In Korean capital Seoul, the first market where commercial Mobile WiMAX and 3G services can be directly compared, W-CDMA is winning out, according to analysts.
ABI Research’s Korea-based analyst, Andy Bae, has published comparisons between the two systems ‘ KT’s WiBro service, based on a pre-standard implementation of WiMAX largely developed by Samsung; and SKT’s W-CDMA/HSDPA network. Bae says WiBro is lagging behind its rival because it has limited coverage ‘ KT has not yet built out beyond Seoul ‘ and because it ‘needs more compelling applications to attract subscribers’. Also, Bae judges ‘consumer awareness is very low. Currently, they should develop some differentiating factor to become competitive against HSDPA.’
In terms of network performance, WiBro currently offers three times the speeds of HSDPA on the uplink, but downlink rates are similar, and the deployment of HSUPA next year will make the two systems roughly equal. However, next year will also see ‘WiBro 2’ ‘ full Mobile WiMAX ‘ and this will leapfrog HSPA’s data performance again.
Currently, WiBro is mainly being used on USB modems for laptops and other portable devices, rather than handsets. Bae identifies one strong point ‘ ‘the emergence of WiBro-only internet access devices such as game consoles’. This reinforces a point often made about WiMAX in general, that it needs to attract well differentiated devices, preferably in categories where handsets are not strong, a fact that Sprint has grasped well. Despite this, WiBro ARPU stands at $20 a month, about half the average sum spent by HSPA users in Seoul ‘ partly because KT has had to be aggressive in offering discounted promotions to attract subscribers.