Pity poor BlackBerry. Just as confidence in turnaround CEO John Chen’s recovery plan was mounting, Apple has hit the firm in its remaining strongholds by signing a far-reaching enterprise services alliance with IBM. However, for all Chen’s efforts, this will only hasten the inevitable, of BlackBerry quitting its once-iconic devices and focusing on its back end services, though even there, an IBM/Apple combination will throw up new hurdles. For the new-found friends themselves, the ailing Canadian firm will not be the target anyway ‘ this will be aimed firmly at Microsoft, and on Apple’s side at least, Google.
The two US giants have had a stormy history. Their long rival in personal computers ended when IBM exited that business, but two years ago, the services firm banned employees from using Siri and iCloud (among other services) on security grounds, and insisted its staff used BlackBerries. Whatever its internal policies, most of IBM’s enterprise customers will not have the same control over their employees’ devices and apps in the era of BYOD, so one focus of the new deal will be to improve enterprise-class security for Apple users.
The companies hailed their agreement, named ‘IBM MobileFirst for iOS’, as a ‘landmark’ and IBM CEO Ginni Rometty praised Apple as ‘the gold standard for consumers’, apparently forgetting similar enterprise-focused alliances it has made in the past with companies like Samsung and, of course, Microsoft. If it puts greater resource into this one than some past efforts, Apple will certainly be able to build on its already impressive growth in the enterprise, acquiring a new salesforce, a hugely trusted brand in areas like security, and 100 new iOS business applications.
These 100 apps are the heart of the deal. They will be created jointly by IBM and Apple, exclusive to iOS and tailored to individual vertical markets such as retail, healthcare, banking, transportation, telecoms and insurance. This will give Apple, already a strong player in the enterprise, the ability to target specific segments in a way its current frameworks do not allow.
In addition, IBM’s cloud services such as device management, security and analytics will be optimized for iOS. This is where BlackBerry, as well as other mobile management platforms, will feel the pinch ‘ and the move may also prevent Apple being tempted to bring its own expanding artificial intelligence platforms into the enterprise space, rather than keeping them for consumers and Siri. IBM’s analytics engines, including the famous Watson machine learning platform, are a critical aspect of its services and mobile-first offering. So it is a considerable coup that Apple has agreed to standardize on its new friend’s analytics and big data apps, effectively cutting a hefty market off for other players in this booming area.
Apple has also agreed to tailor AppleCare for enterprise deployments with support onsite via IBM; and use IBM’s Fiberlink MaaS360 for mobile device management; while IBM will package device activation, supply and management for the iOS partnership; sell vertical-focused iDevices bundled with its apps; and lend the support of its 100,000-strong consultancy group and its financing arm to push Apple solutions.
IBM has been shifting heavily towards services to help large enterprises adopt mobile-first strategies, and will now be able to tap into the popularity of the iDevices among corporate employees. That should give its services business some new angles to play with, but more importantly, it will put some of its important enterprise apps, and particularly its growing data analytics platforms, firmly in the face of the Apple community.
Apple CEO Tim Cook said: “We’re putting IBM’s renowned big data analytics at iOS users’ fingertips, which opens up a large market opportunity for Apple. This is a radical step for enterprise and something that only Apple and IBM can deliver.”
Other large enterprise services suppliers will now be looking for their own alliances. Google, of course, has a readymade seam to sow with its Android partners, but will be aware that iOS’s market share in the enterprise, unlike the consumer world, is larger than Android’s. Android suppliers, like Samsung, which have invested heavily in enterprise solutions, are now locked out of the IBM community in vertical sectors, while enterprise software players such as Oracle and SAP will similarly see a key potential alliance snatched away.
Microsoft is the obvious target of the collaboration, but is likely to be the most resilient against its impact too, since the company has worked hard to get the large number of remaining Windows enterprises to adopt its mobility and cloud solutions too. The more it pushes those, but opens up Office and other key apps to iOS, the more it may be able to work around the IBM/Apple combination, except in verticals where IBM is significantly more powerful than its erstwhile PC friend. As analyst Charles King of Pund-IT said: ‘Having official IBM support for those 100 apps will be attractive to some core IBM constituencies, but it’s hard to say how many will jump to replace what they have now.’
It was only in March that IBM went out to bat for its old ally, more than 30 years after it made the company’s fortune by backing MS-Dos. Four months ago, Jim Szafranski, SVP of customer platform services, said Windows Phone was the best mobile platform for the enterprise, mainly because of its integration with the huge historic base of Microsoft technologies, and announced that Big Blue had added WP8 support to its mobile device management (MDM) platform, recently acquired with Fiberlink. Although he acknowledged that “actual end user momentum is trailing business interest’ in WP8, he added: ‘IT likes Microsoft and likes Windows. They’ve made a lot of investment in things like Active Directory and Exchange and as a result they have a lot of interest in seeing Windows Phone used by employees.” Clearly, that interest has not been strong enough to keep IBM out of Apple’s clutches.
While many are calling this the ‘last straw’ for BlackBerry, it may also create some interesting echoes of the Canadian firm’s story. As the consumer smartphone market commoditizes, it is likely to account for less of Apple’s revenue and share, and certainly its profit. Like BlackBerry, it may find itself increasingly relying on the enterprise segment to drive the iDevices, but in that market, the real sellers are the apps and the back end services. Unlike BlackBerry, Apple now has no need to build those itself, and has acquired itself a readymade hedge against falling profits in the consumer mobile world. For all the ‘cool’ that Apple brings stodgy old IBM, that makes the smartphone maker a far bigger winner from the deal than its new partner.