As expected, the European Commission has opened formal antitrust investigations into possible “abusive behavior” by Qualcomm, piling on more pressure on the US company’s famous licensing models.
Those models, as applied to its vast store of patents, have often been questioned and criticized, but rarely, until recently, formally challenged. However, the company has come under multilateral assault in recent years. It agreed a settlement with Chinese authorities earlier this year, to the tune of $975m in fines and changes to its licensing practices and fees; and it has also been the subject of probes in Korea and the US.
There are two investigations under way. The first European case concerns accusations that Qualcomm might be abusing a dominant position in cellular chips and standards-essential patents (SEP), by tying licensing deals into chip sales or offering financial incentives to customers to buy almost exclusively from Qualcomm. This case applies to both 3G and 4G products.
The second case, which is about 3G chips only, is investigating allegations of “predatory pricing”, in which a vendor charges below-cost prices in order to squeeze rivals out of the market.
Both practices are illegal under European Union law. Some of the charges echo those against Intel in 2009, which resulted in the chip giant paying fines of $1bn for offering financial incentives to PC makers in return for buying Intel processors only.
Margrethe Vestager, EU competition commissioner, said in a statement: “We are launching these investigations because we want to be sure that high tech suppliers can compete on the merits of their products. Many customers use electronic devices such as a mobile phone or a tablet and we want to ensure that they ultimately get value for money. Effective competition is the best way to stimulate innovation.”
Qualcomm’s own statement said: “This step allows investigators to gather additional facts, but it represents neither an expression by the Commission on the merits of the case nor an accusation against the Company. While we were disappointed to hear this, we have been cooperating and will continue to cooperate with the Commission, and we continue to believe that any concerns are without merit.”
There is no legal deadline to complete antitrust investigations and typically these European cases take years to resolve, but they create uncertainty for Qualcomm investors and customers, and raise new question marks over the sustainability of its licensing model – and therefore the level to which it can monetize its SEP assets – in future.