Significance: Just weeks after he was the face of the Windows 8 and Surface tablet launch, Microsoft’s Windows chief Steve Sinofsky has departed, and nobody will be more interested in his successor, Julie Larson-Green, than Nokia. The Finnish firm’s CEO insisted it still had a ‘special relationship’ with Microsoft, but even if that is true, it currently goes no further than handsets, increasingly a dead end in terms of device innovation and influence. Smartphones may deliver the volumes that Microsoft craves for Windows Phone, but it is in the increasing convergence of WP8 with Windows 8 where new device/service formats will be found and new leaders identified. So far, Nokia has had no role in W8 or larger screened products, and that could be a fatal error for which its genuinely market leading activity, in mapping, will not be able to compensate.
Nokia’s CEO Stephen Elop insists that his firm still enjoys a ‘special relationship’ with Microsoft, though like the more famous ‘special relationship’ between the US and UK, it is clearly more important to the European side of the axis. He was commenting specifically on the favors Microsoft has been granting to other Windows Phone vendors, such as long time partner HTC, but there are far bigger issues for Nokia. One is that it has no role in Windows 8, even as Microsoft is likely to converge its two platforms, a process that may be accelerated under W8’s new chief, Julie Larson-Green. Beyond handsets, HTC will be the least of the Finnish firm’s worries when it comes to Windows fellow travellers, with all Microsoft’s old PC friends leaping into W8 tablets and hybrids. And of course, Nokia may even see Microsoft itself launching a smartphone in its Surface family next year, a move CEO Steve Ballmer has hinted at several times.
In this situation it is unsurprising that Nokia is placing ever more emphasis on the one area of its business where it still leads the market, mapping, and ‘ in this area at least ‘ severing dependence on a single operating system.
Nonetheless, Elop told a Morgan Stanley technology conference in Barcelona that Nokia remains in pole position in Windows Phone, even though other vendors like Samsung are showing far greater commitment to the OS in its new generation; Microsoft has given very vocal backing to some rival launches, notably a cross-marketing pact for HTC; and the software giant dealt Nokia a poor hand when it said WP8 would not be backwards compatible with WP7, leaving the Finnish firm’s Lumia base stranded. He insisted, according to Reuters, that rivals are ‘not sitting in the priority meetings that we’re sitting in’.
However, the latest Lumia models, the 920 and 820, have been launched at AT&T, with variants planned for Verizon, and are being well received in Europe, according to several cellcos. Telefonica O2 Germany’s CEO Rene Schuster, for instance, told the same conference that he was “very, very pleased” with early Lumia sales. Operators are keen for WP8 to succeed, to provide a viable counterweight to Apple and Android, whose power bases are often seen to be in conflict with carriers’ priorities.
However, analysts remain less convinced. Michael Schroder, an analyst with the Finnish investment bank FIM Securities, predicts that Nokia will sell between one million and three million of its new Lumia models during this quarter, which would be very disappointing given that it managed to shift 2.9m of its older Lumia products during Q312, and that was a slip on previous quarters. And the latest smartphone rankings from Gartner calculated that Nokia had dropped from number three position in the second quarter, to number seven in the third. Samsung and Apple took the top two spots of course, but the increasingly consolidation of the sector in their hands was highlighted by the fact that RIM and HTC managed to take the third and fourth positions even on the back of declining sales. Samsung made 55m sales in Q3 to take 32.5% of the global market, widening the gap with Apple, which sold 23.6m iPhones. With almost half the base between them, other vendors are fighting for a ‘distant third place’, said the analysts. In overall mobile devices, Nokia is still in second place ahead of Apple.
Against this bleak backdrop, Nokia can cling to one source of growth and leadership. Its mapping activities have moved to the center of its strategy as other businesses have declined, almost justifying its huge $8.1bn purchase of Navteq. It has signed a string of licensees for its Maps platform, both in the smartphone world and among carmakers and embedded players. Now it is pushing its location plans further with the introduction of a cloud-based platform called Here, which will reach out to iOS users stranded by Apple’s second-rate launch of its own mapping service.
