The extension of PC-focused architectures into the handheld market is sparking new interest among hardware makers in low power chip platforms, as well as a desire to counterweigh the potential power of chipmakers sitting at the convergence of PCs and mobile devices, such as Intel. So last week saw two somewhat odd acquisitions of low power processor start-ups, with Sun buying Montalvo Systems of Santa Clara, California, and Apple snapping up PA Semi. Both seem to have invested primarily in IPR and engineering talent, and perhaps the chance to increase their own influence over the architectures underpinning key new products.
Montalvo is a secretive outfit that only emerged from stealth mode in February, having reportedly got through about $90m in VC funding in its quest to commercialize an x86 media processor design for low power, portable devices, featuring asymmetric cores’complex cores for heavy duty tasks and simpler cores for lightweight ones. However, it had hit problems in getting the silicon working and was said to be looking for a further $100m, while burning cash rapidly. Taking on the x86 market was always going to be an ambitious goal, even in the low power sector, now that Intel has ramped up its own efforts in that direction, targeting ultra-mobile PCs and eventually handsets and taking aim at ARM’s heartland. Sun is reported to have paid only about $5m for some of Montalvo’s IPR assets and a handful of its 300 staff.
The purchase points to Sun’s own efforts to evolve its microprocessor platform and adapt it for low power, portable products ‘ a battle that many believe it should abandon in favor of relying entirely on third party (mainly Intel) processors, and refocusing its value proposition on software like Java, especially in the handheld world.
Also determined to base some of its differentiation ‘ and its bargaining power with chip suppliers ‘ on its own processor technology is Apple. Despite its accelerating shift from PowerPC to x86 architectures following its landmark 2005 agreement with Intel, it has acquired ‘ in its typical secretive way ‘ PowerPC designer PA Semi, for a reported $278m. This deal sparked a wave of speculation that Apple was distancing itself from Intel ‘ or at least setting up a negotiating tactic ‘ with a partial return to PowerPC, and also that the fruits might go into a new portable device, such as a much rumored PDA version of iPhone, geared to RIM’s enterprise space and the Intel UltraMobile PC market. If true, this would be a major blow to Intel’s new flagship product, the low power x86-based Atom, its central processor for UMPCs and other mobile devices.
However, a more likely, though less exciting, interpretation is that Apple is not looking to continue to develop and use PA Semi’s dual-core PWRficient processor (despite its heavy installed base within the US Department of Defense), but has instead bought the company’s engineering expertise, especially in low power systems, in order to gain greater leverage over Intel and work more effectively with the silicon giant, to ensure future platforms are well geared to Apple’s mobile product roadmap. Insiders within PA Semi itself said they expected Apple to end production of PWRficient this year and last week the start-up informed its customers it was being acquired and could no longer guarantee supplies of its chips, as the acquirer (then unidentified) was interested in the IPR and talent, not products. It did say the buyer might be able to support PWRficient on an end-of-life basis, though this would depend on the transfer of a third party license (presumably a PowerPC architectural license from IBM, which enables PA to create its own PowerPC designs from scratch).
Most semiconductor industry watchers seem to think the Intel-Apple relationship is sound, and that Apple is not reneging on its recent strategy of using off-the-shelf chips for many new products (such as Apple TV and the Mac Mini). But research group Portelligent and its sister company, news service EETimes, point out that Apple may be trying to increase its influence over IC design at its supplier companies by enhancing its own silicon expertise and its inhouse design capabilities. This is a tactic already seen with regard to the iPhone, where Apple has worked with mainstream suppliers but insisted on considerable influence over their designs for the iconic handset ‘ a relationship it may, ambitiously, try to nurture with Intel too, for the x86 products, in order to create technological differentiation from rivals such as Sony or PC makers. Portelligent also believes Apple may need some proprietary silicon to handle digital media and refresh the video capabilities of most of its products. This was echoed by Richard Doherty, head of research group Envisioneering. “There are 100 flavors of video out there, and they want them all to look good on Apple products,” he said, saying that the Mac Mini and other key products need a refresh soon.
PA Semi was founded with its sights set on Apple, since its original target was to get its low power PowerPC processors (which consume only 15 watts while running at 2GHz) adopted for Apple notebooks, a hope dashed by the computer maker’s switch to x86. The start-up then had an uphill battle to attract mainstream customers outside the DoD, despite its strong technological heritage ‘ in particular its founder Dan Dobberpuhl, helped design Digital Equipment’s StrongARM chip, which eventually became Intel’s XScale processor, and later launched SiByte, which created a low power MIPS processor acquired by Broadcom. Apple’s likely killing of the PWRficient product line will be a favor to Freescale, the major PowerPC chipmaker, which has not achieved the same levels of power efficiency as yet, despite a stated focus on embedded markets.