Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 June 2007

Amp’d Mobile files for Chapter 11, casting doubts on ‘content is king’ mantra

The once starry US MVNO sector has suffered another blow, with music-oriented player Amp’d Mobile rather hastily filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, citing a shortage of funds to rebuild its back end infrastructure. The move – following hard on the heels of the demise of ESPN Mobile and the continuing tribulations of the Earthlink/SKT Helio venture – does not necessarily sound a death knell for the virtual model in the US. After all, Virgin Mobile continues to perform well. But it does teach the market two important lessons. First, whatever the trend in current operator thinking, content is not yet king, and voice-oriented MVNOs like Europe’s Blyk may not have it so wrong after all And second, MVNOs work best trading off a brand that is already well established in a clearly targeted demographic, like Virgin. A well recognized brand is one of the only defenses, for a non-infrastructure vendor with limited ability to influence fixed costs, against a margin-destroying price battle.

One-year old Amp’d said it would continue business as usual, but it will find it hard to continue to fuel the advertising spend needed to keep growing, especially as it has admitted to major problems in collecting customer payments, with about one-third in default. ‘We expect to continue normal business operations throughout the reorganization process. We are confident that we will emerge from this stronger than ever due to the strength of Amp’d Mobile’s brand and high customer demand for the product,” the company said in a statement.

During the reorganization process, the company will work with one of its existing investors to obtain debtor-in-possession financing and the management team is expected to remain largely intact. It is unclear exactly how much cash the company retains from its earlier investment rounds.

Amp’d investors include Qualcomm, MTV and Universal Music Group, along with Columbia Capital, Highland Capital partners, Intel Capital, Quilvest Private Equity and Redpoint Ventures. The company was launched in late 2005 and rents airtime from Verizon Wireless and claims 200,000 subscribers. It has raised some $360m so far.

Last September saw the demise of Disney’s ESPN Mobile and it became clear that many MVNOs were relying too much on the power of their brand and content, and needed to focus on the concrete benefits of low priced voice services, a move that Amp’d followed this January. It managed to weather the storm and after initial mistakes claimed ARPU of $100, with $30 coming from data services, and in 2006 it signed up more than 100,000 subscribers, including 70,000 in the fourth quarter. Although this was far lower than its initial predictions, it was far better than previous sign-up rates and Amp’d looked like it had seen the worst of its problems off. It also signed distribution deals with Best Buy and Circuit City, but warned in January that it needs to average 25,000 net new subscribers a month to hit its target of an operating profit by the end of 2008.

Amp’d was also known to be working towards partnering Canada’s Telus and KDDI in Japan to launch versions of the service there, but not as an MVNO, instead with the cellcos taking the media services and re-branding them in an attack on the youth market. This suggested that the company would be more successful as a content company than an operator, a direction it may still pursue – and that may be prompting its apparently urgent need to rework its back end systems.

‘We see ourselves as a global, mobile entertainment company which has an MVNO business here in the US,’ said Bill Stone, president of Amp’d Mobile, in an interview last January, claiming the company would now export its “secret sauce of Amp’d Live” around the world. He said he had not ruled out ever doing another MVNO but, outside the US, this would not be the first priority – a tough decision that other MVNOs may have to face too. Virtual operators like Virgin know that their key asset is their brand, and in some markets it may be appropriate – or not – to apply that brand to an MVNO as part of a general lifestyle portfolio of services. This is what Amp’d is now trying to do in reverse – creating awareness of an entirely new brand and content through the initial MVNO activity, but now seeking to extend that asset through partners.

Telus has signed up to improve its approach to the youth market. It will run back office operations and Amp’d will handle marketing, events and content, with the service marketed as ‘Amp’d powered by Telus’. Key competitors will be Fido and Virgin Mobile.

In Japan, the relationship with KDDI goes beyond revenue sharing to an integrated portal model. Amp’d content will be available on about 20m KDDI handsets immediately, Stone said, and the company will receive a share of the revenue generated by users’ consumption of content. The service will include both a la carte and subscription services, and access to games, music, and the “rich graphic interface’ from Amp’d that will be exclusive in the Japanese market.

In both countries, Amp’d is opening up facilities including a studio that will allow content from those countries to be recorded for their domestic audiences and exported back to the US. The company offers big brand content from exclusive partners as well as its homegrown offerings, called Amp’d Originals (which, according to RCRNews, represents less than 5% of the content available, but 30% of the views). Stone hopes that some of this original content will be licensed by television companies to show on bigger screens or on their own mobile TV platforms.

This approach may give Amp’d a route out of its troubles, though it will still be in a highly pressurized field with as-yet vaguely defined business models. But for other MVNOs there will not be the same exit, and like major 3G providers before them, they will have to face up to the fact that voice, not content, remains the killer app for mobile networks, and will remain so until the mobile internet experience is significantly improved in terms of usability, services and pricing. Just as 3G players have been forced to leverage their efficient networks to deliver cheap voice minutes rather than high margin video apps, so the US MVNOs have reworked their plans to lead on voice. Last year, Amp’d introduced voice and data plans that matched or undercut those of the majors, splitting off the high end video offerings that it had hoped would drive its business.

In other words, customers are acquired with cheap voice minutes, not the inclusion of advanced content ‘ a fact that restricts the MVNOs’ ability to differentiate their plans from those of the national cellcos. This truism does put voice-based MVNOs in a new and attractive light, particularly those with a creative approach that could avoid the inevitable price carnage of the European low cost MVNOs.

Blyk, which is using Orange’s network, is offering its customers an interesting proposition where their free calls and text messages will be subsidized by advertising. It already has deals with advertisers such as Coca-Cola and Yell.com and will go live in its first market, the UK, in August. In the mean time, the company is talking up its model to potential advertisers and decrying the ‘content is king’ mantra that has driven operator thinking for most of the decade. Antti ‘hrling, who set up the company with former Nokia president Pekka Ala-Pietil’, told prospective advertisers in London recently: ‘The first myth that people tend to believe is that content is king in the mobile domain. You have to think about the medium. Mobile is a communications channel, not a content channel. The next generation of the mobile experience will still be around communication, not content.’

The company also claims it will set up its systems from the start to collect personal information rather than just billing data, so that it can target ads and service offers accurately.

Of course, operators will move on from voice, but the only companies capable of creating a content-oriented mobile internet experience with mass appeal are currently the majors, since this will be a long and high risk process requiring deep pockets. That means that alternative sources of revenue, rather than alternative applications, will mark out the successful challengers, and has Google has proved, the key ingredients may well prove to be advertising support and brand.