Nokia also announced that it had acquired Earthmine, a specialist in 3D mapping technology ‘ a key feature of recent enhancements to Google Maps and Apple’s offering. Speaking at the launch event, CEO Stephen Elop said: “Maps and location experiences should inspire us to sense our world’, claiming that Nokia’s next generation system would create ‘more personal maps that change how we navigate our lives’, by using greater “quality and quantity” of data than ever before.
He promised Nokia Here would be ‘the best location platform in the industry’ for almost any device, and would “transform mapping in ways we haven’t even thought possible yet’. By targeting most mobile products and operating systems, Nokia is cutting the cord between its mapping system and its own phones, or Microsoft’s WP8. This shows it is recognizing that the Navteq unit has potential well beyond its own platform, and that it can even generate valuable revenues in the transition period while it waits for Windows Phone to take off.
The HTML5 browser-based mobile platforms which are starting to emerge could become challengers, in time, for Windows Phone and the other native OSs, but that is not putting Nokia off forming new partnerships to boost its crown jewel. It announced a location focused alliance with Mozilla ‘ soon to release its own cloud-oriented mobile OS ‘ based around HTML5.
“We want to give everyone with any type of device the ability to use this’ Elop added. So Nokia will roll out a software developers’ kit for Android during the first quarter of next year, while Here Maps for iOS will make its debut within a few weeks.
Nokia Here will integrate conventional Navteq data, as well as many other data sources and methods, plus information contributed to the cloud-based system by its users. Michael Halbherr, head of the firm’s location and commerce unit, said: “We need to translate usage into better services so that more people are using Here. We need to deal with millions and millions of updates.” Perhaps in a swipe at Apple and its now notorious mapping errors, he added: “If my daily life depends on it, what is on a map has to be accurate.”
As for the Earthmine deal, both firms’ photographic capture and modeling solutions will be integrated into one process, with the main focus on urban modelling, or computational cartography, which can ‘compute the city — not just visualize it’. Halbherr stressed the scalability of a cloud platform, saying that the new system would actually feature “millions of maps” layered on one another for on-demand computation and information based on the particular requirements of the user. And with much of the processing done on the server, the service is suited to low profile devices and data connections as well as smartphones and tablets.
There is high confidence in the maps platform, which really does stand a chance of defining the next generation of location experience and services ‘ something which, as Apple’s failure showed, is no mean feat. If Navteq were still a standalone business, this would be a huge breakthrough, but Nokia’s business model is not adapted to being a cloud or applications player alone, but to shifting large numbers of devices ‘ and hopefully moving towards an integrated hardware/services play, like Apple and Amazon. But this is about apps and content adding value and incremental revenues to smartphones, not about ditching the devices ‘ especially at a time when software-only giants like Microsoft are going the other way. Becoming an industry standard mapping platform for everyone ‘ consumer or industrial ‘ without their own cloud offering is a powerful and achievable strategy, but it is far too little to save Nokia in anything like its current, or rather its former, form.
To regain past glories, it not only needs to build up consumer and carrier love for its new devices, but to drive the future experience and services they support. And that in turn requires Nokia to be the primary vendor performing that role for the whole Windows Phone platform, otherwise it will be forever merely an also-ran player in smartphones, with none of its former influence over the industry. And it is almost certain that, on its own, Windows Phone will never gain significant market share. Instead, it will become powerful by being an element of the broader Windows offering, spanning x86 servers and clients, ARM-based connected devices, and mobile gadgets. Nokia’s ability to be a mover and shaker in ‘big Windows’ is far from assured, whatever the ‘special relationship’ in handsets. Handsets alone will become a segment of commoditized devices and price wars, where the economies of scale Nokia is rapidly losing will be more important than innovation or services.
The opportunities to drive the industry and gain decent margins and influence will come in emerging device types, in which Nokia has so far made no moves at all. This is partly because of Microsoft’s decision to confine Windows Phone to small screens, keeping the tablet market for Windows RT, but that in itself should have sounded loud warning bells for Nokia, seeing itself crushed into an unprofitable niche with its primary OS ‘ and if it ventured into Windows RT, having to compete on a level playing field with everyone else.
