Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 June 2015

Would Deutsche Telekom prefer Sprint to Dish?

Deutsche Telekom’s reported plans to acquire operators within its European footprint to build an IP super-network rely on selling its 67% stake in T-Mobile USA, and it has repeatedly indicated that it is keen on a deal, if the right price can be agreed for the fourth US mobile carrier.

However, despite reports last week that TMO was in advanced merger talks with pay-TV provider Dish Network, DT’s CEO Timotheus Hoettges is said to prefer a deal with Sprint. The New York Post, citing unnamed sources, said Hoettges told investors at an RBC Capital Markets event last week that a Sprint merger would create high value for

shareholders and the industry, while a Dish transaction would make more sense at some point in the future.

Last year, Sprint and its parent Softbank were interested in bidding for TMO, but backed away before making an offer, presumably because of fears of regulatory hostility to a deal which would, once again, reduce the number of mobile players in the US. By contrast, a Dish-TMO combination would offer the authorities the advantages of retaining four national MNOs, while strengthening TMO’s ability to compete with Verizon and AT&T, since it would gain Dish’s considerable spectrum assets, its TV customer base and fixed satellite network, and its content relationships. These could be the basis for a quad play, whereas a Sprint combination would not, and would primarily deliver economies of scale and market share.

According to the reports, Hoettges believes that the US’s largest cableco, Comcast, might bid for an enlarged TMO to create a major quad play provider. However, if Dish were part of that combination, it would likely be blocked by antitrust authorities. “If you buy Dish, you kill the prospect of selling to Comcast,” he is said to have told the investors, though DT denied the reports.

One way in which TMO and Sprint may cooperate is in bidding for 600 MHz spectrum in next year’s auction. TMO is lobbying the FCC to allow joint bids between national carriers.
Hoettges said in May that DT would consider any TMO option that would improve profitability at the carrier, but insisted there was no rush, as the US operator is on a roll in terms of subscriber growth. “If we find a partner who will help us to do so, we will obviously consider it,” he told Reuters, but added: “Customers are literally flocking to us.”