Nine months after saying that DVB-H will officially be the European technology of choice for mobile TV, the European Union has taken one more step ‘ mandating that its member states encourage, through their regulators, the uptake of the standard. This is no surprise, given that the EU position has been clear for the past year, but just where it leaves countries like the UK, where there are far too many parties calling for UHF spectrum, or Poland or Spain, with similar problems and delays, remains unclear. Should the UK not be allowing Orange and T-Mobile to run a network in the UK using the spectrum they already own (which would mean the NextWave TDtv technology)? Will UK regulator Ofcom step in to intervene? Should it also intervene to stop Alcatel-Lucent implementing its DVB-SH satellite version of DVB-H with spectrum that is already available?
Ofcom has its own problems trying to auction 40MHz of L-Band spectrum in the 1452MHz-1492MHz range by April 10. This is the only likely set of airwaves for mobile TV on the near horizon in the UK, but Ofcom has made it technology neutral, and has not mandated usage. But to use this spectrum with DVB-H will require thousands of transmitter sites, and cost anything from two to four times the cost of a network build-out in 700MHz, and would defeat that EU objective of having a series of linked TV networks with full roaming.
We already know that most of the major cellcos have already stated they will not bid for the 1452MHz spectrum in order to use it for mobile TV. There exists the faintest hope that BSkyB, the News Corp satellite TV subsidiary, might bid for it and use it with MediaFLO, but recent executive statements at Sky seem to suggest that it is an arms dealer in the mobile TV race, and will not put its own army together after all.
However, if the EU rules don’t and cannot apply in the UK, can they be applied anywhere else in Europe? No, because they can only apply to spectrum that has not already been brought to market, or spectrum to be sold with auction rules that are already specified.
The European Commission statement said: ‘The addition of DVB-H is a new step towards establishing a single market for mobile TV in Europe that will enable all EU citizens to watch TV on the move. Mobile TV could reach a market of up to €20bn by 2011, reaching some 500m customers worldwide.’
Our own forecast, just published, reckons the number is perhaps closer to 300m by 2012, and here the Commission has taken the most optimistic forecast out there, to make it look like there is a big opportunity. But Europe’s insistence on using DVB-H plays to the strength of national broadcasters, not cellular operators, and these are pushing more and more for the free-to-air model with which they are confident, and which has worked in Korea and Japan, but are being pushed back by the cellular community, which does not want to cede control of the European mobile TV agenda.
‘For mobile TV to take off in Europe, there must first be certainty about the technology,’ says the statement from European Commissioner Viviane Reding, a statement that couldn’t be more wrong. There must first be certainty about the business model, before the technology is selected (a lesson that Europe should have learned from 3G). fThe statement also talks about a transparent intellectual property regime for DVB-H, something that has curiously not been addressed by Nokia, one of the lead intellectual property owners in the standard, and the Commission says it will closely monitor progress towards a DVB-H patent pool.
If the European Commission really wanted to do something, it would put pressure on the local regulators to find UHF spectrum in most European countries, something that DVB-H supporters have been calling for, with only qualified success, for at least three years.