Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 October 2012

Google Now is critical to keep oxygen flowing to the search giant

Significance: Google has had its share of failures in launching new services, but its dominance of the search/advertising business has been unquestioned. However, when Apple launched its Siri AI-driven virtual assistant, Google acknowledged that the product, and others like it, were a critical threat because they redefined the nature of search. The company has responded with Google Now, which seems to go a lot further than Siri in its intelligence, and importantly, relies more heavily on data which Google controls. The recent Apple Maps fiasco indicated one of the firm’s weak spots, that compared to its rival, it is reliant on third parties for many data services. Now has flown under the radar so far but should gain more prominence when it appears on devices like the Galaxy S III this season. Google needs to get this one right, not just to grab the search high ground back from iOS, but to stay at the helm of the Android experience, fending off rivals which seek to create alternative user interfaces, app stores and even search engines. And even more importantly, Now is vital to demonstrate how Google can hold onto its leadership in the overall search space in a multiscreen, always-connected world.

An undersung aspect of Android 4.1 (JellyBean) was the inclusion of Google’s challenge to Apple’s Siri virtual assistant, Google Now. This is not just another OS feature, but a vital application for Google to get right as it seeks to retain leadership of its core search market.

If Google loses the initiative in search, it will be under severe threat, especially as it has often been ineffective in extending its advertising model to applications like social networking. Siri-like technologies threaten to change the whole concept on which internet search is built so creating a superior rival is not just important to the Android/Apple war, but to Google’s broader business.

Executive chairman Eric Schmidt highlighted the danger a year ago when he said: “Apple has launched an entirely new approach to search technology with Siri, its voice-activated search and task completion service built into the iPhone 4S.’ In response, Google is really seizing the initiative in mobile applications from Apple, helped enormously by the very public Maps fiasco. But while that highlighted how even the iPhone maker can lower its design standards when under intense pressure, there are no indications there has been a material effect on actual iPhone sales. Google can only really capitalize by continuing to roll out superior apps and make them the clear differentiator for Android, regaining its leadership of its own OS again.

Anything that changes or enhances search and is not under Google’s control is dangerous, hence the crucial importance of Now. And by all accounts it does go significantly further than Siri in harnessing artificial intelligence techniques plus the power of Google’s huge stores of data.

The firm now urgently needs to shout about it. Unlike Apple, whose Siri launch saved the iPhone 4S debut from dullness, Now has largely slipped under the radar even though it is already available on the Nexus devices. However, that will change when it appears on bighitting phones like the Galaxy S III and HTC One S (both expected this month). That will be the start of one of the most significant bouts yet in the Apple-Google fight to dominate the mobile web experience.

Now claims to take Siri’s AI skills a step further, not just offering a ‘do engine’ (as Apple calls its product) in place of a search engine, but anticipating the questions the user will want to ask.

The key difference between Now and Siri is that the latter relies on third party services to answer users’ voice commands and queries, while the former uses Google’s Knowledge Graph. Of course, if Now proves to be a hit, that will only emphasize Apple’s Achilles’ heel, as seen in Maps, of being rather light on its own data. Also unlike Siri, Now harnesses information about the customer’s life and preferences via web searches, email and other sources to make predictions of what he or she will ask for.

Google claims this adds considerably more intelligence and accuracy to familiar preferences and recommendations engines. And the voice activated search is smart enough to prioritize its notifications according to perceived importance to the user (an audible alarm for a traffic jam alert is given as the example), and mistakes in its findings are included in the database, to be avoided in future.

Hugo Barra, Google’s director of product management for Android, told Technology Review: ‘It uses every system that Google has built in the last 10 years. It touches almost every back end system at Google’ and hides that power behind a simple, highly automated user interface.

Google Now is unproven as yet, and its database may be heavily geared to North America, but it shows the company placing significant investment not just into attacking Apple’s weak spots, but also seizing back the momentum when it comes to shaping the future web search platform. This is important, as Apple increasingly looks to create a Google-free zone in iOS, working with partners such as Baidu in China and Yandex in Russia to oust its former friend from the homescreen and even from its most critical location, the search bar.

Of course, some of the firms which are benefiting from Apple’s patronage are also looking to sideline Google in its own Android platform. Again, in an open source environment the only way it can fight this is to create apps which clearly beat the opposition in user appeal, and market them aggressively. This is why it will be important to internationalize Google Now as quickly as possible (especially as most of the firms with alternative Android platforms, like Amazon and Baidu, are poor at expanding rapidly out of their homelands).

