Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 December 2020

Telefónica and Sky Deutschland tap 5G-Broadcast for live sports production

The 5G era promises to liberate the long-standing potential of cellular for both production and distribution of live TV after many false starts. Lack of network bandwidth has been a constraint in both cases, while high quality video distribution has also been hampered by cost of associated mobile infrastructure upgrades and lack of capable devices. The upshot was that live video especially could not be delivered with a good experience, with no compelling business case for operators.

Under LTE, the distribution side did start coming together under LTE Broadcast/Multicast with trials from Verizon among others, but still the ROI was not there for operators and so video streaming was largely confined to unicast transmission with its inherent inefficiencies for popular live or linear content. Yet as devices became more capable of rendering video at high quality, operators found their networks increasingly congested as a result, spiking further interest in broadcast, or especially multicast since the latter avoids unnecessary transmission of video to cells where there are no recipients.

Meanwhile on the production front, that is to bring footage back from the field over the cellular network instead of traditional satellite links from OBVs (outside broadcast vehicles) for example, LTE started to provide an alternative, with the help of bonding multiple connections to create sufficiently big pipes.

Bonding will still often be required under 5G because content at production stage generates large amount of data but it will become viable in more situations, while fewer connections will need to be fused together. This has led video production technology firms such as Live U and Dejero to integrate 5G into their transmission products. In turn trials have been conducted in all regions around live sports especially, with NBC Sports, BT Sport and the BBC in the frame.

Most recently pay-TV operator Sky Deutschland joined up with Telefónica O2 Deutschland to incorporate the 5G-Broadcast suite for a live sports production. This led to a demonstration on December 6, of live coverage from the German Handball Bundesliga match between SG Flensburg-Handewitt and Frisch Auf Göppingen. The interest here was in use of 12 standard 5G smartphones to transmit signals from around the stadium to provide a range of alternative camera angles.

The quality might not have been quite as good as that taken by the principal dedicated camera, but was adequate to pan in the different views almost as clips, adding perspective to the coverage. As Alessandro Reitano, SVP of sport production at Sky Deutschland, put it: “The positioning and use of the 5G smartphones brings us completely new possibilities in capturing game situations. Our viewers can thus dive even deeper into the action in the Flens Arena.”

Such trials are not entirely confined to sports, with the Seoul Broadcasting System deploying LiveU’s 5G integrated encoding and transmission products for live coverage of South Korea’s recent election.

5G-Broadcast, as used by Sky Deutschland, has been optimized particularly for video distribution over cellular. It is the direct successor of LTE Broadcast, with enhancements that integrate with unicast distribution via transparent handover between the two, as well as other efficiency and quality improvements. These have been incorporated in the latest version initially referred to as Further Enhanced Multimedia Broadcast Multicast Service (FeMBMS), delivered within the frameworks of 3GPP Releases 14 and 15. This has been renamed Enhanced Television (En TV) for simplicity, one of the main gains being consolidation with the cellular broadcast overlay model called High Power High Tower (HPHT).

HPHT incorporates elements of digital terrestrial broadcast, especially the latest North American version known as ATSC 3.0 which has the latest over the air broadcast technology already on board. This underpins the 5G-Broadcast overlay model, imposing effectively a traditional DTT (digital terrestrial TV) network on top of the cellular one, comprising larger supercells just for the multicast video traffic.

Within this model, 5G-Broadcast enables a service to flip between unicast and multicast on the basis of measures defined by the operator, which can vary over time or according to overall traffic profiles. The basic idea is that when demand for a live video or TV service exceeds a preset threshold within a given area, transmission is switched from unicast to multicast in order to save bandwidth.

This leads to a trade-off between unicast and multicast, determining the threshold at which the bandwidth savings of the latter outweigh the computational overheads of the former. That calculation is complicated now for cellular, especially 5G, by the growing use of beamforming and highly directional antenna that enable multiple unicast sessions in the same spectrum. The distinction between multicast and unicast at the RAN level then begins to blur, as content can be unicast to multiple users more efficiently. This would increase the threshold at which multicast distribution across the RAN, which means occupying overall spectrum, becomes desirable.

A survey reported in July 2020 by a Norwegian vendor of virtualized media production technology found that 82% of broadcasters now believe 5G will eventually replace traditional broadcast distribution methods such as DTT and satellite as the preferred way to access TV content. Over a third thought this would come to pass within 1-2 years.