Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 April 2008

Nokia rubs salt in Motorola’s wounds with vision of the new handset

Samsung solidified its position as number two handset maker behind Nokia in the first quarter of this year, with Motorola turning in another grim set of results. The fortunes of the various players highlighted the widening gulf between the vendors that understand the need for a whole new breed of mobile device, and those, like Motorola, that are struggling just to keep selling the old ones. So Nokia talked about openness and a whole new approach to handsets, and Apple, LG and Skype pointed to new approaches geared to the mobile internet – while Motorola saw sales at its handset unit crash by a massive 39% year-on-year.

Motorola’s loss was worse than expected, and since October 2006, its share of the global handset market has fallen from 21.1% to just 9.5%, with its native US its only surviving citadel, and even there it is losing ground to the Korean vendors and smaller players like Apple and RIM. This was Motorola’s worst ever quarter, with a loss of $194m narrowly outdoing the record $181m loss reported for the same period in 2007. Sales for the company as a whole fell 21% to $7.45bn, with the 39% drop in handset revenues to $3.3bn dragging down the other divisions, which are set to be separated when Motorola pursues its plan of spinning off the devices business ‘ a plan that is looking increasingly urgent, but also increasingly unlikely to attract the top-notch turnaround CEO it needs in order to win shareholder confidence, or a credible acquirer. The handset arm increased its losses by 80% over last year. The handset unit posted an operating loss of $418m, compared with a loss of $233m in the year-ago quarter.

In his analyst briefing on the results, CEO Greg Brown tried to focus on the break-up plan rather than the figures themselves. This could at least put the other businesses in infrastructure, home and enterprise mobility in a stronger position to build on their various strengths without being bled dry by handsets, but it is hardly a course of action destined to create a communications powerhouse, but rather a short term rescue plan for three activities that, without the unifying factor of devices, are likely to drift apart and become second tier players in their respective markets (see Wireless Watch April 15 2008). And there is an increasingly large question mark over whether the handset unit can survive at all, except as sad remnants following a last ditch and unattractive acquisition such as that proposed by India’s Videocon. In the first quarter, Motorola sold 27.4m phones, compared to 45.4m a year earlier.

Brown said in the analyst call: ‘During the first quarter, we made an important strategic decision to separate the company, creating two independent, publicly traded entities’, but would not enlarge on precisely how this would help avoid a repeat of the awful Q1. He has now said the handset unit is ‘of no strategic value’ to the company, something that is sadly becoming a self-fulfilling prophesy, though with the stunning lack of self-awareness for which he is becoming known, he also told analyst that Motorola is ‘a vibrant, very successful mobile device business with a fresh portfolio that is aggressive and competing effectively. These elements, I think, will allow it to compete ferociously in the future.’

Motorola’s already crippled share price fell a further 3.7% to $9.12 as the news sank in and Motorola warned of a ‘significant loss’ in the current Q2 as well.

The home and networks mobility division, whose flagship products are the cable set-top boxes, also had a bad quarter, with operating profits down 8% to $153m on sales up 2% to $2.4bn, although operating profits at the enterprise mobility unit nearly doubled to $250m, on sales up 5% to $1.8bn.

Meanwhile, Nokia and LG were showing how it should be done. Nokia has the market share and strong financial footing to be able to conceive grand plans that will help it steer, rather than follow, the next generation of the mobile device business as the industry moves towards open internet and true broadband ‘ and it certainly intends to take advantage of Motorola’s woes to reinforce its own position and leverage this to take that steering wheel in both hands. So as Brown was floundering through a dismal results briefing, Nokia’s CTO Bob Iannucci was setting out the Finnish giant’s strategy at The Mobile Future conference, sponsored by the universities of Carnegie Mellon and Berkeley. This was the flip side of the internet services vision often articulated by marketing chief Anssi Vanjoki, focusing on how the devices operations need to work with the fledgling software and services unit, and with the internet industry at large, to meet the challenges of the new mobile world.

