First it was China, now Russia – a giant market aiming to create its own mobile platform, reducing reliance on western technologies and patents and becoming self-sufficient. Russia wants to create its own smartphone operating system, according to minister of communications Nikolai Nikiforo, to squeeze the power of Apple and Google, and seems focused on using Jolla’s Sailfish as the basis of it.
This has all kinds of echoes of the past. China has repeatedly tried to create its own platforms in the mobile world, from its WiFi security system, WAPI, to its own 3G standard, TD-SCDMA. Early this year, a government-backed mobile OS, COS, was unveiled, with similar objectives to those voiced by Nikiforo, to provide a localized source of innovation and developer effort, which would create an optimized platform with low royalty fees.
But in reality, few of those Chinese attempts have succeeded, even in the home base, with the exception of TD-LTE – but that, though initially heavily backed and developed by Chinese players, is an international effort and has gone through global standards bodies. That means Chinese firms will have a greater IPR position in LTE than in previous standards, but as part of a global system, not an island of technology. By contrast, the island mentality – as seen in WAPI, the WiFi overlay which was licensed only to a few Chinese vendors – has never achieved significant results.
The same is sure to apply in Russia. Like Alibaba and Baidu in China, the country has its own mobile software giants, which are capable of creating powerful alternatives to Google’s and Apple’s services and platforms – but on a commercial basis, not by seeking to cut Russian consumers off from the rest of the mobile OS world. In particular, Yandex, the leading search engine in Russia, has been steadily creating a fully fledged mobile experience and app store, based around heavily customized Android user experiences which exclude Google services.
So Russia’s ambition, while understandable in the current tense political climate of trade sanctions, is unlikely to reshape the commercial landscape. Nikiforo says he aims to reduce his country’s dependence on foreign technology from 95% today, to 50% in a decade’s time, in terms of the number of users. That means, apparently, harnessing technology from a small player, which it can control, and from a non-US firm. In the wake of the Edward Snowden revelations, Russia demanded that some hi-tech suppliers disclosed their sourcecode to check for security back doors, but Apple, among others, refused to do so. Nikiforo may feel more comfortable with Jolla, which hails from Russia’s neighbor Finland.
There are already government initiatives to fund developers to migrate their apps to the Sailfish OS, which is based on the same open source code as the Nokia/Intel MeeGo OS, which was a casualty of Nokia’s decision to adopt Windows Phone. However, it currently has an estimated 0.5% of the Russian market, despite a deal last year for Yandex to sell Sailfish apps alongside Android ones in its store.
Yandex has a far better chance than a government scheme of wooing consumers away from Google – its platform is Android-based, but it has created its own version using the open sourcecode underpinning the Google OS, not the official Open Handset Alliance specifications, which might be considered suspect by the Russian authorities (though they are royalty-free).
Last year, Yandex launched its Kit, which provides a pre-packaged suite of services to replace Google’s, and was immediately adopted by Huawei for devices the Chinese vendor planned to sell in Russia. The suite includes email, mapping, browser, 3D launcher, and Yandex.Store, which boasts around 100,000 apps.
The kit is free, as the Russian web giant’s aim is to increase uptake of its services, and even extend them outside Russia on the back of foreign OEMs. It will take a cut of app store revenues and offer customization so manufacturers or operators can brand the services themselves. Huawei uses the firmware on a Russian version of its Honor 3 handset, and local vendor Explay does the same on its Flame device.
Yandex insists this is not an Amazon-style fork but a layer on top of the basic OS, providing system tools, apps and services but remaining compatible with mainstream OS and updates. Alexander Zverev, head of mobile ecosystems, said in an interview: “When smartphone manufacturers use the Android platform, they normally have to stick to Google’s services ranging from search to application store. We are offering a full-fledged alternative here, and we are among a few companies in the world capable of doing this.”
Yandex had 62% of the Russian search market in early 2014 compared with Google’s 27%, according to local research firm LiveInternet. Those kind of figures should make Nikiforo pause before repeating China’s mistakes of the past, and look to Russia’s local innovators to squeeze Google all by themselves.