Industry maverick NextWave has surprised the market yet again with the decision to sell off its extensive US spectrum holdings in the AWS and 2.3/2.5GHz bands. With no further US auctions of spectrum suitable for mobile broadband due for years, and several major players disappointed in the AWS and 700MHz sales of the past 18 months, this is clearly a prime time for the company to divest its holdings and, in the US at least, turn its back at last on its original and ill-fated role as an operator, which ended up in the first incarnation of NextWave filing for bankruptcy protection. But perhaps that was not so ill-fated, or this latest move such a U-turn ‘ indeed, under the ambitious technology plans and complex business models that NextWave has outlined in the past year, lurks a far simpler beast, the spectrum speculator. The first time around, its massive investment in PCS licenses led to Chapter 11 and to huge swathes of spectrum lying unused, disputed and unpaid-for over the course of years ‘ but in the end, NextWave emerged like a phoenix, sold most of those licenses to Verizon, hung on to its 2.5GHz holdings just as this spectrum was becoming desirable, and delivered a healthy eventual return to its own investors (as the company likes to point out when reminded of its chequered past).
The fruits of spectrum speculation, second time around, may now fund the creation of a genuine technology business in WiMAX and LTE ‘ NextWave actually does have a couple of real crown jewels for the 4G world now, notably the TV system it acquired with IPWireless and the PacketVideo business. Backed by the likely proceeds of the spectrum sale, these could now form the nucleus of a well differentiated offering ‘ and NextWave would do better to focus heavily on the partnerships these advanced video platforms could attract, than to pursue its original one-stop shop strategy, offering new operators everything from chips to equipment to spectrum to support disruptive systems and applications.
One element of that spectrum-to-silicon offering will already disappear, of course, and we would be unsurprised to see many other components of the roadmap falling by the wayside too. The grand sounding plan to develop base station and CPE chips and systems – and drive sales by also buying up the spectrum to run them in – was ambitious enough when WiMAX was the only target (and even then, NextWave was trying to make up for being late into the game by promising ‘WiMAXplus’). Then it acquired IPWireless, lonely supporter of the TD-CDMA standard, the TDD implementation of W-CDMA that was once hoping to be a WiMAX killer. This made it logical for NextWave to address TD-CDMA’s successor, TDD LTE, too, but also threatened to stretch its resources and credibility further ‘ except that, with IPWireless, it gained the TDtv technology that the UK-based start-up had devised to give its TD-CDMA networks a commercial hook. In fact, this may prove the most useful technology NextWave owns, especially as it has been relatively easily adapted for WiMAX as well as TD-CDMA and, later, TDD LTE. It basically implements the MBMS standard, heavily backed by Ericsson, in TDD spectrum ‘ MBMS runs mobile TV over existing 3G networks rather than dedicated systems such as DVB-H and a TDD version will be of increasing interest as the balance of operators’ spectrum holdings starts to shift slowly in favour of TDD, to support broadband data services.
Huawei and Alcatel-Lucent have already partnered with NextWave for the WiMAX version, MXtv, and with Ericsson and the Chinese vendors working hard on TDD LTE, there would be a logical tie-up between NextWave and the Swedish giant for TDtv. This in itself – along with the plug-in devices the company has made for mobile TV, and the PacketVideo software ‘ forms an attractive integrated product range for an area of hot customer interest, and does not seem to require NextWave to venture into the hornet’s nest of competing with far better established silicon vendors in the mainstream WiMAX and LTE markets.
As for the spectrum sale, NextWave has signed up Deutsche Bank and UBS to help divest the assets, which include licenses and lease rights for a total of 4.7bn MHz/pops of spectrum including 154 AWS licenses in the 1.7/2.1GHz band, 30 WCS licenses in the 2.3GHz band, and 39 EBS and BRS licenses and leases in the 2.5 GHz band. NextWave was once expected to be a key player ‘ along with Sprint and Clearwire – in getting WiMAX a foothold in the US, and had trialled its own WiMAX-like systems in Las Vegas and other markets. That will not now happen, but the unexpected availability of a new tranche of AWS and 2.5GHz licenses could nevertheless attract a WiMAX operator, old or new, to buy them up and create a counter-balance to the expected dominance of LTE in 700MHz, where the two leading telcos hold the lion’s share. AWS is not an official WiMAX profile (nor is 700MHz) and it is largely an FDD band, but some vendors like Nokia Siemens have already demonstrated 802.16-based equipment for the spectrum (see Wireless Watch April 10 2006) and the WiMAX Forum is working on the FDD implementation of its standard.
