Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 May 2015

Redrawing the maps – Apple buys Coherent, Nokia Here may go soon

Mapping is integral to the mobile user experience, which nowadays doesn’t only live on the handset. With cars and laptops increasingly becoming mobile devices, maps are no longer used solely to navigate from A to B. They are portals to business interactions and advertising, as well as the foundation for many app-plugins that contextual location.

Even takeout-ordering apps need a map these days, as well as access to the increasingly advanced functionality that supports them. As such, it isn’t surprising to see Apple make another big play to bolster its own mapping app, and for the protracted bidding war for Nokia’s Here to drag on.

This week, Apple has confirmed that it is acquiring the San Francisco based Coherent Navigation, but hasn’t explained why – giving its customary “Apple buys smaller technology companies from time to time, and we generally do not discuss our purpose or plans,” response.

Nonetheless, the prime focus of the buy will be to position Apple Maps as a viable application, following its debacle of a launch and the damage to the app’s reputation. Trying to dethrone the incumbent Google with such a poorly received app was a disastrous plan in 2012, and to this day, Apple Maps still has to compete with Google Maps as the native mapping application on iOS – such is the perceived quality of Apple’s own maps.

ComScore figures put Google Maps usage on iOS as twice that of Apple Maps, a ratio of 2:1, despite users having to download the app onto Apple’s iOS. This is almost certainly the impetus behind the acquisition – not that Apple is confirming why it bought in, and whether this was for products or just an acqui-hire.

Thankfully, its logo no longer instructs users to leave a bridge and try to vertically merge with the freeway below (such was the apparent level of attention to detail, as well as the poor route-planning that became an internet sensation at Apple’s expense), and anecdotally at least, the app is reasonably usable these days. With Siri integration, it isn’t too painful an experience, but the combination of Google Now and Google Maps on Android is hard to beat.

This is why Apple will be acquiring Coherent, as the company tries to improve the quality (objective and subjective) of its app. Coherence was known to be working on High Integrity GPS (iGPS), which combines the standard GPS satellite positioning data with information from low-earth orbit data communications satellites to provide more precise location data.

The first mentions of iGPS seem to trace back to a joint Iridium and Boeing press release, announcing the success of the iGPS system used by the US Naval Research Laboratory in 2009 – with Coherent Navigation mentioned at the bottom, as a project partner. In the tests, the iGPS system was used by moving vehicles to gather positional information while the traditional GPS link was being jammed.

“When a military GPS receiver is jammed, it cannot obtain a position fix, and movement only makes the situation worse,” said David Whelan, Boeing’s then Integrated Defense Systems chief scientist. “Even from a cold start, it took only minutes for the High Integrity GPS-aided receiver, in a moving vehicle, to receive the GPS signal while being jammed. Without assistance from High Integrity GPS, a position fix would never have been obtained.”

So being able to term Apple Maps military-grade has obvious appeal, but Coherent’s history since that release is tricky to trace. Now that the news of the buy has been confirmed, the Coherent website simply redirects to Apple, and even dating the acquisition is problematic.

Scraping LinkedIn, Coherent cofounders William Bencze and Brett Ledvina joined Apple in April, but CEO Paul Lego was brought inside Apple in January. Now reunited (if they were ever truly separated), the Coherent team is part of the location-related projects, with only Lego of the three confirming his direct involvement with Apple Maps itself.

Coherent is the latest known acquisition that focuses on mapping. Apple has previously bought Broadmap (geographical data analysis and management service, December 2013), Embark (public transit route planner, August 2013), Hopstop (public transit route planner, July 2013), Locationary (crowdsourced locational and business data, July 2013), Pin Drop (map tagging, November 2014), and WiFiSlam (indoor WiFi-based location system, around $20m, March 2013).

The iGPS system will help augment the current GPS systems, adding to the familiar systems that leverage the cell-tower and WiFi access point. Other tweaks to the platform include adding TripAdvisor and Booking.com to the existing Yelp reviews, a change implemented last month in order to increase the likelihood of pushing accurate information to Apple Maps users.

Nokia’s Here bidding war heats up:

Elsewhere in the mobile mapping sphere, the hidden bidding war for Nokia’s Here mapping division has apparently escalated to $4bn, with one bloc comprising German automakers Audi, BMW and Mercedes-Benz allegedly falling off of the pace. This looks to be a significant write-off for Nokia, given the $8.1bn it spent on acquiring Navteq in 2008 – the basis of Here.

The main rivals are Chinese web-giant Baidu, ride-sharing application Uber, and investors Apax Partners on one hand, bidding against another rather similar group, comprised of Chinese web-giant Tencent, Chinese mapping and telematics business NavInfo, and Swedish investment firm EQT Partners.

In that three-way race for Here, all the parties have definite interests in acquiring the well-regarded mapping platform, as Nokia seeks to recoup some of the $17.45bn it expects to pay to acquire Alcatel-Lucent.

According to Bloomberg, Microsoft has offered to buy a minority stake, and US private-equity firms Hellman & Friedman, Silver Lake Management, and Thoma Bravo are also in the running, according to its sources. Previously, Alibaba and Facebook have been linked to the deal, but the volume of apparently interested parties shows the appeal that a developed mapping platform can generate in this mobile world. Apple remains convinced that acquisitions and development will win this race.