The Japanese Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications (MIC) has dealt a body blow to nascent cellco plans to add WiMAX to their next generation platforms, by proposing to exclude current 3G license holders from bidding for 2.5GHz licenses. This throws in doubt some of the plans of the leading cellcos – NTT DoCoMo, KDDI and Softbank – to build out a parallel WiMAX network to carry heavy duty multimedia traffic and so boost total spectrum capacity while easing the pressure on the 3G systems. These companies, already under intense competitive pressure, will now have to wait for further spectrum allocations to pursue their mobile broadband initiatives beyond 3G, a turn of affairs that will also hit those vendors with the strongest links to the Japanese mobile carriers.
The Ministry’s proposals for introducing the ‘Mobile Broadband Wireless Access’ system in 2.5GHz, on which it has now invited comments, include plans to eliminate 3G mobile carriers and their subsidiaries, specifically the big three and EMobile, their group companies, and any carrier in which board directors of the cellcos hold more than one-third voting rights. If the plan is approved unaltered, Japanese mobile operators will not be able to opt for a wireless or converged quad play, of the kind being pursued by Sprint Nextel, KT and others, before the next decade.
Less controversially, the MIC said the 2.5GHz band would be reserved for mobile access using broadband channels, and therefore technologies such as WiMAX, 802.20, CDMA EV-DO Rev C (UMB) or Willcom’s successor to PHS (the other key option, LTE, was not mentioned by name).
The proposed plan says that 80MHz between 2.535GHz and 2.63GHz (excluding the guard band) will be divided into two bands, one for nationwide mobile access and one for fixed access per local community. The mobile band will be allocated to two carriers with a channel of 30MHz each. 3G operators cannot bid for either fixed or mobile bands.
The MIC’s reason to exclude current players is predictable – to promote competition between current cellular and future MBWA services, rather than allowing one set of companies to control both; and to encourage new and hopefully innovative entrants. However, this policy may be going too far in Japan. DoCoMo and KDDI are already among the most innovative cellcos on the planet and in the forefront of introducing new services, and both are under huge pressure from the recent increase in competition, and particularly the resurgence of what was formerly Vodafone KK but is now being invigorated under Softbank’s ownership. It is clear that 3G is inadequate to support a full mobile broadband offering of the type that Japanese consumers, in particular, will demand at an early stage, and DoCoMo will argue that it has invested heavily in building out 3G, and in putting Japan center stage in the mobile world, only to see another company given the weapons and frequencies to deliver a real broadband experience. Despite an instinctive hostility to WiMAX, DoCoMo’s parent NTT has also been aggressively trialling convergence solutions that would bring together the cellco’s existing and future wireless systems with wireline networks to create an early stage quad play.
Of course, a company like NTT would still be able to partner with a 2.5GHz spectrum holder to fill in the gaps in the quad play, but would not gain the same economies. And in a nation as saturated with broadband as Japan, a 2.5GHz licensee with no wireline or cellular back-up may find it tough to find a profitable model, certainly without wholesaling.