So which parties might try to snap up some or all of NextWave’s horde? CEO Allen Salmasi is already talking up the assets, saying NextWave has received multiple offers since the 700MHz auction ended. The simplest answer would lie in operators looking to expand existing holdings:
Sprint and/or Clearwire in 2.5GHz, though probably they have enough spectrum already, especially if they do indeed form a joint venture, and Sprint might hit antitrust blocks;
AT&T or Horizon in 2.3GHz (AT&T has the 2.3GHz licenses it inherited from BellSouth, with a build-out mandate from the FCC, and to the surprise of some has chosen to hold on to them rather than sell them on);
In AWS, flat rate operator Leap Wireless, which was vocally angry about the fact that Verizon and AT&T were such convincing winners in 700MHz, and which needs to expand rapidly to sustain its growth now that its flat rate model is being emulated by the giants.
T-Mobile, which could look to supplement its AWS holdings as it starts its belated 3G roll-out and tries to work out a response to the 4G plans of its three major rivals.
Verizon Wireless and AT&T are always looking for additional spectrum to widen the gulf between themselves and any other challenger (except Sprint in mobile broadband terms).
Or the licenses could go to an operator with a more disruptive approach, but which balked at the high prices of recent auctions. NextWave will hope a few such parties at least get involved, in order to drive up interest and the price tag. Google will inevitably be mentioned as a candidate, though we should probably have learned by now that the search engine king is far more likely to support its favored open mobile access models indirectly ‘ perhaps by funding a new provider ‘ than by becoming a spectrum holder itself.
The most interesting option would be the cablecos or satellite providers. The mobile satellite and satellite TV players pulled out fairly early from the last two auctions, but both are looking to increase their terrestrial wireless capabilities to improve their cost structure and deliver new services (see separate item on Dish Network). The cablecos have been experimenting – individually or through the collective of Comcast, Time Warner, Cox and Advance/Newhouse ‘ with various ways of obtaining a wireless network in order to support a full quad play and keep up with AT&T and Verizon. These are perhaps the most likely no-traditional candidates to go after NextWave’s holdings, since their most hopeful-looking plan, a far reaching alliance with Sprint Nextel, has collapsed (see separate item), and Comcast, at least, is widely rumored to be on the brink of a wireless move. Working through their SpectrumCo joint venture, these four cable operators acquired significant AWS holdings and some 700MHz.
If the cablecos decide this is their last chance for ‘beach front’ spectrum and go head-to-head with one or more cellcos, NextWave could see a very healthy return for its dalliance in spectrum trading, more than enough to make a 4G video/broadcasting platform business very viable, and eventually very saleable. It paid very little for its 2.5GHz and 2.3GHz holdings ‘ like Sprint and Nextel, it bought these when high frequency broadband wireless licenses were considered junk spectrum, and now sees these bands taking their place as the centrepiece of 4G. When NextWave mark one emerged from Chapter 11, it sold off its PCS holdings, to Verizon and MetroPCS, for about $3bn ($398m of this returned to the FCC in settlement of the eight-year old dispute over NextWave’s failure to pay for the licenses. In 1996 it had bid $4.7bn for the PCS assets, but only paid the $500m deposit. But it kept about 10% of its spectrum, mainly in 2.3/2.5GHz, and then added a major chunk of AWS bandwidth in 2006, acquiring 154 licenses for about $140m. It has also acquired spectrum in other areas, notably in European 3.5GHz via a majority stake in WiMAX Telecom, but this is not currently on the table.
In the US, the spectrum has not been built out beyond a few test markets, but just by
demonstrating technology that can create an IP-based triple play class network across multiple, unrelated spectrum chunks, NextWave believes it has effectively increased the value of its holdings quite dramatically. On its books, the spectrum assets are valued at $528m, with $450m of that in renewable licenses or leases.
