In the early days of Mobile WiMAX, there was widespread criticism of slow progress in developing the core network, but last year, the commitment of Sprint Nextel and a few other major operators drove vendors to step up their efforts, and the R6 interface for the ASN gateway took center stage. However, no sooner had robust platforms started to appear, from equipment makers and specialists, than disputes over the favored R6 profile have erupted again and, as in the RAN, the looming presence of LTE has forced core network suppliers to refocus their efforts on unified ‘4G’ platforms.
Among the specialists, WiChorus has been an innovator in the WiMAX core, and for a start-up, it has succeeded in adapting very quickly to changing market conditions. Like larger rivals, it has softened its stance on which of the three WiMAX Forum profiles for R6 should dominate ‘ last year, Profile C looked set to eclipse A and B; now the interest in femtocells and other new architectures is pushing vendors to be more flexible around interfaces between the RAN and the core. And WiChorus has already managed to incorporate LTE into its system, unveiling SmartCore, which can work with WiMAX and/or LTE. For the former, it incorporates an ASN Gateway, Intelligent Home Agent, and WiMAX Mobile Internet Gateway. It will also, once LTE standards are finalized, support the equivalent functions for LTE – LTE Service Gateway, PDN Gateway, and Mobility Management Entity.
In addition, WiChorus is also reflecting the trend of the whole sector by introducing support for picocell and femtocell gateway solutions, which connect these miniature base stations to the core, and which are currently being standardized by the Femto Forum and 3GPP (see Wireless Watch May 28 2008). As operators start to take the concept of WiMAX femtocells seriously, there has been new interest in different R6 profiles (see inset for descriptions of the three variants). While Profile C is geared to open, best-of-breed networks with carrier class functionality and macrocell designs, Profile B ‘ which tightly integrates RAN and core within a ‘black box’ and so is usually locked into one vendor ‘ may be more useful for operators that choose to make their first deployments based around hotzones in high value user bases, built with small cells. In this scenario, there are hundreds or thousands of base stations to link to the core, so low cost and simplicity are important, and the WiMAX or LTE network has to interoperate with the 3G network for wide area hand-off and roaming. This means operators will be more likely to start their deployments at the core, with the focus on integration and femtocells, rather than the macro RAN, as happened in 3G.
Open interfaces between the access network and the core are important to enable operators to select elements from different vendors, and this becomes even more crucial when interworking with an existing core. For best of breed strategies at the core, the critical interface is R6, which connects the WiMAX access network with the core IP network via the ASN gateway. This is the focus of activity for many specialists like Starent and Aricent, also working hard on new WiMAX core capabilities and on LTE. The major vendors will not be far behind, and this activity is certainly starting to fill some major gaps in the Mobile WiMAX offering for large scale operators and those looking to deploy mobile internet services. Until a year ago, ‘the focus of the WiMAX ecosystem was on fixing the radio access network,” said Arnab Das, director of WiMAX product management at Aricent, in a recent interview. “Then service providers started thinking about how to deliver services, or handle hand-off and roaming, which is where the ASN (access service network) and CSN (core service network) come in.”
Together the CSN and the ASN support the delivery and authentication of subscribers. The CSN sits in the core network and contains the AAA server and mobile IP Home Agent elements, and these are then connected to the RAN via the ASN Gateway, which sits between the radio and the IP elements of the WiMAX network. The ASN Gateway connects to WiMAX base stations via the R6 interface and is the most complex piece of software in an 802.16e system, and therefore the source of the greatest competitive edge for vendors and operators. It handles network entry and attachment, subscriber authentication, data session creation, handover and roaming. For smaller operators, companies like Aricent offer less fully featured options (in Aricent’s case, the low power, lower cost ASN Lite, which is targeted at smaller or hotspot providers).
There are two main ways to integrate a Mobile WiMAX network with an existing cellular network. With tight coupling, WiMAX is treated as a cellular RAN and is connected to the core by standard 3GPP interfaces; with loose coupling it is not treated as a cellular RAN and is connected by IP gateways that route WiMAX traffic to the internet without impacting the existing core. The WiMAX Forum has preferred the latter approach because it is more flexible, and allows the operator to innovate in WiMAX access without serious impact/risk in the core. Most 2G and 3G operators remain, at least in the early stages of 4G, nervous about any major disruption to the core, which has accounted for some slow uptake of technologies that would otherwise stimulate multinetwork integration, such as femtocell RANs and IP Multimedia Subsystem. However, with LTE on the horizon and mobile internet business models becoming de rigeur, this caution is declining.
