Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 January 2013

The latest wireless standards war: UltraGig vs Miracast

The standards war that was once brewing in the 60GHz wireless HD video space has largely been averted in the usual way ‘ the victory of a WiFi platform. Various divisions in the 802.11 and WiFi camps have been overcome and WiGig, based on the emerging 802.11ad specifications, sealed its dominance when its trade group combined its efforts with those of the mainstream WiFi Alliance. The 60GHz technology is now positioned as complementary to a nearer term WiFi standard, 802.11ac, which achieves gigabit-plus speeds in more conventional 5GHz spectrum. All that harmony means challengers in the wireless HD video world, such as WirelessHD, have been heavily sidelined. But Silicon Image, which became a backer of WirelessHD when it acquired pioneer SiBeam, is still ready to take on the WiFi juggernaut, promoting its own UltraGig technology against WiFi extension Miracast.

Miracast, which is based on WiFi Direct, allows content to be beamed from a handheld device to a TV wirelessly, and is being supported by several WLan chip majors such as Marvell and Broadcom. It gained considerable attention at the recent Consumer Electronics Show, but its victory is not assured. There are single-vendor alternatives like Apple AirPlay while Intel could provoke another split in the WiFi world by supporting WiGig instead of Miracast.

And now Silicon Image wants to press the cause of UltraGig, which is effectively the new name for SiBeam’s WirelessHD (Silicon Image acquired that start-up in 2011). WirelessHD has attractions ‘ it is optimized for uncompressed 1080p video transmission, so avoids the downsides of MPEG compression, such as potential packet loss. And like Miracast it can support peer-to-peer wireless connectivity in a living room, usually between a smartphone and a TV.

As Tim Vehling, general manager of Silicon Image’s wireless division, told EETimes at the CES show, the use of 60GHz spectrum means there is no congestion and interference from other WiFi devices, whereas Miracast is a software layer that enables WiFi silicon ‘ usually in conventional 2.4GHz and 5GHz bands ‘ with peer-to-peer connection capability.

However, it is the word WiFi that should make Silicon Image think twice, whatever its technological pros and cons. Miracast is a standard created and maintained by the WiFi Alliance, which has huge and increasing power over the broader wireless standards community as its platforms expand their reach from carrier networks to the internet of things, and as it increasingly works alongside other powerful groups like 3GPP.

The obvious downside of UltraGig is that it is a proprietary silicon solution with, currently, only one vendor, which adds to cost and risk for consumer electronics firms. Some believe Silicon Image’s best bet would be to converge UltraGig with WiGig, in which it also has activities, and try to steal a march as an influential 60GHz player. Since the WiFi Alliance embraced WiGig, there is no longer a hostile barrier between 5GHz and 60GHz solutions, and indeed, WiGig is likely to appear mainly in triband chipsets spanning all three 802.11 frequencies. But there will be a role for 60GHz-only solutions in the home, and a WiGig/UltraGig combination might indeed push out Miracast. Intel has already indicated it could support WiGig, in which it has significant influence and IPR, as an alternative to the 5GHz standard.

Even without the 60GHz factor, there is a long way to go before Miracast is acknowledged as the standard way to support peer-to-peer streaming in the living room. It is being adopted by many powerful players such as Nvidia, Qualcomm Atheros, Marvell and Broadcom, but Intel offers the competing WiDi (Wireless Display) technology, which cannot be dismissed because of the firm’s influence at the PC end. As outlined above, many expect Intel to replace WiDi with WiGig, over time. Although Intel is supporting Miracast too, it prefers standards over which it has more direct influence.

Other vendors have their own approaches to streaming audio and video directly from a mobile device to a large screen, without a router involved. As well as the well-established AirPlay, Microsoft and Nokia are working on an application called ‘Play To’, which will let Windows Phone gadgets stream to DLNA TVs.