There has not been much slack in the valuation that is applied to NextWave, which has made borrowing to support its ambitious speculation and R&D programs expensive. Its shares trade around $6.5 ‘ down from $9.5 a year ago, with the company’s valuation reduced from $805m then to about $660m now. In full year 2007, its loss widened from $105m the year before to $320m, on sales more than doubled from $24.3m to $59.1m. The greatest portion of the revenue comes from IPWireless and Packet Video, the portable device software designer, which leads on video capabilities carried in pure IP packets. Packet Video came out of the compression and signal processing business, and set out to be a software company able to target the entire handset market, though its talents are now being harnessed strongly for TDtv and MXtv.
The two other core acquisitions, prior to IPWireless, were Cygnus Communications – which NextWave acquired for just $9.8m in February 2006, for a headstart in developing WiMAX semiconductors – and Wi-Fi mesh start-up Go Networks, for which it paid $13.2m upfront, with performance-based further payments. In January 2007, PacketVideo added the acquisition of tiny Swiss Secure Digital Containers for $19m in cash. In all, these acquisitions cost NextWave around $124m, and if we add those payments to the $528m of spectrum assets, and the $200m of cash, we reach $843m, which is less than the market capitalization NextWave had when it announced the purchase of IPWireless for up to $235m. Since then the value has fallen.
To say that the value is now under the net asset value isn’t strictly correct. When each of these companies were purchased there was plenty of goodwill in each case, and in the case of IPWireless, a considerable amount, especially given that it was more or less pre-revenue, or at least pre-volume revenue. But we can say that the sum of the value of NextWave is less than the value of the parts it has purchased. Which implies that either Wall Street doesn’t ‘get’, the NextWave proposition or more likely, only insiders get it and outsiders cannot yet afford to speculate on it until it proves that its plan is working. The sale of its spectrum assets may make it more attractive, and easier to understand.
This is reflected in the official line: ‘Since the completion of the recent 700MHz auction, we have received multiple offers for our US spectrum assets,’ said CEO Salmasi in a statement. ‘Given our continued success in developing highly differentiated wireless broadband and multimedia-enabled products, we no longer view our spectrum holdings as critical to reaching our product sales objectives, and believe that now is the perfect time for us to sell these valuable assets while network operators are trying to finalize their band plans and spectrum holdings for their continuing 3G and planned 4G roll-outs. Monetizing the value of our substantial spectrum assets would allow us to further strengthen our balance sheet, retire debt, and continue the commercial introduction of a wide range of innovative wireless broadband and multimedia solutions.’
The 700MHz spectrum map:
The controversy over the results of the 700MHz auction ‘ particularly the poor showing of independent or rural operators and the increased power of the leading two telcos ‘ continues, and the chair of the House of Representatives telecoms subcommittee, Edward Markey, has called ‘the decision to eliminate spectrum caps by the FCC under Chairman [Michael] Powell is proving highly ill considered ‘. The so-called ‘spectrum screen’ of 95MHz that has substituted for the original cap has been blown away in this auction by AT&T and Verizon in eight of the top 10 markets, and 17 of the top 25 markets, where that amount of spectrum has now been exceeded.’
If these claims prove to be true, the FCC will have to decide whether to demand that AT&T and Verizon Wireless return spectrum in excess of the 95MHz limit. However, according to reports by RCRnews, the case against the leading operators has been overstated, though they probably exceed 95MHz in a dozen or so large and small markets ‘ rather than the 38 out of the top 100 markets that some have claimed.
The screen – which is not an outright cap but merely triggers closer scrutiny for possible competitive damage in individual markets ‘ used to be set at 70MHz (for total spectrum in all mobile bands held in one market), but was increased to 95MHz when the FCC was considering AT&T’s acquisition of rural operator Dobson Communications last year, because 700MHz was about to be added to the mix. AWS and BRS 2.5GHz spectrum does not count towards the total as it is not significantly available throughout the country (due to government relocation and band realignment issues) at this time, though it may be included on a case-by-case basis.