Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 June 2015

Qualcomm pushes home MU-MIMO lead

We’re a little baffled by this week’s announcements from Qualcomm Atheros about its new MU-MIMO WiFi chips, the QCA 9984 and 9994, as these seem to be very different from the chips launched back in spring 2014.

Analysts from Wireless Watch’s sister service, Faultline, say that Qualcomm has moved away from its previous stance, that three multiuser streams were enough for MU-MIMO (a technology which characterizes Wave 2 of the 802.11ac gigabit WiFi standard). Its previous generation devices – the QCA9980 and QCA9982 – supported three streams, and like Broadcom’s Manny Patel, director of WLAN business development, Qualcomm argued that this was sufficient. For instance, a 4×4 MIMO device might only deliver on three streams in terms of real world performance, because the fourth stream would be used mostly to null the other three in the directions they didn’t wish to go.

Qualcomm, after almost two years of boasting a MU-MIMO chip (having been second to market only behind the exceptional Quantenna), is now lining up its customers in public. Its latest announcements have supporting quotes from a number of vendors including Dell, Acer, Linksys, TP Link and Netgear, as well as Xiaomi, Numbia, Amped Wireless and Hitron. That doesn’t mean that all of these will go exclusively with Qualcomm for Wave 2 802.11ac, but it suggests they will all use the chips in at least one product, highlighting what a thorn in the side of global WiFi leader Broadcom its San Diego rival has become.

Broadcom came to market with a 4×4 802.11ac chip at the Consumer Electronics Show in January, at the same time as Marvell and MediaTek. It took the line that earlier launches from Qualcomm Atheros and Quantenna had been premature and unproven. But Qualcomm’s customer list suggests otherwise, and attests to the benefit of the market headstart – some analysts have even ventured that Broadcom has lost the lead in the WiFi market virtually overnight.

In fact, Qualcomm’s early market share is likely to have been based on older chips which are now being updated to be more in line with those from Broadcom, Marvell and MediaTek, but the early position will certainly be valuable. The company has added, with these updated chips, the ability to target 160 MHz channels or two non-contiguous 80 MHz channels, inside the 5 GHz WiFi bands. The QCA 9994 can also support 5 MHz bands, which is ideal for public safety applications. Qualcomm says that the new QCA9984 is designed for home routers and the QCA9994 is for enterprise access points.

To address 160 MHz, a device needs two antennas on each chunk of 80 MHz, and can switch between the two 4×4 in 80 MHz, or 2 x2 in either 160 MHz or two separate 80 MHz networks.

The peak speed is cited as the same that Quantenna and others have been quoting for years in 4×4 devices – but it’s actually realistic in MU-MIMO, at 1.7 GHz. In order to actually achieve that throughput with SU MIMO, a 4×4 receive chip is needed, because SU-MIMO WiFi does everything sequentially. If it is talking to a 1×1 chip it is at best talking at 433Mbps, because that’s all the device can receive. It then goes onto the next job. It only gets higher if all four radios are talking at once and being heard by four radios at the other end. In MU-MIMO it can talk at 433Mbps to four devices at once.

What is far more interesting than any of this is the idea of bandwidth agility. This means that the radio can move seamlessly between channel widths on a packet-by-packet basis and achieve greater spectrum efficiency and throughput. If there is less interference and signals are in the same room, a device may indeed opt to send in a single 160 GHz channel for higher speed, and if it is through a few walls, it may want to send to as many concurrent devices as it can in MU-MIMO mode.

But doing this on a packet by packet basis is tricky. It may mean jumping in an out of pre-established configurations, or it might mean looking at information on other channels and swapping to a channel it also knows has less interference on it. To do this is hard work and requires constantly updated information on the conditions of those channels, but it is key to how some video specialists use existing chips, and is already be done in software.

Meanwhile Qualcomm also unveiled what it calls the first hybrid wireless extender which uses HomePlug AV2 MIMO alongside its 802.11ac WiFi. This is simply a range extender that repeats the WiFi signal after going over a Homeplug AV2 powerline. It has two, one that works with a single stream over the Powerline, and one that uses MIMO and both outputting to 802.11ac devices. Range extenders have been enabled by the 1905.1 standard for interoperability between Homeplug or MoCA, and WiFi, and will soon be joined by products that are built around G.hn. Qualcomm has signed up Zinwell to build a product using this chip.