Sprint Nextel’s much anticipated joint venture with Clearwire to put the Xohm WiMAX business on a viable footing remains mired in negotiation and pleas for funding, and now the final death knell has been sounded for the operator’s other once visionary partnership, Pivot. The venture set up in 2006 with four leading cablecos promised to create a quad play alternative to those of AT&T, Verizon and potentially Dish/EchoStar; to give Sprint a major and guaranteed customer for its CDMA and WiMAX networks and a huge expansion of the MVNO model that effected its mid-decade turnaround; and to provide the cable providers with a relatively low cost, low risk route into mobile broadband. Like Xohm, the vision was grounded by Sprint’s operational and financial problems, the negativity of its board, and the political wrangling and shareholder nervousness of the partners. The Pivot venture, its wings fatally clipped, had made little progress and is now officially dead, and one of the partners, Comcast, looks set to break free from the other three (Time Warner Cable, Cox and Advance/Newhouse) and pursue a unilateral route into convergence.
Comcast has not only pulled out of Pivot ‘ with its existing cellular subscribers, like those of the other three, being moved directly to Sprint’s own customer base ‘ but is reported to have set up its own wireless unit in preparation for launching a mobile offering, and various quad play bundles, under its own brand. Presumably it would use the network of another cellco, or a shared network built in the spectrum it owns jointly with its three cable allies via their SpectrumCo venture (Sprint was also part of this when it bid in the 2006 AWS auction, but subsequently pulled out, the first sign of the cracks in the marriage). But it seems to be turning its back on the idea, to which the four cable majors have clung since they started discussing wireless plans seriously in 2005, of not only sharing network and spectrum costs but also launching a combined brand. What is now unclear is whether Comcast would look to establish its own wireless brand on a near-national basis, via roaming deals with other operators, or just within its cable territories.
The strongest indication that Comcast is planning a wireless launch in the next two years or so is its hiring of David Williams, the well respected former CTO of Telefonica O2 Europe, to ‘explore wireless options’, as the cableco put it in unofficial comments. Williams is well qualified for this strategic role ‘ as well as his experience at multinational converged operator Telefonica of Spain, which he joined along with its acquisition of the UK’s O2, previous to that he was VP for strategic planning at Cingular Wireless, now AT&T Wireless, and so has knowledge of the US market. Before the creation of Cingular through the combining of SBC’s and BellSouth’s wireless units, er he was in charge of technological operations for the western region of SBC Wireless and helped integrate the company into the Pacific Bell Mobile network, which he had also helped create. So he has strong expertise in the creation of new networks, the integration of networks via partnerships or mergers, and the positioning of wireless operations within fixed and converged operators ‘ all of which could be highly relevant to Comcast, and to the other cablecos if the largest of them chooses still to work with its former friends in future.
As well as a reworking of the Sprint deal, and a decision on whether to act alone or with other cable companies, Williams is likely to be exploring more radical options too. Buying a cellco such as Alltel, T-Mobile USA (unlikely as Deutsche Telekom would only consider this at a very high price), or even Sprint Nextel itself might be considered, as would a JV with any of them to help them build some converged defences against the increasingly powerful big two. Even a satellite tie-up would not be out of the question ‘ AT&T and others are already in talks with mobile satellite firm Inmarsat about the possibility of using its planned network to expand their services, and Comcast could do the same. Comcast seems eager to start turning SpectrumCo’s assets to practical use ‘ most notably, it has $2.37bn of AWS spectrum in 1.7GHz/2.1GHz, suitable for 3G, LTE or even WiMAX. The grouping did not bid for 700MHz, but the cable leader is hotly tipped to be a bidder for NextWave’s AWS licenses, which are now up for sale (see separate item), and could even take its 2.5GHz assets too, especially as part of a venture with the WiMAX providers.
The fact remains that the best option for Comcast, or for a surviving cableco alliance, remains an alliance with WiMAX ‘ preferably with a combination of Xohm and Clearwire, which the cablecos could facilitate with the injection of cash. This was rumored to be on the cards recently and although Comcast’s intensified interest in wireless is being widely taken as proof that it has tired of joint ventures, it could still be interested in investing in Xohm-Clearwire, alone or with its SpectrumCo partners. Indeed, it is almost inconceivable that Comcast would look to add a national wireless operation to its activities without working closely with partners, unless it goes for an acquisition or simple MVNO deal.