With Google Now, the firm has taken back a lot of the high ground in redefining search, but it still has a tough battle to hold onto its leadership in mobile advertising and web services. It has not yet, despite repeated attempts, supplanted Facebook in social networking and though Google+ is its best effort yet ‘ and Facebook has its own mobile problems ‘ Schmidt also identified that as a critical threat. He told the Senate antitrust committee: “Social networking sites like Facebook and Twitter also allow users to leverage their social networks to find answers to their questions. Google is therefore competing with all methods available to access information on the internet, not just other general search engines. The source of Facebook’s competition with Google is not only through using Bing to search the internet but, also by offering users a fundamentally different way to discover and connect with information on the internet.”

And even in areas where Google is strong, there are more and more alternatives, not just in iOS but in Android, to Google Maps, Chrome and even Google Play. The latest comes from Russia, where
Yandex recently came to prominence when it replaced Google as the default option for maps, and possibly search, on iPhones in the country. Now the firm is rolling out a full alternative to Google in the Android mobile web platform, with its own app store and browser.

The move echoes that of Baidu, China’s leading search provider, which has also taken advantage of its local leadership and Google’s relatively low brand profile, compared to that in the west. Baidu has released a full mobile operating system based on Android, but sidelining the Google web services ‘ and therefore its advertising and content revenues. Amazon has done the same in the US, and now Yandex aims to be the ‘Russian Google’.

It has used the open source Chromium code, which also underpins Google Chrome and the next Android browser, combined with the Turbo technology from mobile browser specialist Opera Software, which compresses web pages for more efficient delivery to resource constrained devices. In addition, it integrates Kaspersky malware detection. This is not the first Chromium-based challenger to Google to appear in Russia ‘ just last week, web portal Mail.ru unveiled a similar offering.

Yandex has also announced its Yandex.Store for Android apps, and is calling for developers to submit their products prior to opening its doors at the end of the month. “We have built a cloud-based browser that integrates the best of our products and services and is open to other web developers,” CEO Arkady Volozh said in a statement.

Like its Chinese counterparts, Yandex hoping for international recognition once it gains a base in its huge home market, particularly by appealing to vendors and operators which want to promote their own brands and user experiences, rather than Google’s.

It boasted in a statement: ‘The company can now offer an alternative package of mobile solutions to any OEM around the world who would like to build their own Android-based smartphone or tablet. Yandex’s mobile ecosystem now has all key components to provide OEMs with an opportunity to customize their devices.’

This platform consists of the core search offering, the new browser and also a 3D user interface, Yandex.Shell; a group of apps which can be preloaded on handsets, including Yandex.Mail and Yandex.Maps; and the new storefront. However, the firm has not gone so far as to create itsown Android-based full OS, like Baidu.

The first operator to support Yandex.Store is MegaFon, one of the Russian big three cellcos, which will use a white label version of the product. Yandex will take a 30% cut of transactions in the virtual shop and says it has “preliminary agreements” with manufacturers PocketBook, Texet and 3Q to preload the store on their devices.

Such moves will boost Android by localizing the experience and increasing consumer choice but will loosen Google’s hold. As with Android hardware, the firm is being forced to fight its own corner far more aggressively. Companies which used its platform to enter the mobile space are no longer allies but competitors, seeking to wrench some of the Android-driven profits away from Google. So it is offering its own Nexus devices, to put its brand and profit model right back at the heart of the Android experience, hoping to appeal to consumers with a new focus on design and integrated hardware/software. Similarly, it will need to lead the field in key web services, making sure innovations and new experiences come out of its own engineering centers, not those of former partners. Google Now, then, is a critical testing point right in the firm’s heartland.

Google will incur higher costs than expected for Motorola:

Google has put more detail behind the costs it will incur for acquiring Motorola Mobility in May, and is looking for deeper cuts and restructuring than it announced in August. Then, it said it would axe about 4,000 jobs at the handset unit, or 20% of the workforce, but now it says, in an SEC filing, that it expects to “broaden those actions to include additional geographic regions outside of the US’.

Google said it now expects to take on severance costs of $300m, higher than the $275m it originally forecast, perhaps indicating that it is recognizing the scale of the task of running a profitable and lean smartphone company when up against the scale and growing dominance of Samsung and Apple. The search giant said it would take a charge of $90m for closing facilities and exiting markets during 2012 and 2013, and around $40m of those costs will be booked in the third quarter of this year.

“Motorola continues to evaluate its plans and further restructuring actions may occur, which may cause Google to incur additional restructuring charges, some of which may be significant,” Google said. The company’s stated aim is to refocus Motorola on a smaller portfolio of higher impact devices and to streamline its structure ‘ 40% of the VP level executives have already left. In Q2, Motorola had just 2% of the total cellphone market, making it tough to go up against Samsung’s broad channels and economies of scale. Google will accelerate the existing move towards a narrower, more profitable range, but may consider more radical action in future ‘ selling on the handset business, or turning it into a purely inhouse activity to support Google offerings such as Nexus.