The future strategy for converging W8 and WP8 ‘ which already share a code base and user interface ‘ and how far Nokia is included in that process, will depend in part on the new head of Windows, Julie Larson-Green, who was appointed to replace Steve Sinofsky, abruptly ousted this week just a few weeks after he was the face of the W8 launch. Sinofsky himself denied that one factor in his departure was a failed bid to take control of the Windows Phone division and include it in the main Windows business, but that is likely to be a future move anyway. WP8 is currently located with Xbox and other device activities but has suffered from changes in leadership itself since former mobile chief Andy Lees was moved aside after poor performance of WP7 ‘ he then negotiated Microsoft’s deal with Barnes & Noble and recently took a role in charge of corporate strategy and development.
Sinofsky’s departure will inevitably be portrayed as a sign of a crisis of confidence in Microsoft’s senior ranks over what many see as a make-or-break platform. It certainly looks like a sudden decision, given the center stage he was given at the W8 coming-out events. And so far, Microsoft’s gamble on following Apple into an integrated hardware/software platform is showing mixed results. CEO Steve Ballmer’s launch-day bullishness was tempered this week when he admitted early sales of the company’s own Surface tablet ‘ designed to alienate PC partners as much as it showcases the new OS ‘ were ‘modest’.
Of course, a senior executive would hardly be pushed out after just a couple of weeks of lacklustre sales of a high risk product, and sources insist his departure has no connection to the quality or reception of the products.
Instead, insiders say Microsoft had grown concerned about Sinofsky’s ability to cooperate with colleagues, including Ballmer himself. But more generally, it seems that the CEO wants to put together a brand new team to steer Windows 8, which is far more than an OS upgrade ‘ it comes close to convergence with its mobile stablemate WP8, to offer a multiscreen platform, and so carries the burden both of prolonging the life of the PC and allowing Microsoft, at last, to challenge Google and Apple on other devices.
The new team might have been better assembled pre-launch, and analysts are now braced for another phase of management transition at Microsoft ‘ transition which some believe should include Ballmer if the W8 gamble does not pay off in full. The company’s stock fell by 2.1% on the news.
Sinofsky has worked for Microsoft for 23 years and focused on Office until 2006, when he moved to the Windows business. He was credited with turning that unit around after the disaster of the Windows Vista release and was widely tipped as a CEO-in-waiting. However, his recent record has been less shiny, partly because of trends beyond his control, notably the decline of the traditional PC and the rise of Apple ‘ trends which W8 and Surface are designed to address. However, revenue at the Windows division has fallen short of Wall Street forecasts in six of the past eight quarters, with a 3% year-on-year decline in fiscal 2012.
In the official comments, Ballmer said of Sinofsky: “I am grateful for the many years of work that Steven has contributed to the company’, while the departing executive said more effusively: “It is impossible to count the blessings I have received over my years at Microsoft. I am humbled by the professionalism and generosity of everyone I have had the good fortune to work with at this awesome company.’ A Microsoft executive recently told CNet: ‘As you think about future leadership, collaboration will be critical in a way it has never has before.”
SInofsky’s successor, Julie Larson-Green, hardly brings the needed new blood into Microsoft, having joined in 1993. She moved to the Windows unit from Office with Sinofsky and was most recently VP of product management.
However, she led the team which drove the redesign of Windows, adopting a brand new user interface close to that pioneered on Windows Phone. Her strengths are seen as being in product design and user experience, which will be valuable in the fight against similarly skilled Apple executives ‘ she also oversaw the change in Office’s look and feel, and was in charge of all program management, R&D and development of international releases for W8. Unlike her departing boss, she is also known for her ability to get along with a wide range of people. Nokia will need to hope that Elop is one of those people, and that her track record of respect for Windows Phone will extend to giving a enhanced role to the Finnish firm, well beyond the handset.