As mobile operators move from trials and spot deployments of LTE, towards nationwide coverage, the next big decision is how soon to turn off older networks.
Some carriers, such as Japan’s NTT Docomo and Softbank, switched off 2G services as early as 2012, and AT&T is looking to do the same at the end of next year. But others, especially in Europe, are looking to keep their GSM networks running for years to come, turning off 3G first. Telenor Norway is in this group, revealed its CTO, Magnus Zetterberg, at the company’s investor day this week.
Zetterberg said the plan is to shut down 3G completely in 2020, but to keep 2G running until at least 2025. The firm has been rolling out LTE since 2012 and the 4G network now accounts for 60% of Norwegian mobile data traffic.
Companies which are considering a short life for 3G have various factors in mind. GSM offers relatively low power levels and low cost chips, and so may support internet of things (IoT) services in the period before the 3GPP finalizes LTE-based standards for ultra-low power connectivity. These efforts, including the LTE-MTC and Cellular IoT proposals, are likely to be included in LTE Release 13 during 2016 and will give MNOs a weapon against alternative, non-cellular approaches such as Sigfox or LoRa.
Also, 2G is generally deployed in lower frequency spectrum (900 MHz and 1.8 GHz) than 3G, and so provides more cost-effective ubiquitous coverage for applications which require that, including voice, critical communications and some IoT services.
For most carriers, it will be some years before LTE covers every corner while also supporting mobile voice – hand-off to GSM, along with WiFi, will continue to fill the gaps in LTE, and particularly VoLTE, availability.
By contrast, in many cases 3G was never ubiquitous, and its relatively high frequency spectrum (2.1 GHz in most regions) may be attractive to refarm for 4G data, or for carrier aggregation with LTE’s spectrum. While the 1.8 GHz GSM band is also a good candidate for repurposing for 4G – an approach already taken by some operators such as the UK’s EE – the 900 MHz 2G band has less capacity and is not being widely refarmed.
Zetterberg told investors: “It’s better to retain 2G than 3G because all the devices today are still embedded with 2G, so you will lose out without the network. 2G is still important for the M2M market.” He said Telenor is increasingly focused on a data-centric business model as voice revenues decline, and its plan is to “dismantle legacy networks and eventually phase out 3G in 2020, before closing out 2G by 2025 and complete the data transition”. By the end of 2016, he expects to cover 99% of the Norwegian population with LTE, and the carrier will start to roll out LTE-Advanced and VoLTE from later this year, with completion after 18 months.
CEO Berit Svendsen reiterated the reasons for repurposing 3G spectrum and focusing almost entirely on LTE, telling the event that Norway is seeing a “huge amount of data in the country, that is now following similar patterns we once saw in the US and Asia”. Harnessing that data traffic will be the main way to compensate for the loss of up to NOK550m ($70m) in top line revenue in 2015, following the acquisition of Tele2 Norway by rival Nordic telecoms group TeliaSonera. That is costing Telenor its wholesale agreement with Tele2. Norway accounts for about one-quarter of Telenor’s group revenue.
Not all operators, of course, are staying loyal to 2G, and the fate of these networks will
vary in different parts of the world. Some carriers are racing to switch off the old systems and repurpose the spectrum to add 4G capacity, especially those in the CDMA market, or with very good 3G coverage. As well as carriers which want to keep 2G for M2M applications, there will also be some in in emerging economies, where there has been very little 3G build-out beyond urban centers, which will retain GSM, and then move directly to the more spectrally efficient LTE as demand for data services grows.
As is often the case when it comes to network transitions, the Korean MNOs plus NTT Docomo, AT&T and Verizon Wireless have had the most ambitious plans. Along with Australia’s Telstra, they aim to switch off 2G as early as possible.
Having initially been so confident about its successive world-beating HSPA+ upgrades that it was quite lukewarm about the need for LTE in the short term, Telstra changed its tune a couple of years ago and started to deploy LTE and now, elements of LTE-Advanced including carrier aggregation across 700 MHz and 1.8 GHz. It will close down 2G by the end of 2016, one of the first carriers to put a firm date on the change.
In a website post in July headlined ‘It’s time to say goodbye, old friend’, Mike Wright, group managing director of networks, wrote: “There is no doubt that 2G changed the world of mobile communications and we should all be grateful to the pioneers of the GSM standards. Closing 2G isn’t viable for many markets yet with more efficient standards such as LTE, wouldn’t it be a great leap forward if we could refarm much of the 2G spectrum, build global LTE scale and get to a point where LTE devices approached today’s 2G price points? If that were possible so much more of the planet could truly be connected into a broadband world.”
Telstra thinks it will get to that point in 18 months’ time, and will spend the intervening period explaining the options to customers and transitioning them. “We have seen steep declines in the number of customers on 2G to the point where today 2G traffic accounts for less than 1% of our total network traffic. We have not sold a 2G phone for several years,” Wright said.
Telstra will not know exactly how it can repurpose its GSM frequencies until ACMA finalizes its plans to reconfigure the band.
Meanwhile, many operators are using at least some of their GSM spectrum for LTE, while some regulators are issuing more of these frequencies. This is mainly taking place in the 1.8 GHz band, which is now the most commonly used for 4G, but there is even some activity in the less capacity-rich 900 MHz area of spectrum. For instance, Russian regulator SRFC said last summer that it would allow operators to use the GSM frequencies in 890-915 MHz and 935-960 MHz for LTE. The 1.8 GHz spectrum was cleared for 3G/4G last December and the agency has also now permitted LTE in the 2.5 GHz band, currently used for MMDS pay-TV.
In the US, the 1.9 GHz PCS band is the main one which will be refarmed from CDMA or GSM to LTE , a process already begun by AT&T, which says it is about halfway through the migration of 2G customers before it shuts the network down by the end of 2016. While most handset users will naturally migrate as they buy new devices, AT&T admits that the process is more complex when it comes to M2M, since a “large number” of its 17m M2M connections are still on 2G. Having GSM, rather than the less global CDMA, helped AT&T in the early days of M2M services but now it will find itself targeted by rival offerings from Sprint and T-Mobile, geared to those customers which do not need high data rates and value the low device costs and the coverage of 2G.