When NextWave Wireless acquired IPWireless last year, it appeared to muddy the waters of its largely WiMAX-driven chip-to-spectrum strategy, since IPWireless was the leading vendor in the rival (though sparsely supported) TD-CDMA broadband wireless platform. It soon became apparent that NextWave’s primary interest in its new subsidiary was likely to be its mobile television technology, and this has been borne out by the release of a WiMAX iteration of that technology, called MXtv, which has already attracted a development deal with China’s Huawei.
IPWireless’ TD-CDMA platform provides its parent with some knowhow that may be useful should it choose to do LTE ‘ until the Chinese hijacked the development of a TDD variant of LTE, there was a potential role for TD-CDMA in that roadmap. But as a mainstream network, the IPWireless system never gained significant support and the standard will now be subsumed into the China-driven TDD LTE. However, the mobile TV system that IPWireless created for its network, TDtv, is a very different prospect, and can be applied to any TDD profile technology, including, potentially, LTE in future. The first example of its ability to be adapted for different platforms, and so potentially to attract a wider base of licensees, is the release of the WiMAX iteration, MXtv, the first fully fledged mobile TV system specifically for 802.16e.
Both TDtv and MXtv are based on MBMS, a 3GPP standard heavily supported by Ericsson, which uses existing 3G spectrum and networks to deliver broadcast television, rather than a dedicated system in different spectrum, such as DVB-H or MediaFLO. MBMS-based networks are widely seen as a good option for cellcos that wish to offer TV services in the short term, but risk being prevented by delays in allocation of specialist DVB-H or other broadcast spectrum licenses. Similarly, in countries where mobile TV frequencies have not been decided on or released, there could be a chance for a WiMAX operator to step into the breach and create a wireless quad play from day one.
IPWireless has been the only vendor to apply MBMS to unpaired, TDD spectrum rather than the paired FDD profiles that dominate current mobile deployments. But as mobile broadband systems proliferate, TDD systems, which are optimized for packet data, will become more prominent, carrying TDD technologies like WiMAX and TDtv in their wake, even as LTE gains its own TDD profile.
IPWireless will be particularly interested in the Sprint Nextel Xohm roll-out, whoever may end up owning or running that ‘ when making its decision on which mobile broadband technology to adopt in 2.5GHz, Sprint trialled TD-CDMA and TDtv extensively, and even invested in IPWireless. The operator always professed itself impressed by the technology, though deterred by the lack of ecosystem or broad industry support. By marrying TDtv with the WiMAX system that Sprint did opt for, IPWireless/NextWave may have a second bite at this cherry.
NextWave plans to deliver WiMAX CPE chips this year, followed by base station silicon and full infrastructure products, as well as buying up WiMAX spectrum to support an end-to-end offering for service providers. MXtv will be a standard feature of all its equipment, the company said.
It has also immediately scored a bigger licensing success than TD-CDMA ever did, signing a joint development agreement with Huawei to integrate MXtv into the Chinese vendor’s WiMAX systems. Huawei has shown strong interest in MBMS, and a year ago collaborated with Qualcomm in one of the world’s first demonstrations of the technology in a handset, a demo geared to the PCCW deployment in Hong Kong, which was an important proof that MBMS was up to carrying video over a 3G network.
Requiring a software upgrade to both base station and handsets, but no hardware change, the cost of rolling out MBMS compares well with launching a MediaFLO or DVB-H network, which could amount to $500m to cover a large country. Although these dedicated datacasting networks may become necessary in time, multicasting from existing base stations can give cellular operators their own TV services, without wastefully using up precious mobile voice spectrum, allowing them to make the immediate switch out of unicasting, and avoid ceding control to the broadcasters, which are likely to drive the DVB-H roll-outs. The total cost of a TDD transmitter to go at each base station is around $15,000, and the total upgrade cost, including an MBMS software upgrade, cabling, power, truck roll and installation, is around $30,000. The handset can gain a radio tuner, antenna and demodulator for an estimated $20 bill of materials. That would make a national UK network, for instance, cost just £140m for 56 channels or around £105m for 28 channels, a cost probably shared among multiple operators. At best DVB-H would be the same cost as TDtv to build, but with spectrum costs added, and offering about half the number of channels – and that’s if a broadcaster were to give access to existing digital TV transmitter sites, giving them a big say in the business model and a share of the revenue.
MBMS is being trialled, with near term deployment plans, in various countries in 3G spectrum. KDDI is using the CDMA equivalent, BCMCS, while a group of UK-based operators are collaborating on implementing TDtv. Now the WiMAX providers will have a similar option.
MXtv supports up to 30 frames per second of video, and provides up to 45 mobile TV channels in 10MHz, said NextWave. The technology also allows carriers to allocate spectrum dynamically based on content availability, time of day, user demand and live events. Also, another NextWave subsidiary, PacketVideo, has designed many software stacks for mobile devices and is contributing its Media Fusion Platform, which provides handset-side and server-side data, search and navigation, with an electronic service guide constructed differently for each customer based on their service subscriptions and preferences. Media Fusion can also handle advertising, and make it different for each person.