With the smart home chiefly in mind, Norwegian fabless maker of low power processors for IoT applications Nordic Semiconductor has acquired the WiFi division of UK Imagination Technologies Group. The company claims to be responding to customer demand, perhaps not surprising given its consumer target market where WiFi is already prevalent, but also indicates how the home and small enterprise IoT field is evolving generally.
Nordic claims that the four IoT wireless suites it now offers are the most popular in its target domestic and light industrial sectors, that is Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) and WiFi, along with LTE-M and NB-IoT, the two cellular 4G low power WAN variants. The company says it wants to blend these into the perfect cocktail for IoT platforms as one of the few yet offering all four, although this will take some months.
“There has long been a gap in between which our customers have been asking us to fill,” said Nordic CTO Svein-Egil Nielsen. “And although it won’t happen overnight as this is an IP acquisition rather than one that comes with WiFi devices ready to sell, we will now be able to add WiFi functionality to future generations of Nordic products.”
It is not necessary of course to own IP in order to incorporate it in products or services, with the option to license or resell. However, Nordic has determined that owning the property will afford greater freedom to innovate in the longer term, even if it means taking time to get going.
“We believe in owning every link in our product chain, and with the Imagination WiFi team on-board we will now be able to add WiFi hardware and software developed by Nordic from the ground up, as we do with all our other wireless product ranges,” said Nielsen.
With that same aim of being a stakeholder rather than merely an adopter, Nordic is seeking active membership of the WiFi Alliance. Nordic’s interest though is chiefly at the lower power end, so that while WiFi alone of the four wireless protocols it supports will bring in higher capacity, the focus is on those IoT use cases around the smart home that do not require high bit-rate, or for that matter ultra-low latency.
But the company argues that IoT straddles a variety of use cases and no single protocol can be optimized for all combinations of bit-rate, density, range and power availability. This diagram provided by BehrTech, a Canadian provider of wireless IoT connectivity software, serves to illustrate that point, showing how each protocol occupies distinctive areas of the field equating range, power consumption and data rate.
In fact that diagram does not do full justice to the distinctions, because it lumps NB-IoT and LTE-M together when their purpose is to address as many LPWAN applications under first 4G/LTE and then 5G as possible. Both emerged as the 3GPP options for LPWAN under LTE initially, vying with LoRaWAN, in particular, among non-cellular variants. LTE-M supports much higher bit-rates up to 7Mbps upstream and 4Mbps downstream in its top end LTE Cat M2 variant, along with lower latency end to end in the range 10 – 15ms at local range.
NB-IoT is lower performing, with bit-rates up to 127Kbps down and 159Kbps up, and latencies in the range of 1.6s to 10s, but in compensation consumes less battery and CPU power. This makes NB-IoT more suitable for those many field monitoring applications where small delays do not matter and data generated is light. Smart metering comes into that category and so NB-IoT has gained some traction there, with China Mobile, for example, using it for its automated cloud-based meter reading (AMR) service, being widely deployed by electric utilities. This helped NB-IoT attain 95m connections in China by the end of 2019 at an annual CAGR of around 150%, followed by full adoption as an official 5G standard in July 2020 by the ITU.
The other main contender there is not LTE-M but LoRaWAN, which is finding particular favor for smart water metering. LTE-M does come into its own though where more bandwidth is required alongside range, as in some video infrastructure monitoring applications.
Nordic then decided there was no need to support LoRaWAN in addition to NB-IoT, with WiFi then filling in at higher bit-rates even than LTE-M. This reliance on WiFi at the higher end of performance but lower range within the overall context of low power explains why the company acquired Ensigma from Imagination Technologies. Ensigma focuses on low power consumption but in the established two WiFi bands of 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz spectrum, rather than the 900 MHz range used by WiFi Halow.
Its iEW220 package is based on the IEEE 802.11a/b/g/n standard in that range, but trading off some performance for low power consumption, with wearables an initial target market.
WiFi Halow, which we discuss in a separate story this week, is pitched more towards the sector addressed by LTE-M and to an extent some of the others. Nordic reckons that it has its base well enough covered with those four protocols, coupled with GPS for positioning and location tracking.