The Wireless Power Consortium (WPC) announced a partnership with furniture giant IKEA at Mobile World Congress, in Barcelona earlier this week. Starting in April sales of a range of wireless-charging enabled furniture will begin in the US and Europe. The furniture will use WPC’s Qi technology which is supported by over 300 devices currently.
WPC appears to have trumped the recent merger of two other wireless charging bodies – the Alliance for Wireless Power (A4WP) and the Power Matters Alliance (PMA) – by signing up one of the world’s most popular retailers. At the moment WPC mostly offers wireless free charging from cars, train stations, and coffee shops.
As is often the case in standardization battles, it won’t necessarily be the sophistication of the technology on offer which is the deciding factor, but the real-world realization and implementation into the consumer’s life.
WPC so far have been front-runners here with more supported devices and commercial installations, and now with the IKEA announcement, a step into the smart-home market. In technological sophistication we think A4WP is in the lead.
Both WPC’s and A4WP’s wireless charging implementations exploit the same physics – inductive coupling. Passing AC through a coil of wire produces an oscillating magnetic field, and if another coil is placed in proximity the magnetic field induces current flow – hence wireless-energy transfer.
The difference between WPC’s Qi and A4WP’s Rezence platform is whether the transmitter and receiver circuitry inside the device and base-station are resonantly tuned.
Currently WPC’s Qi technology uses non-resonant inductive coupling; referred to by the industry as Magnetic Induction (MI). Whereas A4WP’s Rezence platform is resonantly tuned; referred to as Magnetic Resonance (MR) not to be confused with magnetic resonance imaging.
Qi’s non-resonant inductive coupling implementation isn’t as selective over which frequency it can absorb energy at, but its efficiency is more highly dependent on the proximity and alignment of the two coils than MR technology. Practically the range is around 5mm, which means only one device can be charged at one time using MI.
In A4WP’s MR implementation the coils in the base-station and device are tuned to a specific resonant frequency, meaning they absorb and emit energy most efficiently at this frequency, with a sharp drop-off of energy transfer on either side of the spectrum.
The design and cost of the two implementations are similar and the MI solution provides greater energy-transfer efficiency, and larger operational distances, around 5cm. This allows for multiple devices to be charged at once from the same base-station. This does increase charge time however.
It is worth noting that Qi is addressing this technological disparity, and has recently announced work on a backwards compatible MR implementation.
Early reports indicate the IKEA implementation of Qi will only supply around 5W of juice, which will be enough for a smartphone or tablet, but not a laptop.
IKEA claims the Qi support will be packaged as an optional extra to a selection of their current products, for around $22, and is also planning to offer wireless charging kits that fit to existing furniture, at $33.