In what promises to be the biggest LPWAN deployment to date, Indian telco Tata Communications has announced that following successful trials based on LoRa technology, it plans to roll out the first LoRa network in India – with Phase 1 covering 400m people, from Tier 1 to Tier 4 cities.
If Tata follows up on its promise, this a huge win for LoRa – with that 400m larger than its collective population coverage to date. Full Indian coverage would extend that to 1.2bn people, although being the seventh-largest country by area, realistically it’s unlikely even a very expansive rollout would not manage to achieve universal coverage.
Nonetheless, this is a very big deal, which is why it’s a little disappointing that no roadmap has been published. All that we know (publicly) is that the rollout will begin with full coverage in Mumbai, Delhi and Bangalore, before moving on to the smaller cities. We aren’t actually sure what the completion date is.
Tata says that its network’s 15km range and 50m underground penetration provides “unprecedented reach” and that customers will find it easy to deploy the Tata network, thanks to a pre-configured plug-and-play implementation that is tailored to different industry requirements. Again, it’s hard to tell from the announcement what role Tata will be taking in the actual deployment, and the company hasn’t responded to our questions yet.
Tata Communications is the telecommunications subsidiary of Tata Group, a rather large global industrial conglomerate with assets including chemicals, steel, automotive and even hotels. Tata Communications was ranked the sixth-largest telco in India this year, with 62.5 million subscribers, and the company also includes wholesale internet access, payment solutions, data centers, and submarine cable divisions. It claims to provide cloud, network or data services for 66% of the Fortune 500, with annual revenues of $3.2bn – 77% of which was generated outside of India.
“Tata Communications is dedicated to enabling cutting-edge, innovative communication solutions for the digital economy. Given our global network leadership, we have a bird’s eye view of how connected applications are permeating all aspects of people’s lives. We see a massive need for a new smart network to enable intelligent solutions for a variety of M2M applications, to facilitate a simpler and smarter way of life, and at a lower cost of ownership. These trials are just the beginning; we intend to deploy this network across India and invite customers with IoT projects to work with us to test it, end-to-end,” said Tata Communications CSO Tri Pham.
With LoRa, a company liked Tata can own its network entirely, with customers paying the Semtech royalty at the silicon level. A plethora of different companies offer the application platforms that coordinate the connected devices, but of course, the network operator could perform that function itself.
This is a different model to its main rival Sigfox, which allows users to pick from a number of different hardware vendors (by providing the Sigfox stack to manufacturers for free use), but maintains control of the cloud-layer functionality. The network infrastructure is built out by partnerships with other companies (like Arqiva in the UK or Abertis in Spain), who then receive a share of the network revenue.
Sigfox could of course partner with Tata to launch in India, or with Tata’s rivals, but the tradeoff for those partners comes in that question of ownership – where there is more choice at the hardware level with multiple Sigfox silicon vendors, but only one at the network level.
Similarly, the LoRa IP is owned by Semtech, and so the company gets a royalty for each chip sold, but through the LoRa Alliance, there is much more choice higher up the stack. LPWAN deployments are still a matter of swings and roundabouts – and it’s an approach that Weightless aims to address with its own open standards, although the technology has nothing near the scale of Sigfox or LoRa yet.
In addition, there are frequent jabs taken at each side of the LoRa-Sigfox divide, with advocates of each accusing the other of failings. Bouygues has gone on the record and said that after testing both technologies, it found LoRa gave better indoor penetration, with others saying (privately) that Sigfox’s uplink is problematic.
Private comments on LoRa’s struggle with the near-far effect (where closer devices drowning out ones further from the base station) have also been made, but extensive comparison field tests are going to be required to draw any sort of definitive conclusion on the matter – and that’s before we begin considering the looming presence of LTE-M and the 3GPP’s upcoming NB-IoT standard, as well as the multiple LPWAN technologies that could all feasibly achieve challenger-scale.