Last month, there were reports in the Wall Street Journal that three of the SpectrumCo participants had expressed themselves willing to invest a collective $1.6bn in Xohm-Clearwire, close to the $2bn Sprint was said to be targeting (Comcast was said to be the lead investor in the proposal, offering about $1bn, followed by Time Warner on $500m and privately held Bright House on $200m, with Intel and possibly Google also putting in smaller amounts). For the cablecos, this would be only a modest capital commitment to gain an advanced national wireless network and a measure of control and ownership in that ‘ better than just a wholesale deal, but stopping short of full investment in individual or shared new networks, something the operators have considered, but which has met with negative response from nervous shareholders.
Although Pivot may not have delivered on its scaled-back objectives, it does not preclude the cablecos and Sprint from making a new partnership, which would revive the more creative goals of the original Pivot vision. While Pivot dwindled into little more than a cross-marketing agreement for cable and cellular services ‘ and an unsuccessful one at that ‘ at the outset it was intended to be something far more ambitious, with the five partners investing in creating a converged fixed/mobile broadband service using Sprint’s CDMA and, later, WiMAX networks, and enabling the cablecos to match the convergence moves of the major DSL/fiber providers, and outdo the satellite TV operators. This would have given Sprint a massively important position in US media and telecoms, in effect leveraging the cablecos’ networks and customer bases to mount a challenge to Verizon and AT&T that would be impossible on its own. For this vision to materialize, Xohm needed to be part of the deal, and could be the sole basis of a new one – because it can deliver the kind of advanced services and true ‘broadband anywhere’ that will be essential for cablecos to stay abreast of the major telcos. It will also have the potential to carry the cable operators’ TV content wirelessly, reaching mobile or nomadic devices and new geographic regions.
Comcast is not the only cableco that may be considering a unilateral wireless move. Cox, which was not apparently involved in the new Xohm talks, was the only one to bid in the 700MHz auction and won 22 licenses (see Wireless Watch April 2 2008), while in December Time Warner Cable CEO Glenn Britt said his company had “no intention of building the fifth cellular network,” but said it would view partnerships and investments in 4G-related systems favorably, though only “as an offensive move’.
For Sprint, it is vital that it retains some close alliance with the cablecos ‘ it needs major partners to gain any of the scale and cashflow it requires to stay within sight of the leading telcos, and the only other option is to leverage Clearwire’s existing tie-up with EchoStar. If Comcast and Cox make alternative arrangements, it will be another major blow for the cellco’s recovery plans, both short term CDMA strategies and its hopes to build a new future in mobile broadband based on Xohm.
The end of Pivot:
It came as no surprise that the cablecos have officially dissolve the $200m Pivot partnership with Sprint Nextel. Pivot ‘was operationally complex,’ said Comcast spokesman John Demming. ‘It didn’t really provide us with the flexibility we needed for a national product.’
He added that Comcast stopped selling its Pivot-branded wireless service this week and will work to move its Pivot subscribers to Sprint Nextel – customers who move will get a free month of service. Cox will adopt the same approach within a month.
Neither Cox’s Ullman nor Comcast’s Demming would provide subscriber numbers, usage metrics or financial statistics, and Time Warner Cable gave no date for its changeover.
Sprint Nextel said it continues to work with a variety of cable vendors for services including VoIP and backhaul and that it is working with Cox, Comcast and Time Warner Cable to ‘determine alternate business structures’.
Pivot eventually reached 33 markets, but its owners stopped expanding the service in December and in February, Sprint removed Pivot from its retail locations. Last November, interim Sprint CEO Paul Saleh admitted that Pivot would not be expanded, saying the service had suffered provisioning issues and did not fit with Sprint’s plans to simplify its business, especially its retail offerings.
There had been predictable problems with integrating billing systems, but also the service had certainly not yet delivered on its vision of integrating TV, video and DVR functions across fixed and mobile platforms.
For grander plans like this, and real mobile broadband, to happen, the initial, relatively simple Pivot services had to be successful and well delivered, and this was not the case. In August former CEO Gary Forsee admitted Pivot’s progress had been ‘disappointing’ and it already seemed that the partners had fatally underestimated the complexity of, as he put it, ‘weaving the service into the cable fabric’.