Two much watched auctions have been postponed ‘ the UK’s 2.6GHz mobile broadband spectrum sale, and the US’ potential offering of 25MHz of unused bandwidth in the 2155MHz to 2180MHz band. Meanwhile, UK regulator Ofcom has been outlining how it plans to deal with 128MHz of UHF analog TV spectrum, which will be freed up as the country switches to digital television between now and 2012.
With regards to the ‘digital dividend’ this will create, Ofcom says in its initial consultation document that it plans to release the spectrum ‘in a way that will promote competition and innovation and allow the widest range of technologies and services to access the spectrum’. All new licenses will be tradable and will be technology and service neutral. The auction will be held in 2009.
But the other major UK auction, in 2.6GHz, has suffered a second delay, this time because of legal challenges from O2 and T-Mobile (see Wireless Watch May 28 2008). The sale was scheduled for September, with an applications deadline of July (and before that, had been slated to be held even earlier, at the end of 2007). Ofcom said it would be ‘inappropriate to set the application date for July or August 2008′ in light of the two operators’ legal action. They are taking Ofcom to court over its decision to go ahead with the auction before it has finalized its policy on refarming of 900MHz GSM spectrum, which could enable cellcos to deploy 3G and even 4G services in these frequencies, potentially reducing their need for 2.6GHz licenses (or at least their willingness to pay large sums for these). The operators argue they are unable to value the 2.6GHz spectrum accurately until they know how much, if any, of the 900MHz spectrum they will be allowed to use for 3G, an issue Ofcom constantly has under consideration.
Over the pond, FCC chair Kevin Martin has removed the planned discussion regarding a possible auction of 25MHz of unused 2.1GHz spectrum from this week’s meeting of the regulatory body. This proposed auction would require the winning bidder to offer free broadband service under a strict build-out schedule.
Martin says he removed the proposal from the agenda because he wanted to look into concerns raised by some cellcos. The operators’ representative body, the CTIA, criticized the FCC in a filing last week, saying that the proposal “upends two decades of spectrum policy in favor of a specifically tailored auction designed to advance the particular business model of a single company’.
Martin remains committed to the plan but thinks more time is needed to examine cellco concerns about interference. He hopes to have the discussion in July and schedule an auction for December or early next year. The plan is similar to one proposed by M2Z Networks ‘ set up by former FCC chief John Muleta ‘ in 2006. This request for 25MHz of spectrum to support free broadband services was rejected, but mainly on the basis that there had not been the chance to consider other proposals, rather than because the principle was deemed to be faulty. Recently, Anna Eshoo introduced new legislation in the House of Representatives ‘ the Wireless International Nationwide for Families Act ‘ that would force the FCC to auction the unused frequencies in the 2155MHz to 2180MHz band for a free broadband network to reach 95% of the US population within 10 years. The FCC also wants to compel the operator to use filters to block pornography, a proposal that is opposed by civil liberties groups.