Vodafone obviously has a vested interest in talking up the success of M2M: it wants to sell SIMs to potential new customers, and it has been one of the most aggressive MNOs in pursuing the corporate side of this market.
But there is real growth there – while the M2M (machine-to-machine) sector currently only accounts for around 2% of its total revenue, it is growing at 25% as module costs plummet and awareness grows. Vodafone’s M2M Barometer is a pretty useful tool to track the progress of M2M, and it’s worth taking a deeper dive into it.
The report polled 650 businesses, and found that 76% had heard of M2M, up from 61% in 2014. In addition, 90% said M2M was relevant to their organization, up slightly from 86% the year before. On top of that, 27% said they had an M2M project in place, rising from 22% in 2014, with an additional 37% reporting that they had M2M projects ready to go live within the next two years.
By industrial sector, energy and utilities led the way with 37% adoption, followed by automotive on 32%, retail also on 32%, consumer electronics on 29%, healthcare and pharmaceuticals on 28%, but dropping noticeably to transport and logistics on 19%, with manufacturing on 17%.
The barometer looked at 16 countries, up from 14 in 2014, which were: Australia, Brazil, Canada, China, Germany, India, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Spain, South Africa, South Korea, Turkey, the UK, and the US. It also added SMEs (small and medium enterprises) to the respondents, and increased its number of interviews by 80% to 659.
Vodafone is keen to point out that once organizations started using M2M, they learned to evolve and expand their platform to support business transformations. 81% of the 2014 respondents who were using M2M said they had increased their use of it – in particular by adding new types of devices (55%), adding more connections (53%), adding data analytics (48%), and adding new connectivity types (45%).
In addition, the proportion of M2M adopters that were using dedicated data analytics had risen, from 75% in 2014 up to 81% this year. In total, 50% say they were using M2M to enable new business and operating models.
In terms of the return on investment (ROI), 83% of adopters felt they had gained a competitive advantage via M2M, with 38% agreeing strongly with that statement. In addition, 59% said they had experienced significant ROI, up from 46% in 2014. In total, 54% reported ROI within 12 months.
In terms of opex, nearly 10% managed reduce their costs by over 25%, with the average saving reported as 18%. That’s a compelling business case argument that businesses can make to their shareholders, and is one of the most powerful ways of improving a bottom line – as M2M is primarily deployed to improve the efficiency of existing operations, and therefore won’t be making shareholders uneasy by venturing out into the great unknown.
The most reported areas that benefited from an M2M deployment were process and productivity (52%), customer service (47%), speed/agility of decision making (46%) and costs (44%).
In terms of how M2M is integrated into the business itself, Vodafone found that the CIO leads the project in 36% of cases, with CEOs in charge 16% of the time – however, 63% reported using multiple leaders.
Around 46% of projects are charged to the IT budget, 42% are charged to the department that will benefit from the project, 30% of businesses consider it a cost of doing business and 29% charge the cost direct to the consumer.
The barriers to increasing the use of M2M were listed as security (33%), privacy (31%), high costs relative to potential benefits (29%), a lack of knowledge (26%), unproven technical performance or reliability (25%), lack of common industry standards (24%), and general economic slowdown (21%) – with difficulties implementing a global solution, regulation and management resistance all clocking in at 20%.
Vodafone also reports that M2M helps smaller businesses compete with the largest enterprises. It notes that 24% of businesses with between 100-249 employees are using M2M, compared to 35% of businesses with over 50,000 staff.
The report warns against generalizing that smaller companies are more agile than larger ones, and notes that “Now, thanks to cloud, some highly leveraged tech companies might servems of customers with a handful of employees. And M2M is having a similar effect: by automating processes using connected devices, businesses can make their employee headcount go much further. For example, car sharing service DriveNow is an SME, yet it has more than 460,000 customers, making it the largest service of its kind in Germany.”
In terms of geographical performance, AMEAP (Africa, Middle East and Asia-Pacific) reached the highest adoption rate (35%), with Vodafone attributing this to the region’s confidence, lack of regulatory hurdles and lack of legacy infrastructure. AMEAP members such as China and South Korea are also pushing M2M projects in national policy.
Europe had the largest overall growth, jumping 10 points from 21% to 31% adoption, with Vodafone noting that the German government’s support for Industry 4.0 is an attributing factor – but also strong growth from utilities and retail.
The Americas showed little change in adoption, with Vodafone saying that the inclusion of Canada has masked growth this year. However, the region leads on adoption among consumer devices, and smart homes and buildings, with more businesses reporting an ROI within six months (41%).
The full Barometer can be found here.
Meanwhile, a report by Telecoms.com Intelligence, The IoT Outlook 2015, found a surprisingly high level of confidence among operators, given that many have, so far, failed to formulate a convincing business model for the IoT beyond fairly conventional device management and connectivity services. Big data analytics, added value services and so on are good topics of conversation, but in the early stages, the firms in pole position are IT and over-the-top majors rather than carriers.
Nevertheless, whether this reflects heady optimism or some real rabbits about to be pulled out of operator hats, 62.4% of the survey respondents said they were confident about monetizing the IoT by 2020 (Telecoms.com interviewed almost 1,000 professionals working for operators, but did not specify how many companies that involved). The highest hopes revolve around industrial and home segments, with 47.2% and 31.1%, respectively, seeing those as the most lucrative areas.
As for barriers to success, security (42.4%) and platform standardization (37.2%) were the most cited challenges, and only 10.2% of respondents said there would be confident of delivering a fully secure IoT service today.
Where the survey findings most clearly reflect the self-interest, or wishful thinking, of the respondents is in the attitude to the carrier networks. In a world of licence-exempte spectrum options – low power WiFi, long range Bluetooth, Low Power Wide Area technologies like Sigfox and LoRa, and new options yet to emerge – 62% still believe the IoT could not exist without radio networks managed by operators. The main reasons are that there will be many critical applications that require security and prioritization, which will be best carried out by the network operator in licensed spectrum.
However, there is awareness that cellular will be one solution among many. The biggest section of the response base (55%) thought that the share of IoT traffic running over mobile networks in 2020 would be in the 20% to 60% range.