The company which is left most vulnerable if the two major UK mergers go ahead is Vodafone, which will be left as the smallest mobile player in its home territory. It has so far been cautious about launching a full quad play offering, saying earlier this year that it would wait to see what BT did.
Now there is no doubt about the incumbent’s high ambitions, Vodafone will have to act, perhaps with an acquisition of its own. While it has significant wireline operators in Germany and Spain, in the UK it only has its C&W Worldwide purchase, which is mainly geared to enterprise services. To attack the residential space, it could eye TalkTalk, or pursue the repeatedly rumored merger with Liberty Global, which would bring it the UK’s leading cableco, Virgin Media, and similar assets in many other European countries.
Indeed, Liberty Global chairman John Malone reignited rumors of that mega-merger this week, saying, in an interview with Bloomberg, that Vodafone’s cable interests in Europe would be a “great fit” with Liberty’s, especially in the UK, Germany and The Netherlands. “We’ve looked at that from our side and there would be very substantial synergies if we could find a way to work together or combine the companies with respect to western Europe,” he said, though refusing to comment on whether talks had actually been initiated.
He did strike a more cautious note too, acknowledging that there are “huge differences” in how the two firms are run. “Their philosophy is low leverage, low risk and high cash payout to their shareholders. I prefer to grow equity value,” he commented.
For now, Vodafone has to keep thinking about scenarios that do not involve M&A, since any deal it considers will attract regulatory scrutiny and possible delays or blocks. At the call to discuss its fiscal year results (to March 2015), CEO Vittorio Colao confirmed that Vodafone would go ahead with a broadband launch in the UK “in the coming weeks”, and it will add the TV element of the quad play later this year.
So far, so predictable – and really just a catch-up move. With BT/EE in play, probably around year end, Vodafone has six months to do something eye-catching and turn itself from follower to innovator. This could involve becoming a content provider, either by acquisition or by acquiring rights to interesting exclusive offerings – as BT and BSkyB have done in the sports and movies arena, as well as large over-the-top players like Netflix and Amazon.
This is an expensive and highly competitive game, and Vodafone’s previous attempts to differentiate itself with its own mobile content and portals have not made much impact on the market. However, there are different pressures at work now. These were highlighted last week by Vodafone’s former US partner Verizon, which did a U-turn and became a content (and advertising) provider via its acquisition of AOL.
Content is a way to differentiate, to establish strong consumer brand awareness (and hopefully attachment), to play the OTT giants at their own game, and to avoid the dreaded bitpipe role. For these reasons, it is looking attractive to mobile and fixed-line operators, despite all its risks and pitfalls – not least the lurking presence of Google’s YouTube and the changing video consumption habits of the young.
There is also the drive to squeeze far better revenues and profits out of the carriers’ huge investments in 4G and fiber networks, which will only continue as they move towards ‘5G’. The modern networks are more cost-efficient, but they still cost large sums – Vodafone’s £19bn Project Spring is weighing on its results, and clearly it will ask how that is justified if the main result is to enable other companies’ 4K revenue streams, leaving just a basic access fee for the network operator.
In the UK, LTE customers can already access services from satellite TV provider BSkyB and online music offering Spotify, but this is very much an add-on for mobile subscriptions, not a full multiplay.
Colao said, on the earnings call, that any move to procure content directly would have to be taken on a market-by-market basis because regulatory environments vary. He commented: “It’s very early for us but in some markets we are starting to think about it … BT is buying content and not really giving it to everybody. We will have to see if this becomes a delicate key success factor for new customers.”
He lashed out at Telefonica for “closing up the content fort” and being a highly “obstructive” incumbent. Telefonica recently acquired Canal+, getting about 85% share of the Spanish pay-TV market. Vodafone is clearly determined to disrupt the situation following its acquisition of fixed-line provider Ono but it will be tough. “The Spanish regulator has strangely said that 50% of TV channels should be made available at reasonable prices without saying what is reasonable,” said Colao.
The key enabler for mobile content will be the Project Spring modernization, which will extend LTE coverage, and add in LTE-Advanced capabilities such as carrier aggregation where required, as well as LTE-Broadcast and other technologies to boost video offerings.
Colao said that Project Spring was 63% complete on the mobile side, and Vodafone now claims to be Europe’s largest 4G operator, with coverage of 72%. It had 20.2m 4G customers across 18 markets at the end of March, while data volumes grew by 81% on-year in the quarter. And there is still much growth to be had. Colao said: “We have significant opportunities ahead of us, with only 13% of our European mobile customers using 4G, and our market share in fixed services only a fraction of our share in mobile.”Project Spring is also important to competitiveness in the emerging economies – it has pushed 3G coverage for Vodafone India to 90%, for instance.
But the profits on those data revenes will be progressively squeezed – as the French market has already witnessed – unless Vodafone can derive more added-value revenues from its network upgrades, which could range from enterprise services to content to the internet of things and big data. That will be important to reduce its reliance on expensive acquisitions to drive growth, and to build on signs of stabilization in its organic performance.
This was seen in its fiscal year results, which signalled a welcome return to relative calm in the European telecoms market, which has been hit for the past seven years by recession, consolidation and price wars. Vodafone reported a 10.1% year-on-year increase in sales to £42.2bn ($65.3bn) in the fiscal year to March 31, and EBITDA up 7.5% to £11.9bn ($18.4bn). However, on an organic basis, revenues were down by 0.8%, and EBITDA by almost 7%, indicating the importance of acquisitions, especially of fixed-line players, to Vodafone’s continuing growth.
They carry costs too. Adjusted operating profit dropped by 18.6% to £3.5bn ($5.4bn), because of a rise in charges associated with its recent acquisitions in Germany (Kabel Deutschland) and Spain (Ono). Net profit fell to £5.8bn ($9bn), from £59.3bn ($91.8bn), largely because of the impact of the sale of Vodafone’s 40% stake in Verizon Wireless, plus recognition of higher deferred tax assets in the year to March 2014.
Once feted by investors for its mobile-only status, as revenue growth has shifted to quad play services and content, the company has started to snap up wireline assets, such as KDG. In addition to the challenging economic and competitive environment, Vodafone’s European results have been hit by high spending on its Project Spring initiative, to upgrade its mobile and wireline networks.
Despite continuing pressures in Europe, Colao said there were “increasing signs of stabilization in many of our European markets, supported by improvements in our commercial execution and very strong demand for data”. This was evidenced by a slight organic increase in services revenue in the region in the first calendar quarter of 2015. That will be a welcome relief, however small the figure, after 10 successive quarters of year-on-year decline in this area.
And Colao was cautiously optimistic about a return to sustained organic earnings growth, predicting that Vodafone will generate between £11.5bn ($17.8bn) and £12bn ($18.6bn) in EBITDA during the next financial year.
Despite hopeful signs in the quarter to March 2015, the full fiscal year figures were still uninspiring in Europe, with full year service revenues falling organically in every market except The Netherlands and Romania. However, in the first calendar quarter, two other markets returned to organic growth – the UK and the Czech Republic – and declines were smaller in most other countries too.
The pattern of recent years has been for Vodafone to generate growth through acquisitions and new, multiplay services in Europe, and to rely heavily on its mobile services in emerging economies. Service revenues from Africa and Asia were up 7.1% in organic terms for the full year.
The operator’s total mobile customer base was 445.84m, with 4.76m net adds during the March quarter. It also had 12.05m fixed broadband customers, an increase of 289,000 during the quarter, with 11.28m of those in Europe, including 5.45m in Germany.