Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 June 2008

Verizon-Alltel: good for Verizon; bad for roaming, Sprint and CDMA vendors

In the least surprising twist in the US’ four-year mobile M&A frenzy, Verizon has acquired fellow CDMA operator Alltel Communications in a deal worth $28.1bn, leapfrogging AT&T to become the largest cellco by customer numbers once more. If approved, the acquisition (for $5.9bn in cash plus the assumption of $22.2bn in debt), will create a carrier with more than 80m subscribers.

Verizon has looked at Alltel several times before, looking for strategic and financial benefits that are fairly clear ‘ economies of scale in CDMA maintenance and expansion, and in LTE upgrade; broader customer reach, especially in the rural areas that AT&T is also targeting, and where the newly acquired 700MHz spectrum should make 3G+ build-out more profitable in sparse populations; a widened gulf between the big two and other cellcos. Verizon could also have opted for a bid for a larger CDMA operator, Sprint Nextel, but the operational problems besetting the US’ third cellco, and its mobile broadband strategy based on WiMAX rather than Verizon’s chosen LTE, would have made this a complicated and distracting merger, as well as attracting antitrust attention. The merger with Alltel does seem to leave Sprint in the cold as far as possible homegrown acquisitions go, potentially pushing its management team towards interested parties from Asia or even Deutsche Telekom.

By contrast with a difficult Sprint takeover, an Alltel buy comes at a good price, and should bring far less significant regulatory intervention or legacy management problems (the private equity team that took over Alltel less than a year ago have sharpened up the running of the operator). However, those same investors ‘ TPG Capital and GS Capital Partners ‘ will be less pleased at the deal. While Sprint has secured a company for a lower price than when it looked at it last year, even though Alltel is 10% larger in subscriber terms, Alltel’s investors are getting a $28.1bn deal, when they paid $27.5bn last November. With Verizon’s offer price falling each time it has approached the smaller player, and no other obvious bidders on the horizon (Sprint being too messed up itself to consider such a move), the private equity firms must have believed this is the best they would get. Ivan Seidenberg, CEO of Verizon Communications, co-owner (with Vodafone) of Verizon Wireless, said in a conference call that the takeover price was only slightly below what he had been prepared to offer last fall (when the private equity firms stepped in instead), but Alltel had grown its business.

So while the deal looks, on the whole, positive for Verizon Wireless, what about other parties that will be affected if it goes through largely unchanged?

Roaming partners:

Apart from the private equity investors, the other group least likely to be cheering the acquisition will be roaming partners. Alltel has held a unique position in US wireless communications because of the vast geographical reach it has pieced together over years of piecemeal expansion and acquisition. Although it remained the fifth player in terms of subscriber numbers and revenues, because many of its territories are sparsely populated and/or low income, its wide reach gave it a pivotal position in roaming deals. The four big mobile carriers, and many smaller ones, all relied on roaming agreements with Alltel to fill in gaps in their rural coverage, the largest players having concentrated the bulk of their 2G and 3G build-out investment on higher margin urban or suburban markets. Alltel also gained an established GSM rural roaming network when it acquired Western Wireless in 2006, specifically to serve the needs of T-Mobile and AT&T.

Both Verizon and AT&T have made a string of purchases of small rural carriers over the past two to three years ‘ and there are plenty more candidates available ‘ but have still remained dependent on roaming. Now Verizon gains control of that broad footprint, just at the time when it has the lion’s share of the 700MHz spectrum, whose propagation qualities make it optimal for covering sparsely populated regions cost efficiently. That could be a serious setback for AT&T in rural areas, since with its arch-rival in control, roaming deals could be altered or fees raised. The same applies to Sprint Nextel, T-Mobile and some smaller players, although the less threatening the cellco, the more likely it is that Verizon will maintain the roaming status quo and pocket the profitable revenues from those deals. Of course, the regulator and competition authorities may also make rulings to protect the Alltel arrangements with its roaming partners. Its deal with Sprint Nextel does not expire until 2016, and with AT&T until 2012, but charges could be renegotiated.

The competition authorities may also force Verizon Wireless to sell some spectrum in areas where, once its own holdings are combined with those of Alltel, it could be deemed to have a monopoly position with regards to roaming partners. If such licenses come to the table, AT&T might try to fill in some gaps, but given its recent purchase of 700MHz spectrum in many areas, including rural ones, T-Mobile might have a greater need to extend its coverage and reduce its dependence on roaming with Verizon.

Verizon itself will greatly reduce its own expenditure on roaming fees by owning the Alltel network, but has taken on the burden of supporting and upgrading the former Western Wireless GSM system, at least until the day when all the networks ‘ CDMA or GSM – are moved to LTE (which is likely to be 2015 or later in rural backwaters). It has recently taken over several MVNO agreements from Sprint Nextel, notably Qwest’s, and this could have increased its roaming charges ‘ acquiring Alltel thus makes those customers more profitable.

