Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 July 2014

EPB utility to petition FCC to expand gigabit fiber triple-play service

City-owned utility EPB Chattanooga is planning to petition the FCC to allow it to expand its gigabit fiber triple-play offering to the Tennessee communities that neighbor Chattanooga. Following praise and tacit approval from the FCC, which is required by law to identify and remove broadband expansion barriers, EPB plans to expand to any community that requests gigabit internet including deployments in other states if it is successful in its petition.

Incentivizing customers with a fast internet connection may be the easiest way to deploy a smart grid, given that you need access to the customer home to install the end-point smart meter. While not so applicable to the US market where utilities are broken into hundreds of local providers, such an approach could be adopted by the larger national providers found in Europe as a way of rolling out nationwide smart grids while providing a boost to the average national broadband speed.

This is the latest development in the legal exchanges between EPB (formerly the Electric Power Board of Chattanooga) and local rivals after EPB became the first company in the US to supply gigabit internet to consumers. It has so far defended against four lawsuits, from opponents who believe that as a public body EPB gains a competitive edge against non-taxpayer owned companies. Currently, EPB can only supply internet connections to customers who buy electricity from it.

Now the tide seems poised on the edge of turning in utility-owned broadband’s favor. Former FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski said in 2013 that EPB’s network was ‘one of the vital components of our broadband strategy.’ His successor, Tom Wheeler, criticized Tennessee’s municipal broadband laws saying Chattanooga was ‘the poster child for both the benefits of community broadband networks, and also a prime example of the efforts to restrict them.’

But the FCC approval was met by a letter from a group of senators, who noted their ‘deep concern regarding the insinuation that the FCC will force taxpayer funded competition against private broadband providers, against the wishes of the states.

However, the fact that EPB reports that there are many communities within its operational area that completely lack a broadband connection of any kind is proof of the reasoning behind the FCC plans to boost broadband expansion. Whether you are against the political act of funding this expansion with tax revenue, you must admit that it is backward that one side of a freeway can receive gigabit speeds while the other is prevented from any connection due to a law without recognizing that the existing model of broadband legislation isn’t working optimally.

‘Communities should have the right, at the local level, to determine their broadband futures,’ said Harold DePriest, president and CEO of EPB. ‘We believe that internet access is the critical infrastructure for the 21st century.’ EPB spokesperson Danna Bailey added ‘while we don’t want to be in a political fight, we think this is important and that our neighbors should have access to the same gigabit speeds that we enjoy.’

While EPB has promised to separate its ISP activities from its electrical division, the company itself has been able to use a $111.5 million stimulus grant for building a fiber optic smart grid to its benefit. EPB also borrowed $219 million to finance the rest of the construction, so we’re not entirely sure that the complaints of rival ISPs are justifiable, given that the federal government only bankrolled a third of the total cost of construction. The grant from the Department of Energy’s American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) was both the largest grant and the largest grant amount per capita at the time.

Since the date of the grant in 2009, EPB has rolled out a fiber network to 60,000 of its 169,000 electricity customers that it claims is only surpassed by a handful of research universities. However, in February this year, EPB said that only 3,640 residences and 55 business premises had signed up to the gigabit service, with the remainder of its 60,000 customers opting for the 100Mbs option. All of the 169,000 customers were scheduled to receive a Tantalus FTTH smart meter, the end-point of the smart grid installation, at a rate of 1,500 deployed per week.

The Tantalus meters report the kWh consumption and voltage on request, as well as in intervals as low as 15 minutes for singlephase lines and 5 minutes for polyphase. The smart meters report outage alerts, restoration confirmations, voltage swells, sags and blinks, which allow a utility to monitor the health of its network ‘ with multi-hop communication in the 900MHz range, otherwise known as ZigBee, the meters can talk to each other as well as to customer equipment for home usage monitoring.

According to EPB’s COO, David Wade, the smart grid project and broadband connectivity ‘will enable EPB’s electric system to be intelligent, interactive and self-healing ‘ helping us to reduce customer outage minutes by 40%, provide our customers with the at-home tools and resources that will allow them to manage their energy use and increase power quality.’ A time-of-use billing pilot scheme of 22 manufacturers was said to produce savings of $2.3 million a year for the businesses involved. Wade also said that choosing fiber meant future proofing against increases in consumption.

The main reason that EPB chose fiber was for the low latency it provided for the two way communications required for ‘coordinated load shedding activities, the split second responsiveness required in distribution automation, and for a virtual real-time energy management tool for customers.’ That it turned the utility into a potentially dominant ISP in the process was a welcome side-effect.

Lafayette, Louisiana, and Bristol, Virginia are both cities that have tried the municipal fiber route and achieved gigabit networks, and a handful of other cities have new networks that aren’t quite so fast. Google’s Fiber project is another privately-held project to install fiber internet infrastructure in the US.