Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 March 2013

T-Mobile USA poised to make its break with subsidies next week

Mobile operators have been toying for a decade with ways to reduce their reliance on subsidies, but real efforts have either been halfhearted or, like last year’s in Spain, a step too far for the market. However, the US majors, led by T-Mobile, are leading the way and the fourth US cellco is expected to announce its ‘Uncarrier’ range of tariffs at an event next Tuesday.

This will be a step towards fulfilling the pledge it made in December to eliminate subsidies on cellphones this year, which could radically change the relationship with major handset vendors. Of course, it is easier for TMo to make this move then the big two, since the bulk of its base is prepaid and therefore pays upfront for most of the device cost. When it concludes its merger prepaid-only MetroPCS, this balance will be even more marked.

However, TMo has also pioneered some creative thinking about alternatives to subsidies for postpaid users, mainly centered on various financing options, which could also help pay-as-you-go users to afford higher ticket handsets ‘ and probably end up paying for more data and services too. And major postpaid rival Verizon Wireless has also vocally said it expects to reduce the role of subsidies significantly from this year onwards.

According to a TMoNews, next week will see the unveiling of two groups of plans ‘ the ‘Uncarrier Classic’, to be offered through retailers like Best Buy; and ‘Value’, to be provided by in the cellco’s own outlets.

For the Uncarrier option, plans range from $60 a month for 500Mbytes of data to $130 a month for 12GBbytes. Unlimited talk and text come free and there is an unlimited data option at $90 a month, though without a hotspot function. Customers will pay for their devices by the month, or bring their own unlocked handsets, entirely cutting ties with the traditional two-year contract plus subsidy.

Verizon Wireless is less aggressive than TMo, but CFO Fran Shammo told a recent Deutsche Bank telecoms conference that he expected subsidies to fall over the next 2-3 years. This would be down less to operator strategies than the increasing price and feature set competition between smartphones, even at the high end, which will prevent a company like Apple achieving the kind of sway over its cellco partners which is still seen in the iPhone space. “I’m a believer that over the next two to three years subsidies will start to decrease just because of the ecosystems,” he said.

TMo will face some dilemmas in its new strategy when it finally gets its long awaited iPhone this year. Before the holiday, new CEO John Legere revealed that his agreement with Apple does not include the volume commitments included Sprint’s controversial pact with the iPhone maker. The carrier is also determined not to fall into the usual ‘iPhone trap’ which makes the gadget a double-edged sword for many operators ‘ because of the hefty subsidy bill.

Legere said that the subsidy alternatives would apply to the iPhone too, enabling customers to pay an upfront fee for the device and then pay off the balance of the cost in monthly instalments. That will give TMo more flexibility to reward users with competitive rates for the monthly data plan. Currently the cellco offers Classic plans which subsidize the device and require a two-year contract, and Value plans which allow the customer either to pay for the handset upfront or in monthly instalments, in return for lower data plan rates. In 2013, only the Value options will be available, though with the addition of the Uncarrier variant.

“We think there is a huge room for a carrier to change in a way that the larger players will choose to, or will not be able to, respond to,” Legere said. Presumably referring to the iPhone, he said users could be able to buy the “most iconic device in the world” for $99 plus monthly payments of $15 or $20 over the next 20 months.

Value customers bring in lower margins than Classic, according to Legere, at 33% and 46% respectively, but the change removes the costs of subsidies and Value users typically stay for two months longer, on average, than their Classic counterparts.

In Europe, though high profile no-subsidy experiments like those in Spain have delivered mixed results, there is progress being made. Some regulators are accelerating the shift by threatening to ban contracts of over one year or let consumers leave their deals if prices go up. And Informa estimates that 30-plus operators have dropped subsidies for at least some customers. The main strategy is to replace subsidies and contracts with leasing and financing plans such as Vodafone’s Red Hot and O2 Germany’s My Handy.