Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 December 2012

Chip upheaval: should Intel become a foundry, or Apple buy STE?

The future relationship between Apple and Intel is a popular topic of speculation and rumor, often involving a possible ousting of Intel from the Mac family. However, the latest twist is more optimistic about the chip giant ‘ analyst Doug Freeman of RBC Capital Markets thinks Intel could win a foundry deal from the iDevice maker. The thinking is that Intel should increase the revenues it generates from its advanced process technologies by creating a foundry business ‘ it has shown some small signs of this in the past year. That would ease Apple’s supply constraints and reduce its reliance on Samsung, and in return it would keep the Intel chips in its Macs and even push them into some iDevices as the two product ranges converge.

The counter to that line of thought is that Apple wants to become more self-sufficient in chips, having designed its own mobile processor, which is based on the ARM core (which Apple has considerable ability to tailor, since it holds an architectural licence going back to its roots as a co-founder of the UK firm). Some believe that, rather than increasing the role of the less malleable x86, it will extend its own Ax architecture into Macs and look around for other components to own, perhaps snapping up a modem maker.

Of course, Apple’s A6 processor is currently manufactured by previous chip design partner (and now bitter enemy) Samsung. This has given rise to periodic rumors that Apple would extend its processor design into the Mac products, replacing Intel’s x86-based chips. Even if that happened, the consolation for Intel could be a contract to manufacture the ARM-based chips. Apple has been looking for an alternative to Samsung as its foundry, and working with TSMC of Taiwan ‘ although for now the transition has been hampered by problems in getting to the right quality and volume levels, and by contractual commitments to Samsung until 2015. Intel, meanwhile, has been making chips for a couple of small third parties, which many take to be a sign that it wants to get into the foundry business, to generate another revenue stream from its massive investments in advanced processes. It may have used recent breakthroughs like its 3D transistor design to lure Apple, say some sources.

Freedman believes Apple may be considering a deal under which Intel would make the iDevice processors in return for x86 chips remaining in the MacBook, or even appearing in some high performance mobile products such as future top end iPads. “We believe Intel has the upper hand due to the limitations of capacity at alternative sources … as the demand is outstripping Apple’s ability to add supply,” Freedman wrote in a client note, quoted by CNet.

An industry source told the news site that the two US giants have held on-off talks over the past two years about a possible foundry deal, but that Intel would demand a big incentive to agree to help Apple out with its capacity challenges ‘ which will worsen if it cuts ties with Samsung. Several Apple launches have suffered from shortages of key components and major mobile players are acutely aware of the risk of supply constraints. These hit Qualcomm’s performance earlier in the year and in this area, Apple and Qualcomm are not in their usual strong negotiating position against supply chain partners. Both were reported to have been rebuffed earlier this year, when they tried to secure exclusive capacity at TSMC, the world’s largest contract chipmaker.

And Intel could leverage its process advantages to make advanced chips for third parties. Rick Merritt of EETimes is one commentator who believes the firm should manufacture processors for Apple, Cisco and other large firms which do not compete with Intel on the open market, and where the silicon giant would also have the opportunity to push its own platforms into their other product lines. He comments: ‘World-class semiconductor manufacturing is as valuable as ever, even as Moore’s Law slows. Here, Intel is still tops. First with high-k metal gate transistors. First with FinFETs. Tons of capacity in leading edge fabs all over the world. There’s little doubt it will be first to field the extreme ultraviolet lithography that is key to next generation processes.’

This would be a useful hedge against possible permanent decline of x86, if the architecture fails to make a convincing transition from PCs to mobile, and if Intel fails to get PC-style gadgets like ultrabooks into the heart of the post-PC generation.

But another analyst, Will Strauss of Forward Concepts, thinks Apple should become even more independent when it comes to chips, so that even an Intel foundry deal would not come with a commitment to x86. The iPhone maker should acquire its own modem technology in order to produce the highly integrated systems-on-chip that Qualcomm and others can do, driving down cost and power consumption as the iDevices hunt for the mass market. ST-Ericsson and Renesas Mobile would both be affordable options, he argues, both having strong 3G and LTE baseband technology but huge financial challenges.

Strauss argues, in his latest research newsletter, that Apple arch-rival Samsung has internal 3G/4G modem capabilities and is integrating that with its Exynos app processor (its own CMC221S LTE/3G/2G modem is shipping in Samsung Galaxy S3 smartphone, replacing Via modems in some models). Apple currently uses modems from Qualcomm and so there is limited integration potential with A6. A feature of the two giants’ handset fight is their increasing level of control over every component of the phone, but so far Samsung is ahead on that score because of its chip, memory and display subsidiaries.

“There are few opportunities to acquire an advanced modem design like Samsung’s, so Apple has to be exploring possible in-house design (no easy task) or casting eyes on LTE/3G/2G modems from ST-Ericsson or Renesas Mobile,” said Strauss.

Such debates also raise the issue of whether hardware control will be essential to competing in the smartphone big league in future, because it supports differentiation, cost reduction and better guarantees of quality and availability of components ‘ or whether the industry will go through its usual cycle again and revert to outsourcing. After all, iron control and a heavy dose of inhouse design was characteristic of Nokia and Motorola in their heyday, and then the sector shifted towards a more open market model.

One handset maker which may be considering greater self-sufficiency is LG, according to Korea Times. The firm has started to design its own mobile processors, reports the newspaper, and will unveil them at the Consumer Electronics Show next month. Insiders say the firm has about 900 designers working on chips for smartphones and web TVs as CEO Koo Bon-joon pursues a growth strategy focused on increased “independence and dignity’. Unlike Samsung, LG does not manufacture processors so would turn to a foundry, probably TSMC.