for backhaul bandwidth ‘ and in backhaul applications, avoids many of the performance problems that dogged LMDS access.

One example is Dragonwave, whose equipment is used by Clearwire and which is now trying to break into the tier one cellco market, promising an all-IP solution to take on the more established wireless backhaul vendors such as Harris or Alcatel.

Its WISP customers typically use the Dragonwave gear to create ‘rings in the sky’ that can be used to backhaul access services, or to lease to other WISPs for their own Wi-Fi or WiMAX offerings. And there is a rush of start-ups to provide leased wireless backhaul for the new breed of broadband wireless providers, illustrating how, as the wireline market gets tied up between a very few players, wireless is promising opportunities for independents to carve out their own niches.

Among its users is WavMax Broadband, which claims it is working on ‘one of the largest high capacity wireless backhaul projects in the US’ from its Colorado base, using DragonWave’s AirPair 200 products. It has built a 400Mbps ring around Denver, which it calls SkyFiber, and which will be upgraded to 1Gbps next year. The plan is to expand nationwide to major metro areas, through expansion or acquisition, and to switch from its original focus on low cost access to concentrating on a wholesale and enterprise business, creating a ‘backhaul railroad’. Where it does offer access ‘ particularly in apartment complexes, ski resorts and hotels ‘ it uses Wi-Fi or pre-WiMAX systems. Its 90-cell site network currently covers about 3,000 square miles between Arizona and southern Wyoming.

Such all-wireless projects are being emulated by other WISPs like Towerstream and in trials by larger players like Qwest. Combined with the rising demand for wireless backhaul from cellcos and enterprises; the emergence of better equipment for LMDS; and the use of Wi-Fi or WiMAX for access, avoiding the need for line of sight in the last few yards, there is good reason to see a genuine new market for LMDS. Inflated valuations like First Avenue’s may hark back to the earlier bubble, but there is a real requirement here, and XO will not be the last company to dump its wireline operations in order to cash in on the shift to wireless in the higher frequencies.

BOX

XO, which forecasts revenues of $1.45bn this year, almost all from wireline, has had a turbulent history. It filed for bankruptcy protection in 2002 and having emerged, landed itself in several controversial acquisition attempts ‘ including failed courtship of Global Crossing and Cable & Wireless US – that often dragged it into court. In the end it bought Allegiance Telecom for $656m, beating Qwest to the punch. It has recently been a fervent opponent of the Verizon-MCI and SBC-AT&T mergers, which of course form a major threat to its business VoIP and wireline activities, and has brought complaints to the FCC of ‘tacit collusion’ between Verizon and SBC in pursuit of their purchases.