Iannucci is in no doubt that a new model is needed, and that those of the telecoms and computing world are not appropriate any longer ‘ a theme on which he enlarged sufficiently to make it clear that Nokia aims to support a model that it will shape and lead, rather than helping to evolve an existing model that is largely in the hands of alternative power bases (Google and Intel in the mobile extension of the computing approach; the cellcos in the traditional telecoms system).

Iannucci said: ‘If we imagine the telecoms’ way of doing that, you imagine these smoke filled rooms where people make a decision, and seven years later, some outdated technology comes out. We can’t do that.’ But the companies coming from the PC world are not getting it right either, he claims, although they have presaged the shift in the value chain from hardware to software and then services. But the computer model is too dependent on a small number of companies setting de fact standards, he said, while the mobile market will need to be more genuinely open. In other words, challenges to Nokia’s power such as Google Android or Apple iPhone will be important but just individual examples of broader trends.

The flip side of this is that Nokia itself will not be able to control standards single-handed either, but it has already demonstrated its willingness to use its market weight to broker balances of powers between different interests, within the standards bodies or beyond ‘ and it is certainly shifting rapidly from loyalty only to its own technologies, such as Symbian, to embracing ‘ and, it hopes, influencing ‘ open systems such as Mobile Linux, while putting some of its own key offerings, like Series 60, into the open source process. Iannucci favors openness because it will enable the mobile vendors to discover the applications that will drive new demand, and will attract developers who will, at last, be able to develop once and target multiple phone platforms. ‘I presume that most of the value of the mobility world five years from now is going to be very different from anything anyone in this room can imagine,’ he concluded.

Such thinking will help put the vendors that ‘get’ the mobile internet model in the vanguard of the new revenue streams in the developed markets. Some of these are niche in terms of sales but important in their power to influence the direction of the industry ‘ Apple being the obvious example. The iPhone may be the least open handset platform in the world, with its carrier exclusives and software lock-ins, but through its marketing impact, it has demonstrated to the wider public the potential for a usable, attractive mobile internet device, and to the US carriers the reality of turning mobile internet usage into increased ARPU (the European operators have been less impressed). AT&T, announcing its first quarter results, said its data revenues were up 57% on the year-ago period, at $2.3bn, or 22%, of the total of $11.8bn, and it credited faster networks and next generation internet-focused devices, most notably the iPhone, with the increase. Inder Singh, an analyst with Lehman Brothers, wrote in a research note last week that AT&T’s users of ‘integrated devices’, such as the iPhone, deliver twice the data revenues generated by customers using other phones. ‘Management stated that its iPhone ARPU was over $90,’ noted another research note, from UBS, and it expects the second quarter launch of the 3G iPhone to drive growth further.

Apple may be the darling of Wall Street and AT&T, but it was actually losing market share in the first quarter, along with Motorola and Sony Ericsson, while the Koreans reaped most of the gains and Nokia consolidated its massive lead. According to Strategy Analytics figures, global handset shipments grew 14% year-on-year in Q1, to reach 282m units, the volume growth driven by Asia and Africa while the developed markets fell back, despite their increased appetite for high end phones, which helped keep margins at Nokia, Apple and others resilient (though Nokia sparked a fall in its own share price with warnings of likely drops in average selling prices this year ‘ see Wireless Watch April 22 2008). LG and Samsung scored because of their broad and recently refreshed handset portfolios. Apple was hit by ‘stock outs in North America and lackluster demand for its overpriced iPhone in western Europe’, according to analyst Neil Mawston. Apple saw global iPhone shipments fall sharply, from 2.3m units in the fourth quarter of last year to 1.7m units in the first quarter of 2008, pushing its market share down from 0.7% to 0.6%.

Among the larger players, Motorola’s share dropped from 12.4% to 9.7% in sequential quarters, and Sony Ericsson’s from 9.4% to 7.9%. While Nokia inched ahead from 40.6% to 40.9%, LG – growing at almost four times the annual industry average ‘ put clear water between itself and Sony Ericsson, with which it tends to swap fourth and fifth rankings regularly. It saw its share rise from 7.2% to 8.6% sequentially, coming in striking distance of Motorola’s. Fellow Korean Samsung was growing over twice the average industry rate and its share leapt from 14.1% to 16.4%.

