While Europe is three years into the hype curve for mobile TV, and still has not delivered very much in the way of a useful consumer experience, the US market is still unsettled and players worry about the shape the market will take there. The situation is therefore still extremely fluid and changes week to week.
Last week, although there were no official moves, was no different, and AT&T has now told the mobile TV community privately that it has dismantled the DVB-H trial that it had been running in Las Vegas, and which it inherited when it bought the 12MHz of Aloha Partners’ spectrum last year. At the time it looked like AT&T would use the US-wide spectrum either as part of an LTE network in the distant future, or to mount a surprise attack on the mobile TV market using DVB-H. That latter move now appears highly unlikely.
That is not to say that AT&T has definitely decided not to pursue its own mobile TV efforts. First it had to see through its commitment to launch mobile TV services through MediaFLO, which it duly did two weeks ago, and which will help it gain experience. Now opinion is divided on just how AT&T will try to dominate mobile TV going forward. It appears to be in a ‘wait and see’ mode. The only decision is has taken is that it won’t use DVB-H. We made the case a few weeks ago that, once Dish Network goes ahead and adopts a hybrid satellite/terrestrial L-Band/700MHz strategy for mobile TV using the Alcatel-Lucent DVB-SH technology, this would mean it would no longer be an effective partner for AT&T. A partnership with Dish works if Dish uses S-Band spectrum and plants terrestrial transmitters on AT&T base station sites, which will now not happen.
The L-Band/700MHz hybrid decision is very much endorsed by the fact that we are told that Dish has taken an option to use the Modeo New York network, which was leased off to financial groups when Crown Castle’s Modeo shuttered that DVB-H service. We had suggested this was a good idea, since it is in spectrum close enough to the L-Band bandwidth that Dish donated to mobile satellite operator TerreStar, when it took a holding in that company, so that a single radio could access both a satellite delivered service and the New York Modeo network.
AT&T also has an abundance of 700MHz spectrum, and while it could use some of that for mobile TV, the dumping of the Aloha/HiWire trial makes it clear that it doesn’t really believe there is a business model to support using such expensive spectrum in that way.
By far the most likely outcome is that AT&T will embrace the ATSC M/H standard when it emerges in the US, and back the provision of the relevant handsets in all of its bundles, subsidized or not, taking all the pressure off it for a definitive dominance move in mobile TV prior to that happening. The merging of the two ASTC M/H candidate technologies by Samsung and LG last week makes this even more likely, because this platform is now building momentum.
We have heard the opinion voiced that the merger of the two proposals should be seen as a Samsung capitulation – that LG was winning the technical trials, and was about to be selected as the US ATSC Mobile Handheld standard, so the mighty Samsung was persuaded to give up its own A-VSB offering and throw in its lot with LG. We think this is highly unlikely. Harris, the US transmitter side of the company, which is partnering with LG on a joint offering with its Mobile Pedestrian Handheld (MPH) ATSC offering, has said that it could adapt to the rival standard in just 90 days, and said that it will go ahead and launch its digital exciter in August, and deliver the new standard in November ‘ a drag time of 90 days. It seems likely that the best elements of the two standards will be hashed into a single standard by October, and that neither side can claim a victory.
What the group of US broadcasters testing the candidate technologies did discover was that the system worked in trials at driving speeds and as far as 40 miles from the transmitter, and that the mobile signal does not interfere with regular digital TV broadcasts. And just as AT&T felt compelled to follow the Verizon lead into mobile TV using MediaFLO, Verizon will be equally compelled to embrace ATSC M/H to maintain its own competitiveness.
Another possibility we have heard in discussion is the idea that AT&T might also look to buy ICO Communications, which has already launched its satellite, purely for S-Band mobile TV services, initially to car seatbacks. This uses the same type of technology as Dish (Alcatel-Lucent’s DVB-SH) in S-Band spectrum. While it is fair to say that Craig McCaw, who indirectly controls ICO, has made a good living out of creating services and then selling them to AT&T, his real investment right now is Clearwire, lined up as it is as a direct rival to AT&T wired and wireless services. He is unlikely to undermine any edge that Clearwire has in the market, such as its own readymade mobile TV strategy, by selling it to the opposition.
So it looks like the US will have ATSC for free-to-air broadcasts, Dish with a huge paid-for satellite/hybrid service footprint, and a residue of specialist options such as ICO and satellite radio video, with a residue of the first to market MediaFLO customers.
This analysis was originally published in Faultline, Wireless Watch’s sister title, which offers weekly insights into the digital media markets and the economics of the quad play. Please contact Peter White on [email protected] for more details.