We have said multiple times that we are close to classifying Sigfox as an asset tracking technology, given the focus that the company has put on that application. Now, Semtech has taken a similar step, launching LoRa Edge as a new hardware and cloud service joint-offering, targeted squarely at asset tracking – and not long after unveiling LoRa in 2.4 GHz, citing its use in logistics.
The gist of the launch is that LoRa Edge will be offering a geolocation service, which uses a Semtech chip that has LoRa, GNSS, and WiFi. This combination allows it to look for nearby WiFi networks, backhaul that information via LoRa, and then estimate where the device is based on a global database of WiFi networks (one we suspect is being powered by Here, given a previous partnership). The GNSS option if for when there is no WiFi, and that data is also backhauled by LoRa.
We spoke to Pedro Pachuca, Semtech’s Director of IoT Wireless, regarding the launch, who explained that the offering was designed based on feedback gathered from multiple verticals – specifically transport, logistics, smart home, building automation, agriculture, industrial, and healthcare. To this end, the LoRa Edge offering looks to cater to any customer here that needs to keep tabs on assets, within these use cases.
Pachuca said that most customers found that using GNSS trackers was too complex, because of their reliance on WiFi or Bluetooth to communicate. Because you would need multiple hardware providers, for each of the different protocols, and then need to broker deals with the geolocation databases, this creates a complex and costly product and service.
This is where Semtech thinks it can win out, with its integrated chip and service, at a price that undercuts what could be done with a cellular-powered GNSS tracker. It should remove some of the duplicate components in the device designs, particularly in power management, which Pachuca said is a big headache for developers.
In terms of battery life, Pachuca thinks that these should last 3 to 5 years in the field, and stresses that rechargeable trackers are not a good idea, as they become as burdensome as trying to replace batteries. That problem scales immensely with volumes deployed too.
The ball park cost for devices built on the new LR1110 chip offering is $20 to $50, estimates Pachuca, who noted that it really depends on how the customers choose to differentiate their products, and then how these OEMs choose to integrate them into the Semtech cloud offerings.
The relative high power usage of these other trackers means that they are often lost, as they have died and cannot be found. Pachuca said this can account for around 30% to 40% of GNSS trackers deployed, which is a pretty significant cost, as these devices have been built to handle indoor and outdoor tracking – a complex task, as GNSS does not work indoors and you need an alternative.
In a similar vein, not knowing exactly where these devices are immediately devalues the data that is pulled from them. Accidental or malicious movement of the device can ruin the value proposition, so being able to accurately locate it and check that it is still in the right place is important – whether that means on the right asset, or in the right position on the asset too.
Semtech claims that its system conveys big battery life savings to the device, as the cloud element is the one running the location processing workload, and not the device. However, Semtech is not making its cloud a mandatory component, as Pachuca said that if customers want to bring their own cloud services, they can do just that.
However, Semtech would like customers to use its cloud, as it is a way to move out of the semiconductor business and into the software and services game – something that should improve margins. In Semtech’s most recent quarterly results, it reported that the semiconductor products group generated $141mn in revenue. Signal Integrity accounted for 42% of that, with Wireless and Sensing (the part that houses its LoRa elements) on 30%, and Protection holding the remaining 28%.
To this end, LoRa is not the majority of the business, and likely won’t be for some time. Semtech’s data center and optical networking offerings are more lucrative, but we have been told that the Wireless and Sensing unit is the growth engine. However, when you look back in those Q3 results, you will see that Wireless and Sensing only grew by 1% from Q3 2018 to Q3 2019. Similarly, in the first three quarters of 2018 and in 2019, Wireless and Sensing was flat – at 31%.
Another interesting tidbit from the quarterly results is that Semtech derives 75% of its sales through distributors, with the other 25% coming from direct sales. In terms of geographical demand, 75% of total sales are in APAC, with North America accounting for 16% and Europe on 9%. Specifically, China and Hong Kong accounted for 50% of sales in Q3, down from 55% a year ago, with the USA flat on 10% in both.
As for tech-specs, the LR1110 is a sub-GHz LoRa radio, not 2.4 GHz, but has a multi-purpose front end that supports 150 MHz to 2,700 MHz, so it can do the WiFi and GNSS (GPS and BeiDou) functions. It is fully compliant with the LoRaWAN standard, and features a cryptographic engine for secure encryption key storage and processing.