All this highlights the fact that, before Apple had lit a fire under the mobile internet with its closed, non-3G, but undoubtedly sexy device, LG had ticked most of the boxes already and positioned itself, among the smartphone in-crowd, as the open multimedia handset cheerleader, foreshadowing many of the iPhone’s breakthroughs in models like the Prada. LG expects to see its handset shipments rise by 20% in the current quarter, while fellow Korean Samsung beat forecasts in Q1 with a 37% rise in quarterly profit on outstanding performance in cellphones and flat screens ‘ despite continuing disappointments in the chip division.

Meanwhile Sony Ericsson, last year the star performer among the handset majors, is struggling rather more now, as it tries to effect the transition from high margin smartphone specialist to broader, higher volume vendor. The joint venture reported a 47% year-on-year drop in its first quarter pre-tax profits to €193m, though this figure was slightly better than many analysts had been predicting. Sales were down 8% to €2.7bn. The main problem, predictably as Sony Ericsson chases market share in markets like India, was falling average selling price, down from €134 to €120.

In a significant reversal of the pattern of the past two or three years, which have seen market share increasingly concentrated in the hands of the top five phonemakers, sales by the other vendors have now started to grow, and not entirely because of Motorola’s problems. Vendors outside the top five accounted for 55.7m handsets, or 19% of the whole market, in the first quarter ‘ a total exceeded only by Nokia. In the first quarter of 2007, the ‘other’ category accounted for 18% of the total, with shipments about the same as Motorola’s. Key players are those with strong brands and highly differentiated, high margin products for well targeted markets ‘ including Apple, RIM and HTC ‘ as well as growth challengers from emerging economies, notably Huawei and ZTE, which are seeing most of their expansion outside their home country, especially in the US.

Skype:

Skype often points the way to the mobile internet, and its open VoIP strategy has been embraced most enthusiastically by Hutchison 3. But now the eBay-owned company has
released a beta version of its client software for mobile phones, which will work on about 50 Java-enabled phones from Motorola, Nokia, Samsung and Sony Ericsson. VoIP does not run end-to-end – Mobile Skype users will be charged for voice access.

Although 3 offers special Skype handsets with the software pre-loaded and a Skype button to invoke the service, this does not support SkypeOut, the low cost option for calling non-Skype phones. With the new client, this is supported and Skype can be run on supported phones under any network operator. Users can download the client directly to their mobile phones or transfer it via Bluetooth from their PCs.

However, as in the agreement with 3, Mobile Skype does not support VoIP over the mobile access leg of a voice call. While presence, contacts and IM will be supported over the data channel, voice will not ‘because Skype wants to keep the client light’, says the company. Instead, both SkypeOut and Skype-to-Skype calls will use a conventional radio voice channel (at local rates) for their first leg, meaning extra cost for the user. This may be because of the complexities of running VoIP over mobile broadband, or an attempt by Skype to win more support from cellcos by not disrupting their charging model entirely on day one.

Skype-to-Skype and SkypeOut calls from the supported handsets are initially available in seven markets ‘ Rio de Janeiro in Brazil, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Poland, Sweden and the UK.

Tier two operators are increasingly looking to take a lead in openness in order to steal a march on market leaders. 3, with moves like its Skype alliance, has been a prime example, aggressively pursuing the bitpipe ISP approach and seeing the rewards in greatly increased data revenues and ARPU. T-Mobile USA is taking a similar stand in its fight to close the gap with AT&T and Verizon, despite its belated roll-out of 3G. It has already used integration with in-home and hotspot Wi-Fi to good effect to support convergence and open internet services and has become one of the most unequivocal supporters, among cellcos, of the Google-inspired Android open development platform.

Last week, the carrier hinted at the Wireless Innovations conference in California that it was working on ‘a new approach’ that would see an increasing number of its handsets adopt open source mobile platforms. Joe Sims, general manager of new business development, said T-Mobile USA would open up its device platforms to developers via open software development kits and applications programming interfaces, and said this would reduce the time it took to develop new applications, from the current range of 3-9 months.