Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 May 2015

Xiaomi squeezes Qualcomm with inhouse processor moves

Qualcomm is under intense pressure in its traditional markets for smartphone chips and IPR. Antitrust probes round the world, industry shifts towards new licensing models, the rise of some powerful competitors in China, and the trend for handset makers to design their own processors – all these are creating the most dangerous situation for the company since the mobile world decided to move away from the CDMA-based technologies the US giant dominates.

Qualcomm has always had weeble-like qualities though, and regularly bounces back from the most threatening situations with a new twist on its business model or its technology. This year, that will focus primarily on the internet of things, not just a slew of new chips from its Snapdragon and Atheros units, but an attempt to set new standards via the AllSeen Alliance (see separate item).

However, the mobile chipset market – and associated patents – remain its bread and butter, and there is no denying the challenges. Qualcomm may have seen off powerful US modem and processor rivals such as Nvidia, Broadcom and Texas Instruments, but it is facing equally powerful newer competitors in Greater China, which are moving up from their traditional low end markets into the loftier heights of 4G and multimedia, along with the local handset makers with which they have such valuable ties. Just as Texas Instruments rode Nokia’s rise up the cellphone ranks, and Qualcomm has benefited from the past successes of HTC, BlackBerry and of course Apple, so MediaTek and Spreadtrum will hope to be the beneficiaries of Xiaomi’s rise from featurephone maker to fully fledged international smartphone contender.

Or perhaps they won’t … The problem for system-on-chip providers is the modern tendency for handset makers, once they pull themselves out of the ocean of featurephone vendors and walk tall on 4G smartphone ground, to decide to go it alone in processors. Samsung is squeezing Qualcomm out of both the processor and modem slots in many Galaxy models, as it enhances the capabilities and volumes of its own Exynos SoC. Huawei is set to follow the same path as it invests in processor and baseband technology in its HiSilicon subsidiary.

Many companies will not brave the difficult modem side, but at least want a differentiated processor which they can control. Apple, of course, took this step, with the inhouse Ax family, although it has Qualcomm modems. Even HTC was said to be working with a Chinese supplier to a customized apps processor. And now Xiaomi is taking the same route, it seems, just at the time when its primary supplier, MediaTek, might be hoping for a significant boost to its sales from the handset maker’s expansion into higher end devices and new markets such as India and even, in a modest way so far, Europe.

The news comes from EETimes, via an interview with Chinese fabless chip company Leadcore. One of its VPs, Marshal Cheng, revealed that Leadcore is to make a customized processor for Xiaomi – a lower cost option than building a whole inhouse team, like Apple and Huawei, but still with the capability to give the handset maker a high level of control over its silicon destiny and differentiation. Leadcore, a subsidiary of Datang, is working with Xiaomi on “all three different levels – product, technology and patent,” said Cheng.

Xiaomi already uses off-the-shelf Leadcore chipsets in some models, including the ultra-low cost LTE handset, the $100 Redmi 2a, and there were reports last year that it was planning to take a 51% stake in the company, though Cheng denied this in the interview. However, it is clear why it would get closer to the supplier. It is not just to move towards differentiated chips and a vertically integrated, tightly managed supply chain, like Apple. It is also to improve its patent position, something it made clear was a priority when its products suffered a temporary sales ban in India because of lawsuits by Ericsson.

That battle drags on, but one of the issues it highlights is the disadvantage of being a vendor without significant standards-essential IPR. The devices targeted by Ericsson’s claims (Redmi Note and Mi3) are based on MediaTek processors, which legal experts say are not covered by a cross-licensing deal between the chipmaker and the Swedish firm, as would be the case for a Qualcomm SoC (Qualcomm’s deal with Ericsson apparently covers its chip customers too). Xiaomi does use Qualcomm chips in some models, such as Redmi 2.

Xiaomi is building its own patent arsenal, and applied for over 2,300 patents in 2014, boasting it will have “tens of thousands” within a decade. And this is another advantage of a close alliance with Leadcore, whose partly state-owned parent, Datang, led the development of the Chinese 3G standard, TD-SCDMA, and all the IPR which went with that. A strong position in TD-SCDMA is a market advantage – as Marvell knows –  because it opens the door to supplying China Mobile, the only user of the technology, with multimode 3G/LTE handsets, and because some of the IPR has found its way into the far more widely adopted TD-LTE.

Cheng said that the modem technology and patents created by the China Academy of Telecommunication Technology, which founded Datang, are “very attractive to Xiaomi”, especially in LTE and LTE-Advanced. It may certainly reduce the risk of going Qualcomm-free, as Xiaomi is doing with the Redmi 2a, which is based on Leadcore’s LC1860 SoC, based on a 2 GHz, six-core ARM Cortex-A7 processor with a Mali T628 GPU.

But for the next generation, the companies will work on customized implementations, harnessing the software defined radio technology Leadcore has developed since 2012, based on CEVA digital signal processor cores. This will enable new modem standards to be supported quickly, as well as non-mainstream ones, perhaps including LTE Category 0, which is emerging for machine-to-machine devices.

All this will enhance Xiaomi’s position in terms of access to innovative technology and patents, especially if ‘5G’ proves to be heavily driven by Chinese inventions. And of course it adds another cloud to Qualcomm’s Chinese sky. Although the US company settled its antitrust differences with China’s authorities, enabling it to trade and collect licensing fees more easily, the rising importance of the country’s device makers – in their world-leading home market and, increasingly, round the world – is a major headache for the CDMA giant. They are growing up with their own well-known suppliers, and now they are following the trend to vertical integration which is reducing the size of Qualcomm’s addressable market alarmingly.

Of course it wins as well as loses – it may see Samsung increasingly replacing Snapdragon with Exynos in the high end Galaxy models, but in some midrange handsets it has seized slots from Intel/Infineon. However, that pattern threatens to push  Qualcomm down into a midmarket bloodbath where its margins and level of quality will not survive. It needs the premium models, and those are where the vendors are increasingly prepared to invest in their own designs.

That will make it urgent for Qualcomm to expand into other markets where it can harness its engineering resources to steal a march on rivals; and to continue to form Chinese alliances of its own, to broaden its relationships and routes to market, as well as its access to technologies and manufacturing capacity. Intel has been active in this regard, particularly with its stakes in Rockchip – which is making a customized version of Intel’s first integrated smartphone SoC, SoFIA, for China – and in Spreadtrum, one of Qualcomm’s key modem challengers.

The San Diego firm will be hoping Intel does not get closer to Leadcore too. Intel has a history of cooperation with Xiaomi’s new best friend, including patent cross-licensing agreements and an alliance with Intel unit Wind River focused on Android chipsets. Intel will suffer too from the squeezing of the high end merchant smartphone chip sector, but it has far less to lose than Qualcomm, of course, since it scarcely got started in the market. Its best way to redress that balance somewhat, as the segment commoditizes, is to forge the ties with Chinese partners that will always be hard for Qualcomm to make.