Verizon Wireless’ competitors:

AT&T Mobility slips to the number two cellco position and thus gets a nudge to expand. Acquiring MVNOs or tucking in small carriers may continue but none has the mass to affect AT&T significantly. Its own drive for scale and new revenues is far more likely to focus on international expansion, an area where its long lines and services businesses mean it already has far greater global reach than Verizon, despite the latter’s acquisition of the former MCI.

With tough foreign ownership rules for carriers, China probably does not make sense, but expanding its Indian presence via a joint venture with Bharti or another large carrier does make sense and AT&T has been lobbying the Indian authorities to allow foreign bidding in their forthcoming 3G and mobile broadband auctions.

While not directly comparable to expanding wireless voice customers, the Verizon-Alltel deal probably makes the prospect of AT&T acquiring Dish Networks slightly more attractive. This would give the giant a net pick up of 11m-12m customers for triple and ultimately quad play offerings and a mobile TV strategy more likely to succeed than its current MediaFLO-based service.

As for Sprint Nextel, while we did not believe Verizon was likely to bid for Sprint as a company, we did think it a qualified buyer for Sprint’s CDMA network. Given the Alltel transaction and the similarity in coverage maps between it and Sprint, it seems less likely that Verizon would now be interested, even if the regulators permitted.

The regulators:

Verizon will have been motivated to bid now and have a good chance of completing the deal before the change of US government, since a potential change of administration could also bring in an FCC and Department of Justice less friendly to large carriers than the current ones have been. Under the current administration, analysts believe the deal has a strong (75%) chance of approval without sufficiently stringent conditions to threaten completion. Regulators are currently more concerned with market share than coverage overlap, so could well keep enforced divestiture of spectrum at a low level, although lobbying by AT&T on the roaming issue might harden the FCC’s line.

Alltel subscribers:

Their main fears will be reduce competition and choice in rural areas, and the likely end of the MyCircles payment plan, one of Alltel’s most innovative introductions, allowing unlimited calling to up to 20 numbers for a monthly fee. MyCircles has also become closely associated with the popular new branded user interface that Alltel developed with Qualcomm’s UIone unit, and which has given it significant differentiation among advanced users.

Consumer groups expressed concerns about the deal too. ‘The deal raises serious concerns for consumers. The wireless industry is rapidly being taken over by the same companies that dominate the broadband and DSL marketplace,’ said Ben Scott, policy director of one pressure group, Free Press. ‘The proposed merger between Verizon Wireless and Alltel appears to hasten this consolidation. We urge regulators to give this merger careful scrutiny with a steady eye toward promoting the competitive wireless marketplace consumers demand.’

Equipment makers:

The wave of operator consolidation in the US is bad news for equipment makers since the number of customers is reduced, overlapping network build-outs are rendered unnecessary, and the enlarged operators gain superior purchasing power. The delay before finalization of the merger could also delay some build-out plans for both Verizon and, in particular, Alltel. However, compared to the Cingular-AT&T Wireless, Sprint Nextel or AT&T-BellSouth-SBC mergers, the impact of this deal will be minimal, given that Alltel has only 5% market share and had not acquired major spectrum holdings for brand new deployments, doubtless with a Verizon bid in mind. But this will be one more in a series of small blows for the CDMA vendor community, as the technology platform suffers some operator defections at the 3G stage, and faces end of life at the 4G phase. With Verizon’s CDMA build-out nearing completion, the main opportunities for vendors in this account now lie in LTE anyway and will only start to materialize after the Verizon/Vodafone/China Mobile technology trials complete next year or 2010. In CDMA, Alcatel-Lucent has been the largest infrastructure supplier to Verizon Wireless, with some input from Nortel and Motorola, and Nortel has led the Alltel account. All three will be positioning themselves to bid for the combined LTE build-out from 2010, but this will not hit volume until 2012-2013, and anyway, they will face competition from Ericsson, Nokia Siemens, Huawei and others.

Device makers:

While consolidation can be risky for infrastructure makers, it can be positive for handset vendors, often accelerating build-out and customer acquisition ‘ even though larger operators also have greater power to beat down prices. Verizon Wireless’ favorite phonemakers are likely to be the big winners from having a larger network and subscriber base to address, in particular its flagship smartphone partner, LG, which sells more handsets via Verizon than any other supplier.

Other strong players at Verizon Wireless are Motorola and Samsung, but Kyocera may lose out, as its phones are carried by Alltel but not Verizon (though the latter does offer the Kyocera ExpressCard). However, Verizon Wireless could learn lessons from its smaller prey in terms of handset and user interface choices, so Kyocera is not inevitably off the list. In particular, Verizon would be foolish not to adopt the Alltel CellTop user interface and mobile web services, and offer them to a wider base, since the platform =- co-developed with Qualcomm UIone ‘ is more advanced than Verizon’s own products for many markets.