The UK is becoming something of a hotbed for emerging open RAN systems, partly because its government has toughened its anti-Huawei stance this year, and is encouraging the four MNOs to open up their ecosystems.
Those MNOs have seven years to remove Huawei from their core and RAN platforms, so there is no great urgency, and BT/EE and Vodafone, in particular, have expressed caution around open RAN architectures for their primary 5G networks. This is partly because the systems are not mature yet, and partly because some vendors, such as Samsung, do no support coexistence with legacy 2G/3G networks, which UK operators plan to retain, at least on the 2G side, for many years.
However, the four operators – BT/EE, Telefónica O2, Vodafone and Three UK – are keen to put the open architectures through their paces and help drive them towards full commercial deployability. Vodafone and Telefónica have both issued open RAN RFIs under the auspices of the Telecom Infra Project (TIP) and highlighted a long list of vendors, many of them non-traditional, which comply with their requirements. And BT runs a TIP ecosystem acceleration center (TEAC) to incubate promising start-ups focused on open telco networks.
Vodafone has gone a step further and committed to deploy open RAN in a large part of its European footprint (without specifying exactly what it means by ‘open’). One of its first moves will be to implement virtualized, disaggregated base stations, supporting O-RAN interfaces, in 2,600 sites in Wales and south-west England. This will support small cells and extended rural coverage – both areas of deployment which are providing useful proving grounds for O-RAN and for alternative vendors, since they carry less traffic than the primary networks, and less risk to the business if they do not perform at the same level as a traditional RAN.
Vodafone’s operating arm in Ireland is also deploying O-RAN – initially, in 30 rural and semi-rural sites. The MNO is working with Parallel Wireless, a US-based firm with strong ties to the UK and Ireland. Its first major contract, for rural small cell clusters, was with EE, and several of its executives and engineering teams are in the UK. Comba Telecom is also a supplier to the deployment, on the antenna side.
Parallel will provide the radio software the 800 MHz 4G band in 30 sites, replacing Ericsson gear in some locations, while others are new deployments. The firm will implement a key element of the O-RAN architecture, a near-real time RIC (RAN intelligent controller), which will host network functions such as X2 handover between base stations, and security gateways. These will run as ‘xApps’ on the RIC, which will be located in capital Dublin.
This architecture is important for new vendors that will have to interoperate with existing installations from other suppliers. In this scenario, inter-vendor handover is handled by the RIC, rather than in the centralized packet core, supporting lower latencies. Parallel’s implementation of the RIC builds on its existing HetNet Gateway platform, which ran network optimization and control functions as virtual instances.
The architecture in use in Ireland is highly distributed. The classic 5G virtualized RAN design has some network functions running in a remote central unit (CU), which can support processes that are not latency-sensitive on commodity x86 servers. Low latency functions such as dynamic spectrum sharing are then run on distributed units (DU) closer to the cell site, which may require more optimized cloud hardware with high end accelerators. However, the DU can be collocated either with the CU or the RU, depending on the system requirements and the geographical spread of the network. Parallel’s network in Ireland is collocating the CU and DU on servers from Supermicro, and these are placed close to the sites to reduce fronthaul burden in rural areas. This mirrors the distributed approach Parallel has taken in rural 4G, pre-O-RAN roll-outs.
“This pioneering new approach reduces cost, increases flexibility and enables new suppliers to support the expansion of Vodafone’s mobile network in hard-to-reach areas,” said Didier Clavero, CTO at Vodafone Ireland.
Vodafone has also trialled Parallel Wireless technology in Turkey and in Democratic Republic of Congo. The operator recently shared its experiences in Turkey in a 42-page TIP ‘playbook’ designed to help other operators understand the deployment process and best practice. The operator also recently announced O-RAN trials in The Netherlands.
Also targeting the UK opportunity is NEC, whose radio units and 5G core are central to Rakuten’s roll-out in Japan. NEC hopes to leverage its success in its home country to break into international markets, riding the open RAN wave (see separate item). It has chosen the UK to locate its new ‘Global Open RAN Center of Excellence’, as a hub for its efforts to promote O-RAN in general, and its platforms in particular, to European operators and partners.
The CoE will be responsible for business and solution development, product development support, project execution and technical support for NEC’s global open RAN business.
It will also be supported by an open RAN laboratory and technical verification facility in India, which will be responsible for multivendor interoperability testing, as well as verifying product and system level performance and quality assurance.
Beyond the UK and Ireland, there has been plenty of other open RAN news over recent weeks. Some highlights include:
- Japan’s NTT Docomo is requiring any vendor to support open RAN interfaces in order to bid for its 4G or 5G contracts. At TelecomTV’s recent Open RAN Summit, the MNO’s general manager of the RAN development department, Sadayuki Abeta, said this was opening up the supply chain. He said: “We have already added new vendors this year… and have just selected new vendors for the remote radio head … to avoid vendor lock-in.”
In September, Docomo deployed a 5G baseband unit, combining a central unit (CU) and distributed unit (DU), co-developed by NEC and Samsung and conforming to O-RAN Alliance specifications. This has been rolled out with radio units from other vendors in a production network.
Abeta also stressed the importance of interoperability testing to reduce build-out and integration time and complexity. The O-RAN Alliance has set up an Open Test and Integration Centre (OTIC) with a series of labs.
Docomo, like new rival Rakuten Mobile, plans to share the O-RAN developments it has made with partners such as NEC, by offering them to open initiatives or individual operators in other markets.
- Two leading lights in the open RAN movement, Altiostar and NEC, were two of the participants in the first India-based O-RAN plugfest. Hosted by operator Bharti Airtel, the plugfest saw several demonstrations of multivendor interoperability, including one by Airtel, Altiostar and NEC.
They showed integration of Massive MIMO open radio units from NEC with virtualized distributed units from Altiostar, running on COTS servers and supporting a commercial end-to-end Open Fronthaul interface based on O-RAN split 7.2x specifications. The demonstration included control, user, synchronization and management plane protocols, including 3GPP RCT and performance cases.
The demonstration also showed how this set-up can be used in an end-to-end 5G Non-Standalone network with EN-DC (dual connectivity).
- In a rare example of harmony in the US Congress, a new telecoms law has been passed unanimously into law. This allocates $750m to encourage and support development of open RAN technologies to help stimulate a US-based 5G ecosystem and build an alternative to Huawei technology.
The ‘Utilizing Strategic Allied Telecommunications Act 2020’ will make the funds available as grants that will be administered and managed by the US National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), which sits within the US Department of Commerce. The DoC has been responsible for increasingly tough sanctions against Huawei in the USA, against the backdrop of escalating trade and political tensions with China.
While major US firms such as Intel and Qualcomm have reportedly been awarded special licences to enable them to continue supplying Huawei, under certain restrictions, the political rhetoric against the Chinese giant is not abating. The new bill aims to “reassert US and western leadership by encouraging competition with Huawei that capitalizes on US software advantages, and accelerate the development of an open architecture mode that would allow for alternative vendors to enter the market for specific network components, rather than having to compete with Huawei end-to-end.”
Democrat Senator Mark Warner, who co-founded US mobile operator Nextel, and is the vice-chair of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, said: “Every month that the USA does nothing, Huawei stands poised to become the cheapest, fastest, most ubiquitous global provider of 5G, while US and western companies and workers lose out on market share and jobs.”