The R6 profiles:
The WiMAX Forum Network Working Group (NWG) has defined three implementation profiles for the R6 interface. Profile A enables mixing of radio and IP functionality in the base station and ASN gateway but components are tightly coupled, while Profile B “hides R6 in a locked black box”. The option favored by best of breed advocates is Profile C , which supports openness and enables flat as well as hierarchical topologies. By keeping the radio resource management functionality in the base station only, it may deliver a faster, optimized handover mechanism.
There is also the option of the R3 interface, which connects the IP-based ASN to the operator’s connectivity service network. Less attention is given to R3 because the majority of the operator’s capex is spent on components around R6, and they can gain the flexibility in shopping around for base stations and ASN gateways from different vendors.
In Profile A the R6 interface is exposed, allowing multivendor connections between RAN and CSN core network. In this case the key radio functionality element, the Radio Resource Management (RRM), resides in the ASN Gateway.
In Profile B the R6 interface is not exposed but collapsed into a single solution that encompasses the ASN Gateway and the RAN on one side and the CSN on the other side.
In Profile C the R6 interface is, like Profile A, exposed, allowing an operator to deploy RAN and CSN elements from different vendors if desired. The difference from Profile A is that in Profile C the RRM is implemented not within the ASN Gateway but within the RAN.
SmartCore:
The newest element of WiChorus SmartCore is the WiMAX Mobile Internet Gateway, which provides all the WiMAX core functions in a single platform, simplifying initial WiMAX deployments.
‘The emerging mobile internet poses unique challenges for wireless operators,’ said Rehan Jalil, CEO of WiChorus ‘Operators are faced with innovative web companies targeting premium subscribers, bandwidth demands disproportionate to average revenue per subscriber, and peer-to-peer traffic running rampant on their valuable wireless spectrum. Smart 4G networks tackle this new environment by delivering dramatically better cost per Mbps and line-rate network intelligence to help control and monetize internet traffic.’
The SmartCore design distributes control and content processing functions across interconnected blades, harnessing the hardware resources across the chassis on an as-needed basis for scalability and reliability. There are three models in the family ‘ the SC 1400, a fully redundant carrier-grade platform with 14 slots; the SC 600, a six-slot version; and the SC 20 and SC 100 appliances.
SmartCore also integrates content management, QoS and security functions on a per-subscriber, per-flow basis, and supports tracking of peer-to-peer applications by being aware of apps as well as just subscribers.
WiChorus is a two-year old outfit headquartered in Silicon Valley, which has so far raised $25m in venture capital from Redpoint Ventures, Accel and Mayfield Fund. Its key product is its Intelligent Access Services Gateway, designed for the ‘fatter, flatter and smarter wireless core’ that high capacity 4G will require. Content management, subscriber management and network optimization are handled from within the gateway, in line with the trend to flatten the network and apply more functionality and intelligence in a single place.
R6 lies at the heart of the vendor’s ‘One Open WiMAX’ slogan, under which it aims to interoperate with as many base stations, home agents, servers (AAA, IMS, policy and so on) and other ASN gateways as possible. So far it has announced Bridgewater Systems, Redline, Aperto and chipmaker Sequans within its self-run interoperability testing program.
WiChorus believes it has a two-year headstart on any other start-up that may be working on WiMAX gateways, and that it will aim to work with the giants rather than compete against them ‘ addressing some of the historic weaknesses of the infrastructure majors’ high end IP offerings (and perhaps angling for an acquisition, like Ericsson’s $2.1bn purchase of Redback in this space late last year). The obvious competitors will be Cisco and Starent. Cisco, according to WiChorus’ VP of product management Eric Andrews, lacks strong wireless awareness or flow capacity in its router-based offering (though could well look for an acquisition itself to strengthen its hand, especially in the wake of its purchase of Navini and stepped-up interest in WiMAX).